Skip to content

small car Vs large car

Featured Replies

yo mo fo's

I'm car hunting for my 2nd polo at the minute. I've been told to get a bigger car like a golf or something.

fuck that! i love my mk4 and i shall be buying a mk6. its not like i have a big family to fit in it. just me and our lass!

do most people upsize or downsize i wonder.

I've seen quite a few people on the forum wanting to trade their golfs for polos lately.

  • Replies 58
  • Views 5.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Smaller cars usually get better mpg due to weight, easier to park, but are less comofrtable(try and find a hatchback with the same level of comfort as the old 5 series!).

I Had A Mk4 Golf..

Got A Mk3 Polo Now..

Big Golf's Are No Fun..

Id rather have a MK2 Golf than a 9n Polo - the considerably lighter car is the Golf,and its more responsive and more fun to drive (by experience).

So yeah,weight is the main factor for me. But that doesn't mean smaller cars when the 9n is as heavy as a Ford Sierra.

I came from a Corrado to a 6N2 1.4 TDI cause I wanted some thing as an economic daily hack. I have to say I'm well impressed with it so far (6 days in), build quality seems good and the cabin is a nice place to be. While not as fun to drive as the Corrado it's proving to be insanely frugal and quite a laugh. Certainly the £180 a month I'll be saving in Fuel/insurance/tax costs will be gratefully thrown at my track car.

Nick

smaller cars feel quicker in the cabin than larger cars, and mk5s and below are great for handling. my polo feels like a go kart round corners :lol:

  • Author
smaller cars feel quicker in the cabin than larger cars, and mk5s and below are great for handling. my polo feels like a go kart round corners :lol:

whats wrong with mk6 and above?!

I went from a Beemer 735 to an 1.4 6n and haven't looked back!

The Beemer had a really comfortable drive and all the toys you could want, but it just WASN'T fun!

mk6s and above are going over 1ton mark, thats with the lighter engines, add deisel engines and handling become more like a jeep :p

  • Author

I'm after a mk6 gt tdi. hope that hadles better than a jeep!

I'm after a mk6 gt tdi. hope that hadles better than a jeep!

the gt's power make up for the handling :lol:

best setting some cash aside for handling upgrades then :roll:

smaller cars feel quicker in the cabin than larger cars, and mk5s and below are great for handling. my polo feels like a go kart round corners :lol:

Older Polo's have really bad handling tbh.

mk6s and above are going over 1ton mark, thats with the lighter engines, add deisel engines and handling become more like a jeep :p

Mk5 1.0 = 982kg

1 UK tonne = 907.18474kg (A metric/USA tonne is 1000kg)

review_DJRWEZ.jpg

I'm after a mk6 gt tdi. hope that hadles better than a jeep!

For me it's all about how "epic" the journey was. I hate cars that bore you to death. Yes my mk3 polo wants to throw me in a ditch at times, but it all ads to the "epic" ride. :-D

Id rather have less weight and less power. I keep telling my golfy mates.

One friend in particular keeps banging on about putting a 2.0L 16v in his small engine mounts mk1 golf and i keep protesting that surely a small block 1500 g60/turbo has to be a more fun approach, due to less weight.

I've came from a top of the range cdx vectra with all the mod con with was well nice to a mk4 6n polo and i love the polo i do miss all the mod cons but the fuel i save is amazing lol 2ltr to a 1.4 is well good cost me like 35 quid to fill up my polo where my vectra was 70 quid

For me it's all about how "epic" the journey was. I hate cars that bore you to death. Yes my mk3 polo wants to throw me in a ditch at times, but it all ads to the "epic" ride. :-D

Id rather have less weight and less power. I keep telling my golfy mates.

One friend in particular keeps banging on about putting a 2.0L 16v in his small engine mounts mk1 golf and i keep protesting that surely a small block 1500 g60/turbo has to be a more fun approach, due to less weight.

and u say about big engie in small cars i had a 2ltr 16v nova and i tell u something that was well gooooood to drive reall really quick but was like a boat on corners i could leave scooby and things like that standing coz it was a shed lol but big engines in small cars are wicked

  • Author
I'm after a mk6 gt tdi. hope that hadles better than a jeep!

the gt's power make up for the handling :lol:

best setting some cash aside for handling upgrades then :roll:

oh yes :-D

mk6s and above are going over 1ton mark, thats with the lighter engines, add deisel engines and handling become more like a jeep :p

Mk5 1.0 = 982kg

1 UK tonne = 907.18474kg (A metric/USA tonne is 1000kg)

Sorry to be 'that guy' but a Tonne is, has always been and always will be 1000 kg

A British Ton is 1016.0469088 kg

A US Ton is 907.18474 kg

So unless he was talking about a US Ton (which i'm pretty sure he wasn't) he's correct.

review_DJRWEZ.jpg

yeah i agree a tonne is 1000kg i work on the bins and my lorry can onl take 26000kg with is 26 tonne

i hate mk4 and mk 3 golfs! mk4 is the worst car ever built! such a ugly fat slug!!!!!! :thumbsdown:

I learned to drive in a new suzuki swift 1.3 and that was pretty slow and handled like a DFS sofa now I've passed I'm in a mk2 square and I fucking love it standard 1.3 can do naughty speeds on local lanes. Small cars with small engines = WIN

Becuase ripping home from work in a large car is no fun, when some businessman idiot see's a little polo boosting up his piece and and his beemer/audi etc cannot shake the little shit box its make me smile :)

I shamed an Audi A6 3.0 v6 on a country lane this morning, small cars with huge engines are just too serious I'm afraid

i have upsized and downsized many times, bora to arosa, astra van to polo etc etc.

i traded my 220bhp golf g60 rallye for a g40 + wedge, the rallye was a great car but it bored me to death where the g40 wasn't the fastest thing in the world but as g40 owners know the lightness combined with rubbish handling and brakes makes it feel like you are doing 100 @ 60mph.

bigger cars really lose that feel, bmw's always seem to catch me out - you'll be cruising along look at the speedo and think fook me though i was doing 40 not 65!!

later vw's weight really take the fun out of driving and for some reason every new mark of polo / golf etc they get bigger and heavier.

my bora has plenty of power and is very comfy but fun - NO it's heavy and you know it, no real feedback when driving either. for out and out speed it's fine but i'd rather have a slammed 1.0 arosa for a point to point run down country roads and round the twisties.

Olly

smaller cars feel quicker in the cabin than larger cars, and mk5s and below are great for handling. my polo feels like a go kart round corners :lol:

Older Polo's have really bad handling tbh.

I cannot disagree anymore.My MK5 Polo GTI handles a dream and thats on a standard setup.I live near alot of country lanes and my car handles lovely through there,grips very well and good speed can be carried through corners.As for the older models poor handling could be the case.

The 9N Polo range are alittle heavier that the older ones (MK5 and below),thats why people are alittle put off them but then models like the GTI have a much more powerful engine to compensate for the extra weight.I'm sure if you bought a TDI and had alittle money aside for a few other bits you could increase the handling and have just as much fun mate.

Brad

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.