Skip to content

small car Vs large car

Featured Replies

older cars feel faster coz they are generally more rattly and dont feel like they should go fast

and smaller cabin size makes the car feel faster aswell

low weight and decent power can make a car feel quite quick but nothing compares to decent weight balance and actual good handling

  • Replies 58
  • Views 5.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

When people say Polos don't handle well what are they comparing it to?

Or are they just saying it in general as in you can feel the car understeering et cetera.

drive something that handles well sometime and you will understand :)

Let's be honest chaps small low power cars are fun because you have to put more effort in and when you weave through those country lanes and put all that effort in to driving it genuinely feels rewarding. You can't say that about a big powerful car as its so easy to drive with enough power on tap to make things comfortable you don't get that sense of achievement that you would in a tiny little polo and to me polos handle good enough and I've driven an elise!(trackday)

^^ Yep. Here's a fact of life - the more you put in,the more you get out. Hard work pays dividends and the case is reflected in driving - either the car is carrying you in a sphere of cotton wool,or you're working it like a gymnasium. The latter gets your blood rushing. As for the former,I've got a sofa at home.

I agree that thrashing a small car around is fun, but sometimes I wish it would be better at motorway driving. It makes a hell of a racket above 60 with wind noise and engine noise (> 3,000 RPM), and I feel like I'm pushing the poor thing too hard.

As a 1.3 with standard 5-speed 8p box,mine was okay on motorways. Is yours a four speed then?

You can get longer ratios if you're alright with the spanners.

I've had a 1.0l mk3 polo and now I'm driving a mk2 golf GTi.

I have to say, as much as I STILL love polos, I'm glad I've got the golf, its not that quick really but pulls really nice and handles a million times better than my polo did... and its got the ancient standard suspension still. I did have a 1.6 mk2 golf before the GTi, had that on coilovers and it handled like a dream. couldnt really faul it in any way. Also, I find u get a little more respect on the road if you are in a bigger car, people will move out of you are way more lol.

But, having said that, id rather have a GT'd loon than my GTi anyday :p

@ random badger.

u only like polos over golfs because you've whored polo parts your whole life and cba to sell them :p

Or are they just saying it in general as in you can feel the car understeering et cetera.

Feeling the car understeer is a good thing, far too many modern cars are so numb you can't feel what the front tyres are doing.

I've had a MKII Loon and now a MKV hatch and both have handled pretty well although admitadly they both have modified suspension. The MKII was lowered and stiff as hell and was pretty chuckable. The MKV is running Koni top adjustables (Set one turn back from full hardness), drop 40mm springs and has the front wishbones stitch welded with all new OE bushes. Handling on this is not far off that of my track car (Which has a very similar setup but with Poly instead of OE bushes).

Nick

Get more repect on the road having a bigger car?

I only stop for other Vags.

And the Point leonh made, spot on in my opinion, well done that man!

I have been thinking hard and long about what to do when I'm 21 next July, do i go for a Bora, corrado or stick with my 6n and put a G40 lump in?

Conclusion, G40 lump. You only live once.

As a 1.3 with standard 5-speed 8p box,mine was okay on motorways. Is yours a four speed then?

You can get longer ratios if you're alright with the spanners.

No, 5 speed.

It just makes a lot of noise in 5th at 70mph (~3,200rpm) and it starts to really wear after a while. Probably shouldn't have removed the sound insulation, but a lot of that is wind noise too.

As a 1.3 with standard 5-speed 8p box,mine was okay on motorways. Is yours a four speed then?

You can get longer ratios if you're alright with the spanners.

No, 5 speed.

It just makes a lot of noise in 5th at 70mph (~3,200rpm) and it starts to really wear after a while. Probably shouldn't have removed the sound insulation, but a lot of that is wind noise too.

Drive at 65if its that bad SMALL CARS=WIN. And I also only stop for VAGs

Yeh I find it annoying too and I've only got a 4 speed box :(. Feels like I'm murdering the car at anything over 60 :/.

@ random badger.

u only like polos over golfs because you've whored polo parts your whole life and cba to sell them :p

And.. there was a reason I whored polo parts not Golf parts :retard:

Main reason is Mk1's fetch huge scene tax, and that's the only mk of Golf i'd ever really want to own, cause the others just got heavier and a mk1 golf is still heavier than a mk2 polo, so epic factor is already down :thumbsdown:

Perfect example of "epic" factor though, corrado G60 bigger, faster, decent handling.. boring, polo G40, smaller slower, worse handling, epic!

Mk1 golf 1.3 driver with P&P head, dellorto 40's and a 4spd box still more epic than a mk2 GTI 8v even though it has less power!

It's all about the epic, being in control is boring, understeering off a roundabout at 70 is epic :badgrin:

Mikeys got it, hard work pays dividends.

Anyhow fuck buying a heavier front wheel drive car, it's gonna be rear wheel or all-wheel driven when i decide i need more weight.

