Skip to content

Polo Three Door available to order!

Featured Replies

http://www.topgear.com/uk/car-news/volkswa...-3dr-2009-10-07

Just saw on top gear.com that the new polo was available to order,

in my opinion it looks fantastic!

Cue modern cars are too plasticy/slow/boring debate! :-D

Edited by Jamie_300

  • Replies 27
  • Views 2.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I'm not into modern cars,particularly the most recent.

But that'll be the best little car out there in my view. I didn't like the 9n-series but that's looking good.

i like the look of it to be honest. a bit of the golf/scirocco front end. not a fan of coras/fiesta so like this one. I'm guessing the one in the pic isnt what they will all look like.... more likely to have a massive list of extras and a prices about the same as an A4.

they all look the same now ?

VW has always had a strong family look though. It's nothing new...

vw-golf-mk1.jpg

MK1_VW_Polo.jpg

VW%20Scirocco%20Mk1.jpg

800px-Vw_passat_b1_v_sst.jpg

Yes but i think the bodies seem different but the new ones have mainly the same fit out etc

Those all have very similar bodies though tbh - Mk1 Polo is a smaller Mk1 Golf, Scirocco is a stretched Mk1 Golf with a lower roof, stretch the Scirocco a bit more and add an extra set of doors and you get the Passat.

But there was always something different about them, all the new ones look like photoshop versions of each other.

I disagree, clearly I'm in the minority here though. Every manufacturer has a family look. IMHO the older V-Dubs look like they're part of the same range and the new ones are exactly the same. Yes they look similar but only in the same way you could argue a Mk1 Fiesta and Mk2 Polo look similar. A Mk3 Polo looks a bit like the facelifted Nova. A Mk4 looks similar to a Mk1 Punto from the front. There's only so much manufacturers can be arsed to do with a hatchback, and that's always been the same.

How many people on here get comments like 'nice Golf' said about their Polo?

i cannot believe the mk3 polo just got compared to a nova :crybaby:

I disagree, clearly I'm in the minority here though. Every manufacturer has a family look. IMHO the older V-Dubs look like they're part of the same range and the new ones are exactly the same. Yes they look similar but only in the same way you could argue a Mk1 Fiesta and Mk2 Polo look similar. A Mk3 Polo looks a bit like the facelifted Nova. A Mk4 looks similar to a Mk1 Punto from the front. There's only so much manufacturers can be arsed to do with a hatchback, and that's always been the same.

How many people on here get comments like 'nice Golf' said about their Polo?

i agree with you, but i'd also say more creativity went into the design of older cars, due to less restrictions on things like safety. computer aided design of cars doesnt really help on the creativity front either

CAD plays a bigger part, I agree, but what makes you think modern cars aren't designed by hand?

021437700_1230032659.jpg

I'm not a big fan of new car but might invest ina new polo

CAD plays a bigger part, I agree, but what makes you think modern cars aren't designed by hand?

021437700_1230032659.jpg

the original concept might be concieved by hand, but computer aid design plays a massive part in the finished article (ever noticed how concept cars rarely look like the finish production car). go into any major car producing company and a vast majority of parts will have been designed on some sort of cad package.

this is a big reason that so many brands and models look similar. Cars are designed with aerodynamics and safety being key features, so it stands to reason that they will all come up with very similar looking designs, afterall you cant re-invent the wheel.

i'd be very impressed if you could name one car built in the last 10 years thats been designed 100% by hand, in fact I would be amazed

I disagree, clearly I'm in the minority here though. Every manufacturer has a family look. IMHO the older V-Dubs look like they're part of the same range and the new ones are exactly the same. Yes they look similar but only in the same way you could argue a Mk1 Fiesta and Mk2 Polo look similar. A Mk3 Polo looks a bit like the facelifted Nova. A Mk4 looks similar to a Mk1 Punto from the front. There's only so much manufacturers can be arsed to do with a hatchback, and that's always been the same.

How many people on here get comments like 'nice Golf' said about their Polo?

The man has a point...my Mk3 Polo gets mistaken for a Golf regularly,even from the

front and lets face it they may look similar but they look nothing like a Golf front on.

  • Author
Those all have very similar bodies though tbh - Mk1 Polo is a smaller Mk1 Golf, Scirocco is a stretched Mk1 Golf with a lower roof, stretch the Scirocco a bit more and add an extra set of doors and you get the Passat.

This is fact!

And i think that the new family has a good look! so why not copy it?

Don't forget when the focus/Ka came out ford completly reddi their range to compliment it!

i like that.....are they the only engine options set for it??

would have been nice to see the tsi lump in there

Not debating that - but safety and aerodynamics have been a consideration for a good long while now. I know it's even more of an issue, but I don't think it's a new thing. Broadly speaking modern hatches are a similar shape, but so are older cars.

If you look at the Mk3 Polo's rivals, there's not a massive variation in side profile.

Polo-G40-1.jpg

mk3fiesta.jpg

vauxhall_nova.jpg

1990_renault_5-pic-390175333962105088.jp

86-peugeot-205-gti.jpg

side.jpg

Pony_Presto.jpg

Not debating that - but safety and aerodynamics have been a consideration for a good long while now. I know it's even more of an issue, but I don't think it's a new thing. Broadly speaking modern hatches are a similar shape, but so are older cars.

If you look at the Mk3 Polo's rivals, there's not a massive variation in side profile.

again they do look similar but each one does at least have a styling feature that sets them apart, the nova has its arches, the 5 has the sloped back, the fiesta has rust, the 205 has that distinctive rear quater window and the AX has angular styling, the polo just looks like a cross of ideas from the nova and fezrot (but then you did pick the model of polo that best suited your arguement)

as for aerodynamcis and safety, yes they have been factors for a long time, but its only in recent years that computers have really started to play a major part in the design. why bother with an expensive wind tunnel, when you can simulate the aerodynamcis of a car using an applemac!

and to be honest cars of the mk3 polo era, are boderline modern in their construction tecniques, so are bound to look very similar. Having said that though, if you go further back in time the same trend applies, so fashion is obviously another key factor of car design.

  • Author
If you look at the Mk3 Polo's rivals, there's NO massive variation in side profile.

:-D

the fiesta has rust,

:lol: guess what my friends N reg fiesta failed MOT on the other day...

  • Author

Anyway back on topic, did anyone see the advert?

Calvin Harris look-a-like or what!

I think it's very good looking. Was one in my local dealer today, very snazzy indeed. I'd have one.

If you look at the Mk3 Polo's rivals, there's NO massive variation in side profile.

:-D

Technically it should be written as "there isn't a massive variation" actually. :-p

I'm with Alex on this.

Makes me laugh when people with mk3's say "they all look the same" :lol:

This is definately one of the better looking standard Polos. Big improvement over the 9N/3 :-)

Anyway back on topic, did anyone see the advert?

Calvin Harris look-a-like or what!

See what you mean actually :lol:

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.