Skip to content

Bad experience with garages (sorry, a bit long)

Featured Replies

I'm gonna explain what exactly has happened to my car in the last month and was wondering what people thought about where I stand with the garage, or just how badly I've been messed about... I've got little experience with mechanics but this seems unreal...

April 18th - gearbox went on my GTi, took it to my local "gearbox specialists" and they offered to "FULLY recon with all new parts" for £665. I agreed to get the work done and got them to put a new SACHS clutch in while they were at it.

April 25th - Finally get the car back, but after driving it around just one day i notice that it's rattling really loud from the transmission area, the rattling dissapears when i let the clutch up but not when in neutral. Spoke to the mechanic who said "it can't be anything i've done it's all new parts".

April 26th - A timing kit and waterpump i had ordered myself previously arrives, so when i take the car back for them to look at the clutch, i get them to do the timing and pump for an extra £100.

April 28th - Phone the garage and they tell me the clutch is perfectly fine and there was no noise. The timing kit was fitted fine but a seal on the gearbox has "failed" and all the oil has leaked out! How does that happen? That has to be something they did/didn't do when recon'ing the box surely? This was the last time I saw the car.

After numerous ignored phonecall attempts - it just rings and rings and rings - i called them with number withheld and someone answered. They said they're having "electrical trouble" and will call me back. No call back for days - i keep calling them but nothing. Basically I spoke to someone a few days ago who said they've replaced loads of sensors and now he's taking the timing belts off and "putting them back on properly"?!?! They were supposed to call me yesterday to tell me whether I'd have the car for the weekend or not, no call. They weren't answering when I phoned them!!! :x

This does sound proper dodgy... Do you think maybe they've totalled the engine by starting the car with the timing set up wrong and are just trying to cover it up? This is the second bank hol without by beloved GTi :-( - anyone got any ideas/advice???

  • Replies 31
  • Views 2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

cant you pop down to the garage and see what is actually going on ?

I work 30 miles away and leave before they open and get home after they close. I'm going to try and get up there today, but they only work Saturdays if they feel like it. I've booked tuesday off so will get up there then.

umh, thats you best option in my opinion at least you can see whats going of and question everything, good luck

Yea... I suppose. Everything seems to have gone wrong wrong since the fitted the timing kit... I'm pretty much gonna flat refuse to pay for any of the work since i took it back the second time. Actually, i think it went wrong when i decided to take the car there in the first place :(

id have it looked at closely when you get it back aswell just incase :thumbsup:

that sounds propper shitty and dodgy...what garage is it...I'm from SoWal :).

ask them for a copy of the work and so on...threaten them with trading standards they should soon change their ways ha ha.

good luck with it anyway buddy :)

Dude i own my own vw specialists garage, and what they have done to you is totally unacceptable!

I hate to say it but i think you are being ripped off. The gearbox repair is way to expensive and if he has fully re conditioned it then why has it leaked oil?

With regards to the cambelt, they are so easy to replace its unreal!

If i was you i would go to trading standards and when you finally get to pick the car up threaten him with legal action! People like that give good mechanics a bad name!

Snap^^

Did they have horses roped up outside drinking water from a wooden bath? (cowboys)

Over 2 weeks to recon the gearbox too? (not even good by the sounds of it) is a major case of lazyitis :-(

New parts are all good, but when not fitted properly they are as useless as fucked parts, that excuse "cant be anything I've done, it was all new parts" is pathetic

yeah cowboys, attitude and things happening are always the sign of a bad garage, a seal might have gone, it can happen, as I'm sure they say, but if it happened at my garage they would fix the problem, and be apologetic about it, and pritty much tell me how it is

they sound like they are taking the piss, as garages can do

give trading standards a ring, they are very helpful people and can guide you in the right direction, I've rung them up a few times and they always give me the information I'm looking for

08454 04 05 06

http://www.tradingstandards.gov.uk/advice/index.cfm

it always gets me how to be a doctor, vet, plumber, electrician you need to get certificates, qualifications etc

but to open up a car garage, all you need is a set of spanners

the law needs changing, and a "blabla approved mechanic" system put into effect, very similar to an MOT, the shit garages will become clear, and give you a clue on who is good and who are cocknoses

infact we should get a "good garage" post up, i can give a few in the Huddersfield area, and I'm sure others can in other areas, it would save problems like above!

Wow, cheers for the replies guys... At least I know for certain that its been total crud service and I'm not just exaggerating. Thanks for the trading standards info DKnight, I'll def give them a call. I'll post back with what happens next...

In the meantime... I can't believe its a sunny bank hol and i still don't have the carrrrr!!!!!! :(

cheers peeps

EDIT: The garage is M&M Auto's in Merthyr Tydfil :ninja:

Edited by wesleymatsell

That sound well dodgy...as its been said earlier, paying them a visit would probably be the best bet and DKnight theres some wicked garages in Huddersfield...Just had to say it! :smile:

Update: Spoke to the garage this morning. Didn't say why they never got back to me last week, I think it's probably because they didn't want to give me any bad news...

The mechanic told me the timing kit was fitted incorrectly and also said that because the car has been sat around for a month the battery is flat and the immobiliser now needs to be recoded??? A mate of his is going to look at it "afterwork" today. I've had enough of this garages sketchy dealings so I spoke to trading standards and my local VW dealership. VW said they recommend I take it to a VW specialist / dealer to have the fault diagnosed properly and then repaired properly too. Trading standards said the dodgy garage are liable and will compensate me by paying for any work that needs to be done as a result of their incompetence.

