Skip to content

garage labour rates

Featured Replies

how long should it take to swap the front metal brake lines on a mk3 polo?

just had mine done at a local garage and they are trying to tell me its taken them two hours! And on top of this I've had to have 2 new calipers at the same time because they snapped the bleed nipples off my calipers!

surely thats only an hours work? hour and a half tops! i can do a charger swap in less than that and its a far more fiddly job

Edited by g40jon

  • Replies 30
  • Views 3.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

so they've replace both solid brake lines at the front and both calipers as well? Two hours seems perfectly reasonable to me, it's a far more involved job than just taking the charger off and back on. Made harder by the fact the pipes are hard to even get to with the engine in the way.

Yeah 2 hours seems fine, would take me a bit longer at home unless I was running around like a blue arsed fly.

  • Author

yeah, one that goes from the driver side flexi to the servo and the other goes from the pass side flexi to a joiner down near the pass side flexi. I actually watched the guy do them and it took 45mins for him to change the pipes, but had to leave the car behind for them to sort the broken bleed nipples. i just dont see how it can take an extra hour and 15 mins to fit a pair on new calipers and bleed them

Some garages charge only by the hour. So there is no in-between rate for 1.5hrs work. Broken bleed nipples could take a while to sort out, likewise getting the brakes bled properly so they are spot on.

might have only took half an hour but if they charge by the hour then you pay for the full 2nd hour.

  • Author

fair enough, just seemed like a lot of time to me. especially as its costing me an extra £100 for calipers, as they apparently could do anything with my old ones (although I'm fair sure that they couldnt be bothered to try and remove the broken nipples)

end result, is that a job the main guy who runs the garage told me would cost £80-£90 is gonna cost £230

so cheesed off, as the pipes were only advisories and the lad doing my brakes said one of them didnt even look that bad.

Couple of hours seems fair, verging on brimming efficiency.

Ask for the old calipers back, can always keep them and refurb them as a spare set or to sell on.

Guessing you MOT'd it and just told them to do what needs doing?

  • Author
Couple of hours seems fair, verging on brimming efficiency.

Ask for the old calipers back, can always keep them and refurb them as a spare set or to sell on.

Guessing you MOT'd it and just told them to do what needs doing?

it would have been an extra £60 to keep the old ones as theres a surcharge apprently. what pisses me off even more is that there are calipers for sale on ebay (refurbed std vw2 ones) for £50 for a pair.

they didnt leave me much option with the car, as i could hardly drive home with no brakes and they werent prepared to change the bleed nipples.

i still think 2 hours is a long time to do just the fronts, they certainly shouldnt have encountered problems with the calipers, as i have only done the disks and pads a couple of weeks ago.

I also find it crazy that i have to pay for a new caliper, when the lad doing the work was the guy who broke it. granted one of the nipples was allready bust, but to charge me for 2 seems a bit off.

bet they wouldnt be pleased if i returned their courtesy car with a bust wing mirror for example and expected them to foot the bill!

2 hours sounds fine to me, quite a fiddly job with engine in situe. And as for them not repairing the bleed nipples, it would probably take a couple of hours labour to get the snapped ones out, so its quicker to get new calipers in their eyes, they dont want a dead car on a ramp when other jobs can be done.

And why should the garage have to pay for your calipers? They didnt break them intentionaly, they were just doing what they had to do to get your brakes bled, they cant help it if YOUR bleed nipples were seized on your car.

well I'm an apprentice mechanic and we get brake pipes in quite alot coz we live beside the sea and the salt goes for the steel pipes, and brake pipes sertainly arent easy althought you do get the odd easy ones its not often and i no wen we do quotes for people we quote upto an hour a brake pipe just incase because some can look easy but when u start taking them off is when u find out how much of a bitch they are to do. as for the caliper if they had fitted new pipes and then tryed to take the bleed nipples off you can tell when there gonna snap and its just as easy to bleed the braked throught the pipes if you have to so it coulda been avoided but not alot of people will try think of other ways they will just try the way they no and if it dont work theyl order new bits. but the 2 hours sounds decent to me.

Lewis

But bleeding it through the pipe union isnt ideal on a punters car, if its to do with brakes its got to be done 100% right tbh. Or you'll get sued....

