Skip to content

6n2 GTi questions for a non-Polo person!

Featured Replies

Hi all. Nice to be here...

Me and the missus have a new addition on the way (its due tomorrow!) so this means we're going to have to hunt down a new second car to replace our mk1 MX5 (I've got a Mondeo ST TDCi for work so its not going to be our only car).

After LOADS of searching, the Mk5 Polo GTi seems to fit the bill for what we want out of a second car: fun, something with a bit of character with a scene, under £4k, smallish but big enough for a pushchair etc.

So I just need to know EVERYTHING there is about them - reliability (heard about gearbox problems or something at 60k miles?), tuneability (any easy mods to get abit more power/speed etc) - just everything - need input!

Cheers all,

Dave (hopefully a future VW owner)

  • Replies 36
  • Views 3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

ok well yes the gearbox is a problem but most of the time they would have been replaced or reconditioned, also the pedalboxes are shit and break but most of them have been done on recall from vw, apart from that youve got a minter very fun car quick as fuck looks the bees knees, in terms of tunability for 700 i got mine to 140bhp (proven when remaped) induction kit really helps the low end torque problem, exhaust (jetex) isnt loud and sounds mint remap ties it all in together and 140bhp is enough for me i keep up with lots of things and the handleing is just about perfect tbh, i cant think of anything else tbh

my mate fitted his 4th gearbox in about a year, i will never buy one on this basis!

nice cars, but the gearbox problem isnt a if, but more a when and how many times!

It really is shambolic that VW cut a corner with the gearbox on a potentially great car..

mines been a great daily slag. 20k in a year. No problems, not a niggle. just a service and some brakes!

After a gearbox's been reconned...they should be fine. if its gone again. Then its been done shit.

After a gearbox's been reconned...they should be fine. if its gone again. Then its been done shit.

totally disagree, thats just passing blame, i will let rae come and tell his story!

well did the gearbox have the uprated parts installed? Or like for like parts installed? Was it a complete rebuild or just the parts that broke?

Is he running standard bhp? or something different

i cant understand it. as theres GTI's plodding on well over 100k on factory gearbox's

my mate fitted his 4th gearbox in about a year, i will never buy one on this basis!

nice cars, but the gearbox problem isnt a if, but more a when and how many times!

5th gearbox / rebuild including when i fitted the GTI engine instead of the 1.4 16v engine

After a gearbox's been reconned...they should be fine. if its gone again. Then its been done shit.

totally disagree, thats just passing blame, i will let rae come and tell his story!

you've just peed me off!!!! been done shit? no chance. i dont skimp out on my/our cars.

the company that rebuilt the 1.4 16v box 3 times have never let me down and they have done every box i've had off cars, including a 91 16v golf gti, a 91 golf G60, numberous mk3 polo's including the G40 box i just bought back which i sold 2 years ago that still works.

then i got fed up with it and bought a GTI engine/box/etc to fit, done that, and its lasted a year / 15000 miles or so before starting to die (before starting to break, gearlever bounced around when you press accelerator, car bunnyhopped etc.

now it knocks when on axle stands in gear / when in neutral.

just fitted another gti box which has apparently been rebuilt and its like brand new, but i recon in another 15000miles it'll be shot and need rebuilding again.

the gearboxes on these 6n2's are SHITE! ... end of.

and i do have mecahnical sympathy.

but on the plus side, I'm shit hot at changing 6n2 gearboxes now. lol.

i dont know of any friends who've had a 6n2 (and one lad who had a 6n 1.4 16v 100bhp) who haven't had to buy a new box, or get one rebuilt.

edit: OH!!! and dont get me started on the clutch pedal snapping when the clutch gets ever so slightly heavier as it wears, and the squeaky dashboards, squeaky seats, rear washer pipes coming off, electric window plastics on the mechanism breaking, plastic trim that the finish comes off.... how hard it is to fit sidelight bulbs to the xenon's without breaking the electric adjuster mechanisms even after removing the bumper, and the headlight to do it properly...... non stop hastle!

Edited by rae

well did the gearbox have the uprated parts installed? Or like for like parts installed? Was it a complete rebuild or just the parts that broke?

