Skip to content

New Member, looking for my first car...1.0 or 1.4?

Featured Replies

Hey Everyone! :-)

New to the site, I'm 19 and passed my driving test in March. I've been looking for a Mk4 (6N) Polo for my first car. Ideally, I want to spend about £1000, but it would be a bonus if I could find something cheaper. I'm visiting dealers when I can, and keep checking auto trader, but am just debating whether I want to go for a 1.0 or a 1.4.

I've got an insurance quote of £1,700 for a 1.0...and using comparison websites, the cheapest reliable quote I could get was about £2,100. I just wanted to get some opinions on how much of a difference their is performance wise between the two cars, and what might be my best option. I'm a large build, so a 1.4 would give me a smoother and better ride, but would a 1.0 be powerful enough for me to use as a first car? I'm only going to do occassional motorway driving, and the money I'd gain going for the cheaper to insure model, I could use for petrol and anything I need to do to it...however, I'm just worried the 1.0 won't give me enough power going up a hill or in situations where I want to get up to speed quickly, i.e. on a motorway, if I've got three other adults in the car.

Am I better going for the 1.0 and being able to use the money I save for other things, or would the extra money I would need to spend to insure on a 1.4 be worth it?

Any comments and help would be greatly appreciated,

Cheers,

Mark

Edited by Mark VW

  • Replies 45
  • Views 2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Hi mate, have you tried churchill for insurance?

Everyone goes on about there crap, at the end of the day, that was the cheapest one i found and all insurance is a con. And the comparison sites are even worse. I'm 17, and i pay £1700 for a 1.4 6n2 which i thought was expensive so £2100 for a 19 is awful imo.

That might give you even more money to play with.

As for the engine, all boys are the same, once you get a car its fast. For about a month, then you want a new one, so if i was you, i would the most powerful car you could afford. As in 1.4 over a 1.0.

Thats my personal opinion anyway, have you tried test driving either of them?

Charlie

  • Author

Hey, thanks for your reply. Haven't been able to test drive either of them yet...it's awkward as I wouldn't be able to test drive one from a private seller, and I haven't found many at local dealers.

In a perfect world, I would like to have a 1.4, I just want to be able to afford to run it and have enough money to spend on other things. The £2,100 was just using gocompare.com, and Swinton was the second quote from the top. It was through Swinton...and Zenith, that I got the quote of £1,700 for the 1.0. My Dad had been trying to get quotes for me and was coming up with more expensive ones.

Tomorrow afternoon when I'm free, I'm going to try and phone Zenith again and see what quote they'd do me for a 1.4.

If I could buy a 1.4 L or CL for about £1,000 and then get a quote of about £1,800 I'd be ok. Is it a lot better to phone the company rather than using comparison websites?

Thanks again,

seriously mate it would be a good idea to try churchill. just before i started driving they quoted me £1200 for a 1998 1.4 6n. they were by far the cheapest for me and my parents and quite a few of my mates aswell.

Yeh you should just do it for a few companies on their own on the internet, those comparison sites are such bullshit its unreal.

  • Author

Ok, thanks a lot. I'll have a look at the churchill site tonight, and then give them a call as well tomorrow to see if they could give me an idea of a quote for the 1.4.

Again, I can have a look myself too...but would there be a difference between the 1.4 L and 1.4 CL models in how much the insurance costs?

I've driven a 1.0 mk3 (model b4 the one your interested in) and it really had nothing to give when you do need to overtake, or pull out of a junction quickly, the 6n (refered to as a mk4 on here) has got a newer version of the 1.0 but i cant see it being much different power wise...

...my first car was a 1.4 6n and that was plenty for me, it wont set the world alight by any means, but it copes easily on the motorway and if you drop it down a gear or two it will overtake with ease...