Surcharge for keeping your old calipers? My arse. I'm highly doubtful that's in place, only reason you would get that is if parts were on an exchange basis which I'd be very surprised if they were. Demand your old calipers back, point out you wasn't informed there would be a surcharge to keep them as they are YOUR property.

2 hours sounds fine to me, quite a fiddly job with engine in situe. And as for them not repairing the bleed nipples, it would probably take a couple of hours labour to get the snapped ones out, so its quicker to get new calipers in their eyes, they dont want a dead car on a ramp when other jobs can be done.

bullcrap

Whats bullcrap about that?

Have you ever tried to change a broken nipple? I gave up after 1 hour, admitedly i didnt have ideal tools but still.

Time equals money

One of my nipples broke on the G and it took a couple of hours, was a right pain :disgust:

I however use my assetts, last work I had done I paid no labour. I suggest saving your pennies for plastic surgery in future bois :smirk: Jokes :lol::-p

  • Author
Whats bullcrap about that?

Have you ever tried to change a broken nipple? I gave up after 1 hour, admitedly i didnt have ideal tools but still.

Time equals money

what were you using? a spoon?! would take no time at all with a stud extractor

Yep, I was using a spoon :thumbsup:

£60 surcharge for taking your calipers back?

that is utter rubbish!

Underdog is right, they are your property, they have no right to ransom kidnap them!

please dont start bickering in this post, single replies like "bullcrap" bring nothing to the discussion but annoy everyone

Yep, I was using a spoon :thumbsup:

:lol: You spoon :lol:

and for the record i have used a spoon once to get a bolt off

I have a deep scar on my left knuckle caused by a spoon, so don't want to go back over that and bring up bad memories.

Got to admit, I think the garage probably did things right on this one. Yeah, a steel brake hose might not be that corroded, but it still needs to appear solid for test. If you've told them to just fix it, then they'll either spend an hour with a bit of sandpaper taking the rust off til next year, or take an hour to renew it with a peice of copper which should last 10+ years. If I were mending my car myself, and didn't have the means to replace with copper, I might be tempted to clean up and recoat the steel pipes, but it's a false economy.

As for the bleed nipples, they do shear off quite a bit, just one of those annoyances of working on cars. You can hit them with a bit of heat or release spray first, but here's a risk of damaging the seals in the caliper anyway. Depending how far down they've sheared, You can use an extractor, but there is a risk of damaging the thread in the caliper. Again, were I DIY'ing it, I'd refurbish the calipers myself, but this would cost about £30 a side in parts and an hours labour each.

Other thing to bear in mind is they'll have supplied the parts at RRP, whereas the ones on ebay will be discounted.

Personally, I'd have DIY'd it.

  • Author
and for the record i have used a spoon once to get a bolt off

:lol: quality!

yeti: i asked them to give me a quote before work comenced, they told me around £80 depending on how much copper would be needed, which i though wasnt a bad price (didnt want to diy it for 2 reasons, 1; i'd rather get a garage to do the brake lines, so i have some come-back if anything bad happened and 2; the weather is horrid at the mo, so i'd rather not be working outside, freezing my butt off for the sake of £80)

my main beef with it all is that one caliper was fine and the lad doing the work, almost appeared to snap the nipple off on purpose! no heat or wd40 was even considered, he just yanked it as hard as he could and suprise, surprise it snapped.

it would have probably come loose had he heated it a small amount and tapped it round with a mallet, rather than applying a constant load till the damn thing sheared!

fine we've come to the conclusion that 2 hours labour is probably reasonable, but i simple cant get my head around having to pay for something that the supposed mechanic broke.

i'd be pretty pissed if i had to pay for some thing that some one else broke. my mate was having some engine work done by a place once and they phoned him up and told him they had dropped his head while working on it and he would have to pay another £400 for them to replace it :lol:

i'd be pretty pissed if i had to pay for some thing that some one else broke. my mate was having some engine work done by a place once and they phoned him up and told him they had dropped his head while working on it and he would have to pay another £400 for them to replace it :lol:

fuck that!! id make them buy it as it was there fault or sue there asses so going american style sue sue sue sue sue lol

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.