Skip to content

Going to view a 98 Diesel

Featured Replies

Hi,

I'm going to view a 98 diesel this evening and would appreciate some opinions/advice so that I'm not going in completely cold.

The car is a 5dr, L. It's red, and has alloys. There is no tax or MOT. MOT expired in June 09. The owner describes the car as follows:

Volkswagen in good overall condition with a good engine with still runs very well. The car has a low mileage of just 55650 so will have many more miles left in it. Gears 1-4 work perfectly well but it jumps out of 5th would be ideal for someone who could do a bit of work on it themselves.

Now I've searched this site for the 5th gear problem and as such it appears the problem could be a) adjust 5th gear wih box in situ, b) replace gearbox, or c) top up gearbox oil.

The car has just 55k on the clock, therefore would the gearbox really need replacing after this relatively small mileage? Or does this car sound somewhat "dubious" and should I avoid it like the plague?

If the car is a good I was considering offering £250-300 - on the basis of it needing a new gearbox (approx £450-500 to by & replace). Are my figures realistic?

Thank you,

Mike

  • Replies 9
  • Views 1.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Fifth gear will almost certainly be a chewed gearset due to the fork being out of adjustment. This can be fixed for peanuts without having to remove the gearbox,plus the cost of new gear oil,by removing a gearset from a scrap car. Fifth is the only gear accessible from the outside of the unit,under a metal plate on the end.

Be aware that the ratios vary considerably between different models,and knowing what car the right gearset is in,isn't as simple as engine size because differentials differ as well. I found a 1.4s fifth gearset to be longer than a 1.6,and nearly as long as a diesel,because the 1.4s differential had a lower ratio than the 1.6.

Seems a low mileage for this damage to have happened,though. If it was low on oil already,that could spell impending problems with the rest of the gearbox. I doubt you'll find out,as its probably been topped up now..

There's a topic on this in the fao section of the engine forum,explains how to change the gearset and adjust the fork.

Any competent mechanic will find it an easy task.

  • Author
Fifth gear will almost certainly be a chewed gearset due to the fork being out of adjustment. This can be fixed for peanuts without having to remove the gearbox,plus the cost of new gear oil,by removing a gearset from a scrap car. Fifth is the only gear accessible from the outside of the unit,under a metal plate on the end.

Be aware that the ratios vary considerably between different models,and knowing what car the right gearset is in,isn't as simple as engine size because differentials differ as well. I found a 1.4s fifth gearset to be longer than a 1.6,and nearly as long as a diesel,because the 1.4s differential had a lower ratio than the 1.6.

Seems a low mileage for this damage to have happened,though. If it was low on oil already,that could spell impending problems with the rest of the gearbox. I doubt you'll find out,as its probably been topped up now..

There's a topic on this in the fao section of the engine forum,explains how to change the gearset and adjust the fork.

Any competent mechanic will find it an easy task.

Hi,

Thanks for the info - I'll take a look at the topic.

I had a chat with the owner earlier. He said a friend drained the gearbox oil and they found shards of metal, he also said that there are more than one damaged cog (so I presume they've inspected the gears via the plate), and that a replacement box would be required.

With regards to money. The owner has said he wants around 500 GBP for the car as is. Will view the car, but if a new box is required it might be better to buy a taxed/tested car to start with?

Thank you,

Mike

Maybe. Unless you're prepared to buy a used one and fit that.

I'm thinking it'll have to be a minter to be worth getting a recon box fitted,but only you can evaluate that really.

Whether it needs one is still subject to more knowledgable inspection. Probably,but still.

Yes,both cogs get damaged and you replace them both. Being absolutely brittle material,the oil will have metal dust in it,and be metallic as a result. And small bits of metal will be found.

This will have done the box no good if they continued to drive it for any considerable distance with four gears,but mine (with the same type of damage) was initially saved,and only then replaced because i found one with a longer final drive ratio.

  • Author
Maybe. Unless you're prepared to buy a used one and fit that.

I'm thinking it'll have to be a minter to be worth getting a recon box fitted,but only you can evaluate that really.

Whether it needs one is still subject to more knowledgable inspection. Probably,but still.

Yes,both cogs get damaged and you replace them both. Being absolutely brittle material,the oil will have metal dust in it,and be metallic as a result. And small bits of metal will be found.

This will have done the box no good if they continued to drive it for any considerable distance with four gears,but mine (with the same type of damage) was initially saved,and only then replaced because i found one with a longer final drive ratio.

This is the car in question...

http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?Vie...E:X:RTQ:GB:1123

Not sure if it would be called a minter, but it looks in better condition than others I've seen of a similar age?

I wouldn't bother with it myself.

Doesn't look like it's been looked after at all...and no service history on a diesel? Thats a turn off in my books. Its also the no frills 'L' model. As for the gearbox, if you can't fit one yourself then its going to be an expensive job, people usually replace the clutch whilst its off too. If you can fit it yourself then you've got to find the Polo diesel gearbox which isn't that easy.

If you do decide to have a look watch out for vibrations in the 'cab' whilst car is running, I've had two of these, my first one gave me headaches and no one knew why it vibrated so much! The second used more oil than petrol because of knackered piston rings or whatever the hell it was.

Keep looking, they are good cars and use hardly any fuel!

I'm inclined to agree,it looks unloved.

I suspect its spent its days doing very short journeys with little other attention,the ancient alloys are covered in brake dust for a car that travels so little. Seems trivial but it could be years since it was serviced.

Speculation of course,but hold out for the final bid because it aint worth a monkey on that ad.

  • Author
I'm inclined to agree,it looks unloved.

I suspect its spent its days doing very short journeys with little other attention,the ancient alloys are covered in brake dust for a car that travels so little. Seems trivial but it could be years since it was serviced.

Speculation of course,but hold out for the final bid because it aint worth a monkey on that ad.

Thanks guys - fortunately the decision has been made for me, as the seller called me to say he's keeping the car after all (and will be replacing the gearbox).

Ah well... the search continues :)

Ah well everything happens for a reason! Keep looking, especially if you don't like paying for fuel :-)

That well pisses me off when people advertise their car for sale then decide to keep it!

Two times that happened to me when searching for a valver!

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.