...in terms of insurance you will without doubt save quite a bit by going for the 1.0 but in my opinion the lack of much grunt will become tiresome, i bought my 1.4 when i was 17 and insured it for the first year on my own policy for £1300 with directline fully comp, and eventually got it down to £785 by the time i turned 19. (i hear quinn and churchill are fairly cheap too)

As mentioned if your not doing motorway driving and overtaking then go for the 1.0 as you'll save on insurance, but if you want to be able to cope easy with motorways/hills/overtaking then go for the 1.4 and shop a bit more for insurance :-D

dont think theres any difference between CL and L for insurance, but do try to find a CL cos you get rear headrests and electric windows amongst a few other things, and upon reflection i wouldve gone for CL over the L i chose

Edited by blindy88

I'll say one thing about Churchill they don't like modified cars much, i'm with them and they said I gota be 25 before i'm allowed alloys on it for the insurance i'm over 25 but must warn you there fuckin tight. As soon as my renewal up i'm going with HIC they specialise in Vdubs and modified cars.

  • Author

Ok, thanks guys...that sounds promising then. So I'll have a look at Churchill, Direct Line, Quinn and HIC later and see what it comes up with.

Blindy88, I'd love to get it for £1,300...off to the gym now, but when I get back I'll go onto the Direct Line site at then let you know what it comes out as. After getting the quote on their site, is it worth phoning them up after to see if they can bring it down? Is there anything I could say to them that would knock a bit off?

The 1.4 CL does sound good, and I have seen some on Auto Trader in the sort of price range I'm looking at. I'll just have to keep my fingers crossed and hope a car comes up fairly locally and that I can get a decent insurance quote.

Thank you, will let you know how I get on later.

check out the for sale section on here!

Ok, thanks guys...that sounds promising then. So I'll have a look at Churchill, Direct Line, Quinn and HIC later and see what it comes up with.

Blindy88, I'd love to get it for £1,300...off to the gym now, but when I get back I'll go onto the Direct Line site at then let you know what it comes out as. After getting the quote on their site, is it worth phoning them up after to see if they can bring it down? Is there anything I could say to them that would knock a bit off?

The 1.4 CL does sound good, and I have seen some on Auto Trader in the sort of price range I'm looking at. I'll just have to keep my fingers crossed and hope a car comes up fairly locally and that I can get a decent insurance quote.

Thank you, will let you know how I get on later.

Well i got a loada quotes online, and i mean loads, for a few diferent models including the polo, and then rang up for a quote, i mentioned that i had been looking online, so he checked i wasnt lieing, and said "ok well seeing as youve got most of your quotes online, il still include the 10% online discount even though youve rang" which was pretty awesome, 10% of £1300 is obv £130 so defo worth a go :thumbsup:

Don't use comparison sites, don't get a 1.0

Avoid churchill

If your under 25 they wont cover you with ANY mods.. No wheels / suspension exhaust.

And if you were REALLY unlucky... the idiot on the end of the phone will say "oh yeh that will be fine, just call us to let us know when you have them on" only when you do phone,...another person will tell you that churchill dont cover anyone under 25 for mods.

Roll on june :?

welcome to club polo matey.

£1700 is shit the bed expensive for insurance. I'd definately do some more searching before deciding who to give your hard earned cash to. Club members get a 10% discount with Adrian flux insurance as well as discounts at many other comapnies and all it costs is £5 a year.

Car wise, the mk4 1.0 is slow, very slow with a 0-60 time of 17.6 seconds or there abouts. As mentioned, they're not good for pulling out of busy junctions or overtaking on normal roads but can handle motorway runs at 80mph although they do drink fuel! If you can afford to go to a 1.4, do it as the little bit of extra power will come in handy and the potential for tuning it later on is there.

Jon.

  • Author

Ahh cool...thanks guys, I didn't realise I'd get as many replies this quickly, it seems like a really friendly and useul site and club too...I'm glad I joined.

Back from the gym...

Right, so you're all pretty much saying the same thing...the 1.4 would be the best option, as long as i can find a quote cheap enough. I could manage paying the £1,700 a year, so if I can use your advice to get it down even more on a 1.4, that would work out well and I'd have the car I really want.

I'll avoid churchill then because I can imagine myself buying a set of alloys eventually, and no doubt my car enthusiast uncle will persuade me to get something else too at some point. I'll try Direct Line and Adrian Flux's websites first, and see what comes up.

