Skip to content

mk4 16v VS 1.6

Featured Replies

first off sorry if its been covered before.....

gonna get a mk4 polo very soon and got my eye on a couple.

ones is a 1.4 16v and the other is a 1.6 8v.

just wondering how they compare?

i know the 16v is 100bhp and the 1.6 is 75ish

does the 16v piss all over the 1.6?

and is the 1.6 slow compared to other 1.6 cars (saxo, corsa etc)

how are they both for feul consumption?

i really want the 16v just insurance is putting me off atm.

but if the 1.6 isnt lacking toooo much id consider it.

cheers

  • Replies 34
  • Views 3.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

By saxos i assume u mean vtrs? And they will piss on a 1.6 8v polo as will the 16v polo's, to put it simply. But you'll get better fuel consumption from an 8v id imagine :)

VTS>16v>1.6

  • Author

yeh i wasnt really expecting either to keep up with the saxo

what bout the vtr though?

how much the slower is the 1.6 to the 16v?

hugely?

Am not sure tbh, but a gt standard is 75bhp - mine wasnt standard and i could only just keep up with a valver.....thats the closest comparison i can give. There are some idiots who will claim a 1.6 is faster as it has more torque - but thats a lie :lol:

16v are cheaper to tax aswell, get one!

Good point there :)

  • Author

I'm talking bout the mk4 1.6 btw, just to be sure.

if theres not much in it i might go for the 1.6. as insurance is lower.

Yer i knew which car :lol: Theres quite a lot in it i was trying to say.....

  • Author

hmm i dunno man

I'm sue to a 1.2 clio with about 40 brake lol

so there both gonna seem quick too me.

Well in that case its up to you :thumbsup: Someone did tune a 1.6 8v up to about the same power as a 16v iirc though :)

Edited by Olly S

hmm i dunno man

I'm sue to a 1.2 clio with about 40 brake lol

so there both gonna seem quick too me.

I have a 1.2 clio as well, even my 1.3 coupe feels quick compare, imo you should go for a gt!

GT's are the shizzle tbf :thumbsup:

"Get a GT" is the answer to every question on here :lol:

The 16v will be much more fun to drive than the 1.6, it's also better spec'd too.

But if you never really stray over 4,000RPM you may prefer the low down torque the 1.6 has, there's not much of that in a valver.

Oh and 16v>VTR 8-)

Oh and 16v>VTR 8-)

You sure about that? :lol:

Yes, proven a few times.

Test Richie, Tej and Amit were witnesses on one occasion :lol:

haha fair enough then :thumbsup:

VTS's are fairly quick though, I don't think I'd have a go against one of them :lol:

Might not be so favourable to you :lol:

I'm curious, how do you guys determine which car is faster? Do you mean faster off the line from a starting position? Because I've got a 1.6 8v and I can go from 0-60 in less than ten seconds quite easily....

I'm curious, how do you guys determine which car is faster? Do you mean faster off the line from a starting position? Because I've got a 1.6 8v and I can go from 0-60 in less than ten seconds quite easily....

all depends what its timed by , all standard 0-60 figures are all done by proper timing eqipment , not by a stopwatch or anything ......

my 16v's eaten a vtr , thats 0-100 , but for me id rather have low down speed than top speed ......

and my 1.6 8v isnt perticually fast , sounds awful no matter what you do to it , and the best thing i can keep up with is a 1.2 clio , but the induction noise from a 1.4 16v is the best bit , and they'll hit the limiter all day long , but the gearboxes dont allways take it :(

saxo vts is a 1.6 16v and will piss over the mk4 polo 1.6 8v and 1.4 16v either way. the vtr is a 1.6 8v but still has 100bhp (if i remember) as standard, so therefore should keep up with the 16v and piss over the 8v

i had a 1.6 8v with bike carbs on and could keep up with 16v's and hadnt had the exhaust done yet so yes they are tuneable, however so is the 16v and they have higher bhp too start with + cheaper tax, the insurance will change with age and driving experience so its up too you but hope that helps

I'm currently down too a 1.4 8v which still goes and is fun too drive, got a lower spec purely due too insurance purposes as i have points also

my gt spanked every saxo i ever came across... granted was stripped out and ran 90+bhp with 8k limiter

got a 1600 8v on bike carbs in a mk1 polo an that is really impressive... would be seriously impressed if a saxo could keep up with it!!!

gettin my valver mot'd next week so will be able to give a like for like comparison:-)

in short the answer is definitely get yourself a gt find a decent one for £6/700 and spend the money you have left over from the valver price tag on insurance and any off the really cheap tuning options that you can afford with anything left over from that!

GT's are brilliant to learn the ropes on as well nothing is complicated on them so you can just jump straight in an learn how it all works!

my GT definitely set the path for all my v.dub antics! Fun Cars!!!

hmm i dunno man

I'm sue to a 1.2 clio with about 40 brake lol

so there both gonna seem quick too me.

i had a 1.2 8v Clio before i got my 1.4 16v and its a totaly different animal, i had a race with my mate and i couldnt belive how far i got from him on a small bit of road. the 16v polos drink alot of petrol even if you try and drive it economicaly

my 1.6 couldnt keep up with sam Rs valver [both standard engine wise] so valver in that sense. but if your not bothered bout bitching people off the lights etc go for a 1.6, you will probly use less fuel as you can stay in higher gears at lower speeds if that makes sence?

however the tax is cheaper on a valver, & you will already have better lights, bumpers, wheels, brakes, interior, general spec. if your planning on upgrading these if you get a 1.6 then your better off getting a valver. UNLESS your get a GL or GLX which come like valvers minus the engine then i dont know mate haha

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.