Skip to content

..wheel came off whilst driving!

Featured Replies

so yeah, i got my 14" BBS RA alloys a week or so ago and went looking for some extended bolts to hold them on (for myt Mk4)

was in a bit of a hurry as I wanted to see what the wheels looked like on the car so i thought i would pop into the old halfrauds before buying anything on ebay. asked the guy in there if he could sell me some extended wheel bolts for aftermarket alloys for a polo mk4. after searching some shizz up he came back with some and said they would fit for any wheels, with a load of spigot rings aswell. i looked at the bolts and was a bit confused asking if he was sure they would fit.

put them on the car and there was literally about 5-10mm of thread holding the wheels onto the front hubs (back was a bit more). it all went ok until i fitted some 40mm lowering springs on the car today where i had to undo these bolts for the first time since fitment. did them back up after fitting the springs and thought they felt a bit 'spongy' upon tightening.

went out around the block tonight around 8ish to test the new springs see how they felt and couls hear rubbing and clicking. just thought it was the wheels on lock (i have veryyy chunky tyres on atm). as i turn right back into my street.. BANG!! the NS drops to tyhe ground and i just see my wheel rolling off into a phone box in front of the car lol. ther car is stranded right in the middle of the crossroads, but luckily I'm able to run home and grab a jack and my old steely before too much mayhem ensued.

as you can imagine I'm pretty pissed off though, i just dont know whether to be pissed at myself, halfrauds, or both. was it my fuck up that the bolts didnt hold the wheel on? should i have held overall responsibility in judging whether they were suitbale or not, or did halfords mislead me and sell me the wrong kind of shit? i dont want to take it too far as luckily no-one else was involved and insurance dont need to know.. worst damage is a new wing, dented front door, new wheel hub/disc and alot of embarassment in front of the neighbours lol

just thought i would vent some frustration on here like the last time i crashed lmao :cry:

  • Replies 9
  • Views 1.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

It's possible that the wheel bolts were to blame for this and it's also possible you too

could be at fault.Did you check the new wheel bolt shape with the old bolt shape before

sticking the wheels back on? If they are the same...did you tighten them up enough...?

I've put up a diagram explaining the seats for wheel bolts...hope this helps!

alloy-steel.jpg

dude must have shit you up a bit, lucky you wasnt on the motorway or something!

its a differcult one to place the blame on anyone really, unless the guy at halfords checked your wheels etc I'm pretty sure they would turn round to you and say you should have made sure etc

just accept the mistake & think yourself lucky it wasnt alot worse

ALSO

is it VITAL to have the correct seating? as in fitting 60* tapered bolts into dome bolt holes?

just I'm having trouble finding some domed bolts short enough for my adaptors, but iv found some with the tapered heads which are? now i worried lol

yeah, if you put tapered bolts in a domed hole for example, the bolt isnt seated correctly. The stress on the wheel could cause them to sheer.

So what exactly happened? Did it shear the bolts, or pull the thread out of the hub? Or did they just come loose?

The round and tapered thing is somthing you need to look into, as if you have the wrong type in the wrong hole then they have probably worked their way slack and come out, the taper is there to centralise the wheel and lock the bolt in to stop it coming undone.

I've had this happen (rear O/S wheel @ 60mph!) but was through too much trust in a mate to do the damn bolts up right!

Check the bolts with your originals. I never trust anything halfords tell me. I Dont know alot about mechanics but i think i know more than most of them!!

  • Author

it just literally sheared the threading. threading in the two of the holes in the hub was mashed and threading on two of the bolts was sheared.. luckily the two hub holes that werent mashed were opposite so I could chuck my steely on and get it back on the drive.

that diagram makes sense.. but in honesty that wasn't half of my problem with these bolts.. they were just too damn short! it took like literally two full rotations to tighten them.. like i said it must have been about 5mm holding them on.

i reckon it's partly my fault.. they had been fine up until i removed them and put them back on.. and i think the spongy feeling i felt was actually some of the threading dying. but still, that shouldn't happen to brand new bolts.. maybe had something to do with the fact that the bolts were gripping onto the hub thread with only two rings of thread, when i put pressure on when tightening it just mashed them up?

i don't know.. but i defo tightened them, and they DEFO should not have been used with my wheels i needed much longer ones, i can't believe how much faith the guy in halfords had in what the computer told him..

anyways i'm going down there tomorrow to at least get my money back, don't think i can take it any furthur

  • Author
I've had this happen (rear O/S wheel @ 60mph!) but was through too much trust in a mate to do the damn bolts up right!

Check the bolts with your originals. I never trust anything halfords tell me. I Dont know alot about mechanics but i think i know more than most of them!!

OMG this is where i consider myself lucky.. thank god i was driving around slowly at the dead of night cos i was checking out my new springs..

and thank god yours was a rear.. losing a front @ 60 would have been alot worse i'm guessing?! what happened and how bad was the damage?

I've heard some Mercedes bolts are the same but longer,might wanna look into it.

You need eight turns (eight threads) from the hubface of the wheel when the bolt is held seated in the wheel,off the car.

in this case halfords were wrong to tell you that they would fit any car,

i work there and i can tell you now for sure that anything like that would have to be ordered in to store ...

i would take pictures of the car and take them bak to halfords and tell them this is what happened to my car after the employee that served you sold them to you claiming that they were the right ones for "any car"

squeeze them for every penny you can get out of them ...

nothing bad happened in this case (no1 was hurt) a few dented panels but thats all ... there could have been people involved and it could of ended up much worse, and no matter how many times they tell you they cant do anything ... its bollox, they can.

you asked for longer bolts and you was supplied with bolts that you were told were the right ones therefore you are not held liable .... if they had said anything to you i.e you can use these mate but its at your own risk.. then its a different case.

if you decide to take this further m8 and you need the umber for halfords head office or anything give me a shout and ill get it for you :)

Chris

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.