Thank you again, hopefully once I get my polo I'll definately become a member anyway, :-)

  • Author

Hey, I went on the Direct Line website, and for a 1997 1.4 CL I've got a premium of £1,982. That works out as £175 for 9 months after the initial deposit. Considering, the quote I got for the 1.0 was £1,720 previously and £171 after the initial deposit (and there's only £50 between the two deposits), that works out a lot better than I was expecting! I guess the other one I looked at had a higher interest rate...thanks for the advice on that one!

Do you think if I phoned up, they'd be able to knock it down a bit or would they stick to that online price?

I would have done my pass plus by the time I get the car, and I'll probably be a member on here too...I guess I could ask if that would lower it.

Edited by Mark VW

Hey, I went on the Direct Line website, and for a 1997 1.4 CL I've got a premium of £1,982. That works out as £175 for 9 months after the initial deposit. Considering, the quote I got for the 1.0 was £1,720 previously and £171 after the initial deposit (and there's only £50 between the two deposits), that works out a lot better than I was expecting! I guess the other one I looked at had a higher interest rate...thanks for the advice on that one!

Do you think if I phoned up, they'd be able to knock it down a bit or would they stick to that online price?

I would have done my pass plus by the time I get the car, and I'll probably be a member on here too...I guess I could ask if that would lower it.

give it a go mate why not, ul probs get the online discount if u ask nicely enough lol, and maybe tell a little porky or two, i.e. yea its kept in a locked garage lol, ask if you can increase your excess, sometimes its set at £500 wi directline, but theres a chance you could get a voluntary excess and thatl bring you are premium down a bit, maybe put a mileage limit on you are policy, say you only use it for work and the odd trip to the shops therefore about 6000miles a year, (bare in mind this isnt perfectly legit) but i had a cap of 6000 n managed a 14000 n had to claim after a lil accident and they still paid out, so its totally up to u... :-D

1. online discount

2. kept in a garage

3. voluntary excess

4. mileage limit

i spent ages lookin for cheap insurance, hence why i keep commenting on you are topic lol

1.0l ain't that bad, mine's awesome - it's like a little go kart :)

Try and avoid Swinton too if possible, they fucked me around big time with my home insurance

1.0 litres are until you have more Sian :lol:

But tbf, in a MK3 they ain't that bad, or not as bad as you would think - Mines got slight poke and loves getting ragged

I would however not own a 1 in a MK4 :thumbsdown: That's just my view though

Edited by D16RRT

True haha!

I have my days where I consider an engine swap and other days where I just rag the shit out of it and drive round with a massive grin on my face.

Guess it depends on the car as the MK3 is quite light.

I got £1,100 for my first car at 18, 1.3 litre Mk2. Insured to drive any car third party too.

I got £1,100 for my first car at 18, 1.3 litre Mk2. Insured to drive any car third party too.

Who's that with? I cant find anyone that will let me drive other cars until I'm 21 at the youngest! :lol: £1700 is really expensive for a 1.0! Youd be better getting a 1.4 for definate, 1.0s are shit slow :lol: If you can get the insurance anyway....you tried tesco or admiral? they are good for me, am 19 too :)

  • Author

Hey, thanks for the replies.

Have been looking at a few different sites for quotes. So far, the best one is still the Direct Line quote I mentioned of £1,982...but obviously, paying monthly with the interest it will amount to £2,141. I phoned up to see if there was anything they could do to drop the quote and they said that was their best price.

I'm stuck...

I've also done a quote ith Direct Line for a 1.0, and it's come out as £1,712...but paid monthly with interest £1,850.

For the 1.0, after the deposit I'd be paying £151 for the next ten installments.

For the 1.4, after the deposit I'd be paying £175 for the next ten installments.

Is the £24 difference each month worth having the 1.4?

Thanks,

Mark

deffinately mate

  • Author

Ok, yea that's what I've been sort of thinking.

I'll keep looking on Auto Trader then and see what I can find, and then nearer the time I could always mention to Zenith, who I got my first quote with, what Direct Line have quoted me and to see whether they might give me a lower quote.

Just have to keep my fingers crossed that I'll find a decent car for sale fairly locally, thank you for everyone's advice so far! :-)

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.