Skip to content

MOT failure... not happy.

Featured Replies

Okay, so i noticed the other day i needed an MOT, and the closest garage is a toyota one, and i'm not all too bothered about getting it to the nearest VW which is a fair bit further away...

anyway... took it in yesterday morning, went to work... then this morning i got a phone call saying it faild on front brake hoses and a slightly loose steering wheel (my fault, forgot to tighten it right back up)

but thing is, they just went straight in and replaced the hoses and tightened my steering wheel, and they've charged me almost £90 for the pleasure... on top of the £54 MOT.

now, i went in earlier and asked what they'd done, and i kicked off about them not asking me if i wanted the repairs doing, and they must know they're in the wrong cos they knocked 20 quid off the bill straight away, but that still leaves me 70 quid poorer than i would have been.

have they broke the law?????????????????

cos surely if i wanted my hoses replaced by them, they'd have to ask me first right???

Edited by arron0909

  • Replies 37
  • Views 2.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

if you didnt ask for it, then dont pay it. they have already as good as admitted they were in the wrong by knocking £20 off the bill

  • Author

i said to them i'm not gonna pay it...

they argued that i was getting a 'deal' because as soon as i would have taken it home to repair it, i'd have had to retest it anyway for another £54? is that true?

Edited by arron0909

a retest shouldnt cost the full £50. the garage i use dont even charge for a retest, unless the car has major defects.

i think the garage are trying to scare you. go speak to citizens advise and trading stds. play hardball with the garage! they are 100% in the wrong

heres some info on mots

http://www.motester.co.uk/mot-retest.html

Edited by g40jon

There is no way you should have to pay for work you haven’t authorized to be done

Pretty sure a retest is a partial amount of the original. But definitely try and speak to the manager of the place as they haven't acted fairly. My car failed last week on 5 things, 4 of which I fixed myself in like 20 mins and the garage did their bit and the retest was free.

the max they can charge for a partial retest is 50%

Most decent garages will do it for free if you bring it back within 24 hours.

If you are a member of the AA you can get MOT's for £30.. ;)

But they shouldn't have done the work without your consent. so Ask them to take the parts off and you will fit your own :)

I would insist they remove the parts to prove a point, if it means going elsewhere for a re-test your no worse off than paying for work. Let them 'loosen' your steering wheel. And they wont be able to re-fit your old brake pipes... so that will have to be a freebie!

  • Author

right guys thanks for your help here... although now i'm angrier than ever about it.

i told my dad about how much of a set of pricks they were being down at the garage, and my dad actually gave me a bollocking for being silly and thinking i know everything about cars... and he's been using that garage for years and was pissed off that i'd annoyed them.

so anyway, i went to work, and when i got back, my car was sat outside my house instead of being down at the garage, cos my dad went down and paid the full bill and brought it home, and now says i have to pay him the money or i'll get kicked out of the house lol.... am pissed off cos i was gonna go back today and tell them how it is, as i've reported them to VOSA and trading standards who say they'll investigate.

how much FUCKING HASSLE can an MOT be!!!!

Good on you for reporting them. They can't do anything to the car without asking for your permission first. That's certainly against trading standards.

If the car failed the MOT, then usually you have 7 days for the necessary work to be carried out and then you pay something stupid like £10 for a retest at the same garage. I'm always wary of some of these garages.

My Citroen Xsara failed it's MOT at the Citroen garage on handbrake and both front suspension bushes, which was going to cost £700 to put right. Took it to a different test centre, who passed it with flying colours and then sold it with 12 months MOT.

My Polos have normally failed the MOT every 2 years, but they always phone me up and we discuss the work that needs carrying out and then I either agree to pay them to do it or take it home and do it myself.

Stand your ground. You're the one in the right.

man your dad doing that must be anoying, thinking YOU was in the wrong. Your going the right way about it tho, keep it up :D

to be fair, you are being a bit of an arse about it.

£90 sounds good to me when my brother just payed £500 for a couple of slight issues :lol:

Not against the law.

My car failed it's MOT on a front wishbone.

Got the MOT for 40 quid, and then a new wishbone fitted for 40, without asking.

to be fair, you are being a bit of an arse about it.

Not at all, when my cars have failed MOTs the garage phones me up with the issues and we discuss what will happen next.

to be fair, you are being a bit of an arse about it.

How do you work that out???

He's just been conned out of alot of money on repairs and adjustments he could have done himself for free.

it is against the law for the to replace things without you asking,the only way it isnt is if the car has no MOT and then it cant legally be driven away,if the car still has some MOT left on it then you have to authorize the work

right guys thanks for your help here... although now i'm angrier than ever about it.

i told my dad about how much of a set of pricks they were being down at the garage, and my dad actually gave me a bollocking for being silly and thinking i know everything about cars... and he's been using that garage for years and was pissed off that i'd annoyed them.

so anyway, i went to work, and when i got back, my car was sat outside my house instead of being down at the garage, cos my dad went down and paid the full bill and brought it home, and now says i have to pay him the money or i'll get kicked out of the house lol.... am pissed off cos i was gonna go back today and tell them how it is, as i've reported them to VOSA and trading standards who say they'll investigate.

how much FUCKING HASSLE can an MOT be!!!!

to be honest i think your being ridiclous reporting them to vosa......your questioning the validity of the test?

dont be such a knob and talk to the garage,they did the work as they probably would for your dad............it failed and they did the work....ok you could of done it cheaper.....but big deal

fully agree with the above

it cost you what, £70? thats not a lot of money. just deal with it

Fully Disagree with the above.

they should've asked, end of.

  • Author

yeah... thanks for the support people, i feel i'm totally within my rights as a customer to report them...

think about it, they could have replaced all 4 of my tyres, full set of brakes, all bulbs, wipers, suspension etc and charged me a fortune for it all... and i wouldnt have had any say in it!.

to the guys who disagree: yeah i know where you're coming from saying i'm being an 'arse' about it, but tbh I'm not the sort of person who people can walk all over... so i do tend to speak my mind.

anyway, I've got the car back thats all that matters, paid my dad the money back, i wont be going to that garage again and thats the end of the matter as far as i'm concerned.

it is against the law for the to replace things without you asking,the only way it isnt is if the car has no MOT and then it cant legally be driven away,if the car still has some MOT left on it then you have to authorize the work

Actually failing a MOT invalidates any MOT you have left on the car.

But I don't think failures are kept on the database just yet. Only valid certificates. I was worried about that when my Citroen failed and I took it to another place, but they passed it without any knowledge that it had failed somewhere else a few days previously so as long as you have the current MOT you should be fine... at the moment.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.