Also, I find u get a little more respect on the road if you are in a bigger car, people will move out of you are way more lol.

I'm with Quicksilver Jake on this one, fuck respect, it's much more fun suprising people in "conventionally fast cars"!

Edited by randombadger69

lighter is better :thumbsup:

i wanted my car to be like a gokart with a shell, and that is how it drives.

i drive my dads x5 from time to time (which for a car of its size handles very well!) and that is nice for long highway miles, but for anything else,

i would always choose my car.

smaller is better!

@ random badger.

u only like polos over golfs because you've whored polo parts your whole life and cba to sell them :p

And.. there was a reason I whored polo parts not Golf parts :retard:

Main reason is Mk1's fetch huge scene tax, and that's the only mk of Golf i'd ever really want to own, cause the others just got heavier and a mk1 golf is still heavier than a mk2 polo, so epic factor is already down :thumbsdown:

Perfect example of "epic" factor though, corrado G60 bigger, faster, decent handling.. boring, polo G40, smaller slower, worse handling, epic!

Mk1 golf 1.3 driver with P&P head, dellorto 40's and a 4spd box still more epic than a mk2 GTI 8v even though it has less power!

It's all about the epic, being in control is boring, understeering off a roundabout at 70 is epic :badgrin:

Mikeys got it, hard work pays dividends.

Anyhow fuck buying a heavier front wheel drive car, it's gonna be rear wheel or all-wheel driven when i decide i need more weight.

Also, I find u get a little more respect on the road if you are in a bigger car, people will move out of you are way more lol.

I'm with Quicksilver Jake on this one, fuck respect, it's much more fun suprising people in "conventionally fast cars"!

so you are saying westys mk2 isnt epic? and think what the outcome is likely to be when u understeer off a roundabout into another car at 70mph in a polo? I think i would rather be in my golf tbh...

I'm not saying small cars aren't fun, but how many golfs have you owned? I've owned a polo remember, albeit a 1.0l, and yes I know what you mean about being able to throw them round corners etc, but as it is, I prefer my 8v GTi, it puts a smile on my face without munching its way through laders and gearboxes, its more comfortable, pulls nicely and handles ok even on the ancient springs and shocks, the only thing that pisses me off is that the TAX is higher. And I'm sure I'll get over that.

Having said that I've never owned a quick polo (being a passenger is hair raising to say the least ;):thumbsup: ) so I could be very wrong in my opinions, but I'm still entitled to them.

Also andy, in the wise words of william webster.....ill cut u :ninja: :grin: anyway what been up to not seen u in ages? :smoke:

Edited by Matt Mk3loon

so you are saying westys mk2 isnt epic?

It wasn't very epic out the box before he completely rebuilt the engine and spent about 2k plus doing so. 126bhp at the wheels is a few more than 112 at the flywheel in 1989! Iv been in many a standard mk2 8v but never owned one becuase they don't do it for me.

Also andy, in the wise words of william webster.....ill cut u

Or at least you would if you could keep up in your big heavy golfy :-p:lol:

anyway what been up to not seen u in ages? :smoke:

Making my red polo more "epic"..

Edited by randombadger69

Also andy, in the wise words of william webster.....ill cut u

Or at least you would if you could keep up in your big heavy golfy :-p:lol:

Not with your head weighing you down I'm gonna be stabbing u a goodun :roll:

How much further have you got with it then? Is the block all painted up with plenty of coats now?

Also andy, in the wise words of william webster.....ill cut u

Or at least you would if you could keep up in your big heavy golfy :-p:lol:

Not with your head weighing you down I'm gonna be stabbing u a goodun :roll:

How much further have you got with it then? Is the block all painted up with plenty of coats now?

The larger volume doesn't weigh any more! The trolley jack in the back does though.

Blocks painted, rods came out last night, need new big-end shells and piston rings, and all the rest of it!

Just ordered the shells, 40 quid a set, apparently the MH piston rings may well be the same, so i might be poncing those out of my mk2 rebuild pile for now!

Edited by randombadger69

Maybe I'm just being a bit too cautious with the car, do you drive your 5 speed around 3.3k rpm?

its not the size, it's what you do with it.

My old Suzuki Whizzkid was 45BHP but weighing only 650KG was epic fun (that and being RWD)

And as for the G40 - just being able to wipe the smile off reps' face's in there beemers does it for me!

"less is more"

:p

Although thinking about it I would like an old Land Rover turbo diesel. Or a Mk2 Passat. Other than that though, small VWs win for me.

I had a mk4 golf and am now driving a mk4 polo. Although the golf was faster and alot more comfortable, i have to say i just love the 6n polo (Y)

I've got a mk4 golf, feels like a slug compared to my mates fez zetec s and on paper my golf is a lot faster...wtf? lol

Looking for a mk5 gti as i have a 6n 1.0l as my first car and i loved ever second so getting the big boys version should be a lot more fun, especially looking at what people have been saying about the mk5's handling!! :-D

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.