Skip to content

VW Service or Independent?

Featured Replies

Got my service due, and was wondering where the best place to get this done would be. This is more a case of VW garage vs independent rather than location really. This is my first service on this car as I've had it under a year. It is a 2003 9n 1.2 with 75k miles. The last couple of services have been done at independent garages, so it doesn't have a complete VW record.

My local garage have quoted me around £135 for their service which includes 'brake inspection, filter changes, and visual checks'. VW have quoted me an identical amount for their 'Basic Service'. I'm guessing the VW garage would bite me where it hurts should I need repairs done though whereas the independent would be cheaper. I fully admit to not having much experience with the ins and outs of getting cars serviced - this is only my first car. So any advice would be really appreciated.

Thanks,

Tim

  • Replies 21
  • Views 1.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

If it's just a minor service, might as well go to VW. If there's other stuff needs doing, they'll tell you before they start, then you can decide where to take it for that work.

75k,my 6N2 GTi is only on 25k wowzaaa.VW's basic service is literally an oil and oil filter change plus and inspection.If you're pretty sure it's not going to need anything else i'd go to VW to keep that booked stamped and they'll reccomend anything if it needs replacing etc.Although they will charge an awful lot more than a local garage for any other works,you can always have them service it and take the car to the local garage once VW has diagnosed any problems if any at all.It may be worth looking to see if there is a VW specialist near you.In most cases they offer the prices of a Local gargage with the experience of a dealership.

Brad

Edited by Bradley

Thanks for the advice guys.

Yes...75k...an awful lot of miles! Although when I picked it up it didn't have a single scratch on the paintwork. To this day I can't quite work out how that's possible with that many miles!

Anyway, I've booked it into VW for tomorrow. There were a couple of minor things I wanted doing..ie. cleaning up the brakes to stop them squealing, tightening the clutch pedal/handbrake. Are these small enough to be included in the service (if not already!), or would I be charged extra?!

It's possible they'll tell me I need a new set of suspension bushes, in which case I'd get the work done elsewhere. There's also the issue of whether I try and get the timing chain tensioner checked :? . I'll have a chat about it with one of the staff I guess.

I haven't been able to find a specialist so far. North London...know of anywhere?

Thanks,

Tim

If you have an interest in mechanics, learn to service it yourself :thumbsup:

Those small bits i'd imagine they would charge you extra,not a great deal but i think they would.If not and you're quite comfortable with basic mechanics or if not at all the brakes is a simple job.I'd reccomend getting Haynes manual for your car it'll teach you so much,you'd be able to do those jobs yourself on a saturday or sunday.

Try and catch the mechanic before you go in,otherwise the desk staff write everything down and make sure it's made chargable,dependant on the mechanic if they're decent enough they'll have a quick look for you.Parts like bushes you can get from a place called www.gsfcarparts.com/contact/branches.asp they're really good for Vag parts and at good prices not to mention if you're a member on here you can obtain discount.Not sure on the specialist I'm from the other side of the river,google it maybe.

Brad

75k's isnt alot really

Vw services and prices seem to be overlooked as being pricey

there not much (if any) more expensive than the vw specialist garages.

I have a receipt from a previous owner that paid 68 quid for a oil change and inspection service at 60k...not alot i didnt think

I just paid 198.00 for a full service, brake fluid change, coolant change, cabin filter change and the exhaust re welded.

Not to mention the all important stamp on the book lol (free screen wash, coolant and air freshner :) )

I wouldnt say no to vw service straight away. Go down to your garage and do some investigating...

Well the car is sitting at the dealership now, but I'm really starting to regret it. I've been told the adjustments and cleaning will be extra on top of the service (they would have been included at my local garage!). The desk guy also refused to believe that the clutch pedal could be adjusted and told me that if it is biting too low down, the clutch is worn. That sounds really odd to me. Is he right? :?

@Bradley: I've got a Haynes manual for it, and am very much up for giving a bit of maintenance a go. However, everything I've tried to fix myself so far has always ended in something else getting broken, so I'm reluctant to go any further really as I don't want to make a real (expensive) mess of something. I'd be really happy to be able to shadow someone doing this kind of stuff though, just to learn a bit more. I really don't know where or how I would get to do that kind of thing though...I don't personally know any mechanics!

The simple and most necessary stuff for a service - (plugs, oil filter, oil) is nice and easy, just follow the haynes manual, would be hard to do anything wrong.

I presume the clutch on them is hydraulic so no it wont be adjustable. Quite possible the system needs bleeding though, that might help.

75k on a 6 year old car is 12.5k per year so pretty much bang on what would be considered average mileage. Consider it high when it gets to 175k :)

Ok just a bit of an update...

