Skip to content

MOT failure... not happy.

Featured Replies

I dunno, if you use this site you can find out if the car has failed since MOTs were computerised(April 2005):

http://www.motinfo.gov.uk/

  • Replies 37
  • Views 2.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Failures are listed, checked up on my mums saab that was "failed" by a dodgy MOT station and its on the list.

TBH £90 isnt bad for New brake pipes considering the work it actually takes to do, all the new pipes need to be bent into position and flanged etc.

Edited by Cymro

IMO Yes it is fairly cheap work for what they have done. The standard of work maybe really good. Lightening up the steering wheel, not a hard job but still they did it.

The point I think some people are missing here is that they actually did the work without the owners permission.

Now imagine you've saved your money together to actually get the money for the MOT test. Weither they have put a bulb in to allow it to pass and charged you the £1, or they have changed your front tyres and charged you £100. You haven't asked them to do that, so why should you pay?

Everytime i take any car for a MOT if there are any issues with it. They always ask me first before doing any work. I believe this is the way things are meant to be done. I have had MOTs in the past where they have actually put a few bulbs in, adjusted the headlights to correct beam. Little things. and they haven't charged me for doing them. Some people may think that he is just being petty or "an arse". But think how you would feel put in the same situation with only the money for an MOT test to your name.

Not good hey. :sad:

And in conclusion. If they do find things wrong with a car at MOT time they should ask first before carrying out any work. And the owner can decide what they want to do with their car.

Steve

right guys thanks for your help here... although now i'm angrier than ever about it.

i told my dad about how much of a set of pricks they were being down at the garage, and my dad actually gave me a bollocking for being silly and thinking i know everything about cars... and he's been using that garage for years and was pissed off that i'd annoyed them.

so anyway, i went to work, and when i got back, my car was sat outside my house instead of being down at the garage, cos my dad went down and paid the full bill and brought it home, and now says i have to pay him the money or i'll get kicked out of the house lol.... am pissed off cos i was gonna go back today and tell them how it is, as i've reported them to VOSA and trading standards who say they'll investigate.

how much FUCKING HASSLE can an MOT be!!!!

to be honest i think your being ridiclous reporting them to vosa......your questioning the validity of the test?

dont be such a knob and talk to the garage,they did the work as they probably would for your dad............it failed and they did the work....ok you could of done it cheaper.....but big deal

but the thing they should have asked to do the work first. Its like takign a car in for a service and them saying "oh it needs a new engine, lets fit one anyway with asking"

they are in the wrong at the end of the day!! they should have phoned/talked to you first to get permission to carry out the work.

Yes they should of told you, but at the end of the day you goig to have to get it done anyway, so maby they were saving them selfs time by having to book it in at a later date. But yes they should of told you.

Its not the money that would bother me it would be the fact that they did something to my vehicle without my permission. If you've asked them to do an MOT on it and they do something else why should you have to foot the bill?

If you went out for a meal and bought some pasta but they brought you pasta and a pizza you wouldn't just munch the pizza and pay for it because they brought it to you.

sounds to me like they were trying to do you a favour. there was no messing about with retests or stuff, they aint exactly charged the earth. work needed doing anyway. sorted in one swoop :?

sounds to me like they were trying to do you a favour. there was no messing about with retests or stuff, they aint exactly charged the earth. work needed doing anyway. sorted in one swoop :?

this is what i was getting at

it seems like they were being nice and you just threw it back in their faces

oh well, like you said done now. but put yourself in their position

it is against the law for the to replace things without you asking,the only way it isnt is if the car has no MOT and then it cant legally be driven away,if the car still has some MOT left on it then you have to authorize the work

Actually failing a MOT invalidates any MOT you have left on the car.

failing an MOT does not invalidate any remaining MOT. An MOT cannot be revoked.

They should have checked before carring out any work. Assuming they are a main dealer I would speak to them one more time, tell them what you want them to do to (something like you will pay cost for the parts but not the labour), and let them know if you remain unsatisfied you will speak to Toyota UK customer services...they will hate it as they are supposed to be able to deal with customer complaints and (if you offer to pay at least cost for parts) you are not being "unreasonable"

it is against the law for the to replace things without you asking,the only way it isnt is if the car has no MOT and then it cant legally be driven away,if the car still has some MOT left on it then you have to authorize the work

Actually failing a MOT invalidates any MOT you have left on the car.

failing an MOT does not invalidate any remaining MOT. An MOT cannot be revoked.

But failing a MOT means its not road worthy, doesnt matter if the car passed an MOT 6mths ago for example and its logged now.

i did not say it was not roadworthy, I said you can't revoke an MOT so does not invalidate it. It would be a different story if say the car had 6 months MOT, was put in for another test and failed, if you then had an accident the insurance company may not pay out depending on what the car failed on and the circumstances of the accident. But an MOT can't be revoked.

lessons learnt i guess.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.