Is he running standard bhp? or something different

i cant understand it. as theres GTI's plodding on well over 100k on factory gearbox's

i wouldnt expect the clutch pedals / gearbox bearings to last much over 100k, the 1.4 engine/box had done 86k and bottom end was fubar, and the box was knackered.

the GTI engine is bog standard just fitted to a colour concept in place of the 1.4 16v.... its not even lowered much!

Edited by rae

god youve had some bad luck :lol:

si_gti's is over 100k on the original box isnt it?

Was one on ebay other week that had too.

Wonder what makes some last ages, and some 30k

Si's is on 106k. Just the luck of the pot really.

  • Author

My god, so they're not as good as I hoped then! This has had to reduce me to looking at French cars... 206GTi maybe!

where are you located. Have to take a test drive in one ;)

Pretty tiny boot, not sure it'd much good for push chair etc?

My god, so they're not as good as I hoped then! This has had to reduce me to looking at French cars... 206GTi maybe!

Every car has it's problems.. Go on any peugeot forum and they'll tell you the problems of a 206 GTi. Bet the polo wins on reliability!

Polo could be an awesomely reliable car...but if the gear box is made of chocolate it's enough to steer people away.

206 gti :shock: dont!!!

I have owned my Polo 6n2 GTI for about a year and a half, i drive it like i stole it (like a GTI should be driven. lol)

I have done over 30k in that year and a half and the only issue i had with the gearbox was putting it into 5th at say 110 (it would sometimes crunch), fitting a short shift kit has got rid of that problem now though and its perfect in every gear, it is the original box and has done 97k.

Out of the 3000 6n2 GTI's made, there are only probably only a small percentage of them with gearbox issues, the only problem is, is that people dont post up on here saying their gearbox is still working ok, only when one fails.

Edited by naf536

I have owned my Polo 6n2 GTI for about a year and a half, i drive it like i stole it (like a GTI should be driven. lol)

I have done over 30k in that year and a half and the only issue i had with the gearbox was putting it into 5th at say 110 (it would sometimes crunch), fitting a short shift kit has got rid of that problem now though and its perfect in every gear, it is the original box and has done 97k.

3 words: good for you.

Out of the 3000 6n2 GTI's made, there are only probably only a small percentage of them with gearbox issues, the only problem is, is that people dont post up on here saying their gearbox is still working ok, only when one fails.

it's not just the GTI's that have gearbox or clutch/pedal issues, google it, there are hundreds of people complaining about them.

as i said, with a 1.4 engine in we went through 3 working gearboxes....

3 words: good for you.

Obviously it is good for me :lol:

Out of the thousands upon thousands of polos made, you can only find hundreds complaining about it ???

Maybe the hundreds of people have bad driving techniques, maybe the one who arent complaining have just been lucky ?

It just bugs me that people are quick to say that the boxes on these cars are shite when there are probably hundreds/thousands who haven't had any problems whatsoever.

3 words: good for you.

Obviously it is good for me :lol:

Out of the thousands upon thousands of polos made, you can only find hundreds complaining about it ???

Maybe the hundreds of people have bad driving techniques, maybe the one who arent complaining have just been lucky ?

It just bugs me that people are quick to say that the boxes on these cars are shite when there are probably hundreds/thousands who haven't had any problems whatsoever.

.... haven't even taken into account the VW Lupo's, Seat Arosa's etc etc with the same type gearboxes that are all affected...

you tell me, just how mine and the mrs's "bad driving techniques" cause the 6n2 box to break, but absolutely thrashing the arse of both my 2nd and 3rd G40's has never killed even one box.....

I wasnt trying to have a dig at your driving, just that the majority of boxes that do go could be because of bad driving, I thrash the shit out of my polo but the box is ok (at the moment touch wood), i have even missed gears by trying to change to fast, and the arosas and lupos are exactly the same in my eyes, hundreds complaining yet thousands made.

There is no disputing that certain parts on these newer cars are made more cheaply these days, that is why there still so many mk1, mk2 golfs etc on the road and the newer polo's just get scrapped when something expensive breaks.

My arguement is that even though hundreds of people are complaining about bad gear boxes, thousands of people arenet complaining meanin either they dont use internet forums, dont feel like its important to mention or haven't experienced any problems.

i agree with you mate.

So right that the only bad rep you hear about gearbox's is from people's that have gone. Not those that are thundering on.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.