Skip to content

should we put an end to "how much is it worth" threads?

should we put an end to "how much is it worth" threads? 78 members have voted

  1. 1. should we put an end to "how much is it worth" threads?

    • Yes
      61%
      48
    • No
      10%
      8
    • I'm not really that bothered
      28%
      22

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

Just curious on peoples views, i see them clutter the forum all the time, and at end of the day, a simple search on ebay, forums, gives you a rough idea how much the car is worth anyway.

Everybody has a rough idea how much their car is worth, i sometimes think asking is a bit of a waste of time

what does the world of club polo think!?

  • Replies 37
  • Views 3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

the same could be said about numerous threads tbh.

Edited by dub17

Put an end to feelers aswel.

This is the real world.

You can't say, "Oh this is just a feeler but I'll let it go for the right price"

FFS just put that "right price" up then in the first place.

No one is ever going to seriously make offers on "feelers" either due to the item in question potentially not being for sale.

  • Author

i know alot of posts are repetitive, but i just think the whats it worth ones happen all the time

Yes.

For sure. It really isn't hard to look through old adverts or ebay completed items.

For sure. It really isn't hard to look through old adverts or ebay completed items.

Thats what really grinds my gears.

They post up on here because they cannot be fucked to go and find out for themselves, pure lazyness if you ask me.

Its like the other threads that are always made that are the same.

And should reuslt in a ban if they haven't searched the internet for at least an hour.

Edited by dub17

^second that! ^ I f-ing hate them "how much could I charge for my mkX?"-topics, just put it up for sale, and you'll find out sooner or later!

I totally agree. If I were to sell my polo I'd just have a ratch around eBay, Autotrader and pistonheads to see what similar polos are going for.

It's not rocket science.

Oooooo, get Dan with his democratic forum improvements!

I'm all for it, top stuff.

  • Author

I'm not saying anything will be done lol

just curious on everyones views, it does seem very lazy, but i suppose sometimes you have to take into account, how many posts the user has made, as some people do genuinely have no idea, but again, search function answers all!

I agree 100 %.

Surely its a lot less effort to just go to the online classifieds and find a car like yours as opposed to starting a whole new topic and waiting for a reply.

i voted yes, as said its just a bit lazy.

another thing that really gets to me though is when people just put offers in there for sale thread instead of a price. can't we have some thing like edition where you have to put a price up or it gets deleted? other wise you end up with a page and a half of people asking what they what for it and the seller saying "i don't know what its worth". every one has a figure of what they would let some thing go for so post it up, if you want it to go for as much as you can get for it then put it on ebay.

rant over :lol:

Poll results thus far say everything tbh

i voted yes, as said its just a bit lazy.

another thing that really gets to me though is when people just put offers in there for sale thread instead of a price. can't we have some thing like edition where you have to put a price up or it gets deleted? other wise you end up with a page and a half of people asking what they what for it and the seller saying "i don't know what its worth". every one has a figure of what they would let some thing go for so post it up, if you want it to go for as much as you can get for it then put it on ebay.

rant over :lol:

I think we do, seems it only gets enforced for me though, I posted a feeler for my BBS RS as I genuinely haven't seen any in the same condition, they are all either fucked or just refurbed, it was deleted within a few hours, however, I see feelers/'offers' with multiple replies all the time, seems like a lack of consistency. I don't care if I can or can not post feelers, I'd just like the rules to apply to everyone.

I voted I'm not bothered, because I'm not.

I have never seen it to be a problem.

Yes.

X2

Two sides to this,from where I'm standing.

Its not always so simple to figure a value,for many of us have things which are unusual and cant just flick open the local Auto Trader and find one alike. Something's only worth what someone else is prepared to pay for it,and that someone can be hard to find.

But such feeler threads just shout 'fishing' to me. Like either put an ad up or dont,instead of filling half of General Cars and Polo Chat with mock scene tax auctioning..

I voted Yes. Put an end to "feelers" and "whats it worth" posts! Do it!

I also agree with McLOVIN on For Sale posts with no price.

I agree with Mikey, for your everyday 6n or 6n2 with general miles then it is easy to make a general guess by justing going onto Autotrader and Ebay etc.

But with the old Polo's you don't really get such a good guess to the fact that you don't find as many.

Therefore I voted, No.

it not hard to compare the car you have to others similar...

pisses me off alot tbh..

put it up for a stupid price then drop it down until some one buys it...

but its only worth what someones willing to pay.

I agree with Mikey, for your everyday 6n or 6n2 with general miles then it is easy to make a general guess by justing going onto Autotrader and Ebay etc.

But with the old Polo's you don't really get such a good guess to the fact that you don't find as many.

Therefore I voted, No.

the for sale section is full of them :lol:

  • Author

what also is annoying when people vote and dont back up their vote with a reason lol

i really cant see any point at all for them, more i think about it, cutmore you voted no, for the reason of old polos and not knowing a rough price, but again the question is "whats the most i dare ask for this car"

everyone has a rough price on every item they own, now posting and asking a forum how much it is worth, is only going to get you a ever more so vague price idea, as everyones views are different, so the whole thing is pointless?

for example the 6n2 gti thread thats going at minute, the fact the guy askign the question says later he had £2800 in his head, so why ask then?

£4300

£3000

£3000-3500

£2500

£2000

£2300

£2000

£1500

£2500

I mean the variation is quite big, so the whole thread is, pointless.

couldnt give a monkeys.

I don't think you can say either way tbh... i agree with mikey.

Yes if someone has a bog standard GTI with 60k on the clock then it's not hard to look on pistonheads / autotrader / phone a garage but for me for example (and no i haven't asked!) but if i did ask how much you "think" my car is worth with these mods then i can't see why anyone would have an issue with that.

This forum isn't crazily busy so i don't see it as "clogginig" and tbf if your not interested in giving a valuation then don't bother opening the thread!

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.