Skip to content

Fixed or Reclining back bucket seats in a road used MK5 Polo

Fixed or Reclining back bucket seats 25 members have voted

  1. 1. All things considered (price, comfort, practicality, looks) would you rather have fixed or reclining back bucket seats in your road used car

    • Fixed back
      20%
      5
    • Reclining back
      80%
      20

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

Alrite people, just wanna see what people think about this.

I am going to be stripping out the rear of my car (just the seats) and then false flooring it leaving just the front two seats.

Will be using 3 point harnesses, but don't know if I should get fixed or reclining seats.

I never and will never use the car on a track, and price is a big factor in my decision.

Been looking at the Cobra Monaco and clubman type seats in particular.

What are peoples opinions and what would you go for. Pro's and con's please of both.

Cheers

  • Replies 12
  • Views 2.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

well harnesses are a waste of time on reclining buckets as you need the seat to be rigid so they stay tight.

when it comes to fixed back buckets DONT get anything steel framed as it will just kill your back and after a while you can feel the tubes through the thin foam,

so to round it off id say a fibreglass shelled fixed bucket is your best bet for comfort and safety

oh and make sure its a side mounted one as the base mount ones look gash and you can never get them low enough

  • Author

I always thought the bass mounted ones sat lower, because they are just on subframes like a normal car seat is? Side mounts tend to make the seat sit up more on stilts don't they? Or am I totally wrong? I want the seats to slide back and forth.

Why would the steel be more uncomfortable than fibreglass? Does the glass allow some flex or something so it isn't totally solid?

the fibreglass is like a shell which is moulded to hug you, so in conjunction with harnesses you are held in with you spine in the right shape resulting in what is actually a really comfy seat.

the steel framed seats are fabric stretched over a steel frame so when you sit in it the fabric stretches and bows out the back so then you have the steel bars at the sides on your shoulders and hips, not fun trust me.

also they arent as safe in an accident as they can bend and or snap! hence why all FIA approved race seats are fibreglass, carbon or kevlar shell seats.

as for the side mount thing i guess if you want the seats to slide then side mounts will be possible,normally they help the seat to go lower because you can lower the base of the seat til it touches the floor because nothing is crossing the base of the seat holding the mounts together. you will have to attach it to a slide mechanism from cobra/corbeau etc tho so it wont go as low.

so your looking at two options:

1, reclining buckets on base mount frames with standard seat belts

2, fixed back fibreglass seats with side mounts and sliders with harnesses

anything else i wouldnt consider safe or comfy

  • Author

okay I guess I'll have to re-think then. The buckets I was looking at were 330 for 2, but I think I'm going to have to add another 200 to that now,

it depends on the seat really, the ones in my g40 are fixed steel frame ones and three hour motorway drives are fine, doesn't do my back in at all really. But it just depends on the seats. I'd get fibreglass ones if possible as they are more likely to be comfier and they look better! I just got mine because they were given to me for very cheap.

side mount ones generally sit lower because they don't have all the subframe gubbins underneath them. Some aftermarket subframes I've seen make buckets sit higher up than the standard seats and look very uncomfortable.

In a daily driver I'd got for reclining seats and not bother with harnesses either, they'd just get annoying. They also restrict your movement which makes things like reversing a pain because you have to take them off to turn around to see behind. I'd never have them in a daily driver.

  • Author
it depends on the seat really, the ones in my g40 are fixed steel frame ones and three hour motorway drives are fine, doesn't do my back in at all really. But it just depends on the seats. I'd get fibreglass ones if possible as they are more likely to be comfier and they look better! I just got mine because they were given to me for very cheap.

side mount ones generally sit lower because they don't have all the subframe gubbins underneath them. Some aftermarket subframes I've seen make buckets sit higher up than the standard seats and look very uncomfortable.

In a daily driver I'd got for reclining seats and not bother with harnesses either, they'd just get annoying. They also restrict your movement which makes things like reversing a pain because you have to take them off to turn around to see behind. I'd never have them in a daily driver.

Also with regards to movement being restricted, I can imagine harnesses not even letting you lean forward to get a better view when pulling out of a junction.

Yer as far as I'm aware, if you can lean forward to see at a junction.....your not in tightly enough! :lol:

me and a mate went to GTi international in his golf with fixed buckets, worst ride iv ever had! we ended up sitting on cusions it was that painful! get the reclining buckets with standard seatbelts, they look the nuts and look so much more comfy!

Jon

  • Author
me and a mate went to GTi international in his golf with fixed buckets, worst ride iv ever had! we ended up sitting on cusions it was that painful! get the reclining buckets with standard seatbelts, they look the nuts and look so much more comfy!

Jon

what make were the seats?

me and a mate went to GTi international in his golf with fixed buckets, worst ride iv ever had! we ended up sitting on cusions it was that painful! get the reclining buckets with standard seatbelts, they look the nuts and look so much more comfy!

Jon

what make were the seats?

cobra monaco's and id warn anyone against them... also depends on your size to what seats to go for, if your a big lad then youll find it had to fit into buckets

Jon

RST recaros FTW cheap and look better then brightcoloured bucketseats

  • Author
me and a mate went to GTi international in his golf with fixed buckets, worst ride iv ever had! we ended up sitting on cusions it was that painful! get the reclining buckets with standard seatbelts, they look the nuts and look so much more comfy!

Jon

what make were the seats?

cobra monaco's and id warn anyone against them... also depends on your size to what seats to go for, if your a big lad then youll find it had to fit into buckets

Jon

Cobra Monaco's were the ones I was looking at because they look so nice.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.