It wasn't all as bad as expected really (thank god!). Nothing really wrong with the car whatsoever :o:shock:

So got my shiny free Sat Nav (piece of shit), paid my £150, and got out of there. They were telling me I needed to get a 'VW brake service' to clean out the rear drums, a brake fluid change, and an air con service; asking for the tidy sum of £297 on top of the original service. hmmm...how about no?! Oh, and the best bit...they wanted to replace a rear indicator bulb for....wait for it....£26!! Although thinking about the labour charge, that only works out at about 10min work, so it's about right :roll:

A colleague of mine recommended me a specialist VW Audi garage while I was pacing the office fretting yesterday :p . I took it down there today to get the work done. Did the whole lot in under an hour while I waited and had a chat with another mechanic about polo mods. Was even honest enough to tell me that the Air Con didn't need servicing yet (doubt I'd get as much from VW!). He charged me £50 for the lot in the end. I'm pretty happy with that result. And I think I've found a half decent garage out of it. All's well that ends well!

BTW: Just a quick thank you to everyone for being so hospitable towards a new member! Thanks :-D

Tim

75k's nowt for a well looked about VW. There's plenty of 80's VW's out there with 200k+ on.

i guess it worked outin the end, and you have a good number to keep with that garage then!

I agree with above, if you have a haynes maual, you can do oil changes, pads, disks and filters, the bog standard service stuff without too much effort. I usually can manage an oil change for about £30 getting stuff from part co or andrew page.

Would be worth buying a decent set of tool, halford do a cracking 150 piece for about £100 i think, with life time warranty. I found when i didnt have the right tool for the job i had problems, but now with a decent set of spanners etc it is a lot easier to get work done on the car.

If you have a mate who know kinda what they are doing get them to look over your shoulder next time to check you are doing it right- best way to learn if you ask me.

...just another thought- have you had your timing belt/water pump done?

I would not ever trust a main dealer with my car !!

Firstly, I am a main dealer. Secondly, I'm not going to start promoting dealers or justifying us etc and Thirdly, i'm not going to name who I work for but i'm happy to give a bit of info as to how we work. If I can help in any way, I will.

Main dealers are more expensive than anyone else. The reason basically comes down to overheads. We have to compulsary purchase special tools from the brand, have to run huge fleets of courtesy cars etc etc etc

We advertise headline rates for service work to try and encourage people to keep coming back to us after their warranty has expired. Our labour rate here is just under £95 per hour and some dealers are way over £100ph. Obviously we make our money from doing the big jobs, not from basic services. All dealers will carry out an Express Visual Check (EVC) regardless of what you came in for and this will highlight anything we recommend you do (and pay £95 per hour for).

We do this to a) generate income but also b) Volkswagen make thousands of recommendations for each model regarding air con re-gassing, air bag testing, tyre age checking etc etc etc and as a main dealer, we need to basically do whatever they tell us to do to prevent us from getting in bother from VW and them unscrewing the roundel from above the door.

The best advice I can offer is to be honest with the service adviser when you book it in. Tell him/her that you don't want to / can't afford to do anything extra. They will still present you with a long list of items but the service adviser will be able to advise how much life those parts have left etc. Remember, a dealer will advise that your brakes are worn if they are 66% worn. Worn brakes sounds scary. 2/3rds used doesn't. Always ask how worn, how many miles left etc.

Main dealers aren't out to rip people off. We are just in business. The service advisers/technicians don't own the business so they don't really care if you spend £100 or £1000. Incidentally, Volkswagen now frown upon dealers offering service staff incentives to force customers to take unneccesary work!

TOP TIPS

If presented with an estimate for £xxx for additional work. Thank them for the advice and tell them you are going to get quotes from your local garage. They should then offer you a deal. Dealers will negotiate on labour particuarly if they think they won't see you again.

Volkswagen dealers operate a price promise. If you present them with a service quote from another garage (non VW) and they use genuine parts, the dealer will match the price and chuck in a wash/vac/air freshener.

Even if your car is out of warranty. If it has a full VW service history, Volkswagen will offer goodwill on unusual faults outside of warranty. I have personally seen a five year old car with a clutch failure. The car had done 55k miles and the clutch was not excessively worn. The car had no warranty but because of the full history, VW paid for over half the repair.

As I said, I'm not on here promoting dealers but please try and see it from our point of view as well.

Cheers, sorry for the long post.

respect

Good post Neil.

Good post Neil,good to enlighten some people on the truth.My car has full VW dealership service history and its good to know a few of those points you made for future works.

Brad

few good points in there. but what ever you do... dont let the dealer wash your car.

Oh?

take your missus to the dealers, get her to wap her tits out, steal the dealer stamp while the guys are preoccupied oggling the zeppelins, do your own service and stamp yer own book with your five finger discount stamp ;)

take your missus to the dealers, get her to wap her tits out, steal the dealer stamp while the guys are preoccupied oggling the zeppelins, do your own service and stamp yer own book with your five finger discount stamp ;)

That, my friend, is a plan.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.