Just need to take a trip up to the garage to arrange it all...

Sorry if this just sounds like a rant - so fed up............ :x

£665 isn't that a lot of money for a local garage to do that, wouldn't you pay the roughly the same at VW :?

Good luck with it all dude :thumbsup:

£665 isn't that a lot of money for a local garage to do that, wouldn't you pay the roughly the same at VW :?

Good luck with it all dude :thumbsup:

Cheers :thumbsup:

It seemed about average with all the quotes I got. It was like £1100 from VW, that was without the new clutch. I've got a 12 month / 1200 mile warranty too.

Mate, I would get your car out of there asap before they do more damage. Make sure you keep all the receipts they have given you for the work. Also if possible have someone accompany you to the garage if you go for further correspondance. A witness is always favourable in this sort of dispute.

It all sounds really dodgy and if it is as described then like the trading standards the garage is obligated to compensate. Depending on how far your willing to take it you can take legal action on the breach of several statutes. The first being The Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982, but you could also imply that there is a case for Misrepresentation. For misrepresenation you need to establish whether they hadnt infact changed the seal in your gearbox and told you they have.

They are most definatly obligated to compensate for the hassle of all of this. If you go about it the right way then they should reemberse you for the work and should pay for the investigation at your VW dealer and the repairs that they make. All depending on the damage in the Gearbox of the damage that has been done due to the incorrect timing. What cowboys, they need closing down!

Dude, they dont loose there codings on the immobilizers if the battery goes flat! That sounds like they are covering up for something!

I have heard horror stories of dodgy garages selling parts off of peolpes cars then telling the customer that there car has a problem and getting the work out of it!

OK, another update -

Went to the garage this morning having spoken to trading standards. They were unbelievable - I could write a VERY long list of crap they spoke and things they did to demonstrate exactly how incompetent they are!!!

EDIT: Just to add we were arguing back and forth, probably for about 45 mins about what they had done, why they never contacted me, etc.etc. I properly wrapped them up, and when I droped the "I've spoken to xxxxxx who is a Senior Fair Trading Officer at Trading Standards" bombshell they didn't have a leg to stand on... /EDIT

Basically they paid to get the car to the nearest VW dealership and will pay for all work done to the car which can be attributed to problems they caused - i.e. the timing kit being put on wrong. While I was there they told me they even took the car to the dealership themselves a few weeks ago to get a sensor on it checked - when i got to the dealers they told me the car had in fact been in - no sensors were checked however, VW just confirmed that there was "no pressure in any of the cylinders" - I think thats what he said - which would indicate the timing was out. So yea, looks like I won out.

Hopefully there won't be much trouble when it comes to them forking out for it all - if there is, trading standards step in and i don't have to do anything! So looks like i get VW to give the car are good going over all at someone else's cost. I really hope that garage closes down!

Cheers for all the advice peeps!

Edited by wesleymatsell

OK, another update -

Went to the garage this morning having spoken to trading standards. They were unbelievable - I could write a VERY long list of crap they spoke and things they did to demonstrate exactly how incompetent they are!!!

EDIT: Just to add we were arguing back and forth, probably for about 45 mins about what they had done, why they never contacted me, etc.etc. I properly wrapped them up, and when I droped the "I've spoken to xxxxxx who is a Senior Fair Trading Officer at Trading Standards" bombshell they didn't have a leg to stand on... /EDIT

Basically they paid to get the car to the nearest VW dealership and will pay for all work done to the car which can be attributed to problems they caused - i.e. the timing kit being put on wrong. While I was there they told me they even took the car to the dealership themselves a few weeks ago to get a sensor on it checked - when i got to the dealers they told me the car had in fact been in - no sensors were checked however, VW just confirmed that there was "no pressure in any of the cylinders" - I think thats what he said - which would indicate the timing was out. So yea, looks like I won out.

Hopefully there won't be much trouble when it comes to them forking out for it all - if there is, trading standards step in and i don't have to do anything! So looks like i get VW to give the car are good going over all at someone else's cost. I really hope that garage closes down!

Cheers for all the advice peeps!

well played mate! need more people like you that persist and get these garages forking out for the shit work they've done.

make sure you get a full service and everything you can :p

Yaa well done mate takes guts! but then again your car is your pride and joy and you trust other people to take care of it.

good news then matey, hope it gets sorted

:( not good pal

I think you should name and shame this garage to warn peeps who live in your area!!

:( not good pal

I think you should name and shame this garage to warn peeps who live in your area!!

Yea, I already did - M & M Auto Repairs - Unit 4, Pant Industrial Estate, Dowlais, Merthyr Tydfil

It's so frustrating, they seemed like really genuine people at the start. I just can't believe they thought they could lie so much and seriously think they could get away with it. They must just assume everyone is as stupid and clueless as them.

When I asked for a receipt, or written log of all the work done on the car, he handed me a jotted note on a ripped scrap of paper. When I said "What's that?!?!" and explained I want it itemised and signed on headed paper he said the boy who prints of the computer is on holidays. "No-one apart from him knows how to print off the computer" - so I made do with a hand written work log with the following written on it (I'll type it case sensetive):

TImmIG BeLT CHAGED

RELAceD CRANKSHAFT SenceR

The guy at VW laughed.

Now I'm not making fun of the spelling at all, some people are dyslexic and perfectly intelligent - it was just another glimpse into this guys retarded world!

argh, I'm gonna rant again.....

I'll post an update as it starts to resolve.

Edited by wesleymatsell

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.