Skip to content

should club polo have a feedback section

49 members have voted

  1. 1. shoul we have feedback section

    • yes
      89%
      44
    • no
      10%
      5

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

bringing this up to help us spot unreiliable sellers

Edited by CHRIS2911

  • Replies 25
  • Views 2.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

This has already been discussed i'm sure mate...

Has it? I say yes to a feedback section.

hmm, i think it could work, but it would have to be heavily moderated, i was all for one, but then after a bit of thinking, the easiest way is if you buy an item, post on the end of the for sale thread, how the sale went, "received item all fine" then click the report button to inform us the sale is done, we lock it, item sold.

Then if someone thinks about buying from the same person, he can search his posts, find the feedback.

I always do research on people i buy from, force of habit!

and Chris, i know you had a bad deal with that benbrew guy, by the way did he ever reply?

but bad transactions are not that often, so on that alone i dont think it warrants it

Yes to this!

I have one seller I could mention right now, who is still active selling bits off of his car so wouldn't want anyone else to go through the hassle and annoyance at the loss of money for something you won't recieve!

Also, the people who are saying no.....would you like to put your reason across?

i was one that voted no, for my points above really

  • Author

or possibly name/shame section

A disputes section where sales have not been completed. Bit like what was suggested above.

I voted No so i can keep scamming people from the other end of the country and get away with it.

:lol: :lol: ^^

I aint voted, mainly due to the fact i haven't bought anything yet.

But i suppose it would be a good thing, but then again, comment sense surely has to come into it alot.

or possibly name/shame section

It will just be covered with my name as i can only post things on Saturday (Sometimes) so people have to wait a few weeks. Even when i tell people before they buy they get pissy and cry.

  • Author
or possibly name/shame section

It will just be covered with my name as i can only post things on Saturday (Sometimes) so people have to wait a few weeks. Even when i tell people before they buy they get pissy and cry.

dont mind waiting for items aslong as the seller communicates with me.

I'll quite happily give a buyer full contact details if they wish.

Sometimes I can't post bits quick as I share a car with my other half so sometimes I'm stuck at home.

I paid for dash speakers last early last week.

same day as I paid for side indi's from Po*Low*

Receives the indi's with communication throughout, But no sign of speakers and no emails back off the seller although he has been posting even today on different threads.

Wonder whether to name and shame,

or wait a bit longer?

On a bike forum i use we have the feedback system and is very useful, it just helps when purchasing something or selling. However TBH everyone could use some common sense, see up to date pictures, dated by a camera ETC, always ask for recorded delivery ETC that way you have something to fall back on.

I am all game for it.

i think what will help is a buyers guide, I'm going to get one stuck up in the for sale section, just with a bit of a helpful guide on how to cover yourself a bit more

There's nothing really I can do now thought is there?

Tbh I think a points system would be best for this, rather than having an open forum for disputes (will give a negative image to general visitors).

In theory it is a good idea, but i dont think it will practically work. I would imagine the server would get over crouded with lots and lots of rants and comments about other memeber, but it would also overload the moderators and Co with thread locking and all that sort. As a buyer on a site like this legally speaking you are introducing an offer to the seller to enter into a contract with them. By the seller advertising doesnt binde them into a contract immideietly if someone replies stating they wish to buy the item. The seller would first have to consider this offer and accept it, to be legally bound. So, in such circumstances like this, as a buyer, even though it is quite hard to police purchases from this sort of site, you pretty much have to excercise common sense and vigilance. Try to protect yourself as best as possible, for example; get recorded delivery sufficiently enough that insures the cost of the item and try to get sellers details before payment. Certainly would be easier to enforce a civil suit. Or do your research before you buy.

Points systems like feedback on ebay that attaches the history to a member doesnt stop them making a new username and continuing scamming people. Its too hard to maintain this type of thing. Itll probably just open a flood gate to complaints and deter people from purchasing or using the forum...unfortunatly.

(it should also probably be noted that I'm a bit of a sinic, so maybe my sinicism clouds my judgement of the human race :))

Edited by goosyganger

But if someones seen to be scamming people, their IP address can be blocked to ensure they dont open a new account to continue.

But if someones seen to be scamming people, their IP address can be blocked to ensure they dont open a new account to continue.

Internet cafes, university computers, Work, mates houses, and thats probably just a few ways they could get around that. But not sure as I'm not too clued up on computers.

i think the only answer is to have a guide, and if you buy an item, and the seller pissed you about etc

post this on the end of the for sale thread, then if someone else does the groundwork to look into someone before buying, they will get a better idea

we are putting together a "buyers guide" at the minute, so if you follow the buyers guide, I'm 99% sure you wont get scammed, and if you do, you will be covered!

I would say yes to a feedback area, but if not, why don't we have a rating system for people, +1 for a good sale / buy, and -1 for bad.

I've bought a few cars off here, and 2 of them have had some pretty serious problems with them, both of which you can't identify on inspection, unless you pull the car apart, or the seller is honest, which is all too rare in this day and age.

Something needs to happen, because too many people are getting shat on, but naming and shaming, along with blocking IP addresses / email addresses / hostname etc. is the only way to make sure they can't do it again as easily.

A buyers guide isn't going to help if the fault isn't obvious, but will highlight a lot of areas for the lesser knowledgeable potential buyers. I'm not saying it's a bad idea, but people need to know if there's a dodgy fecker scamming all the time.

Edited by donnyburger

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.