Skip to content

which polo?

Featured Replies

I'm currently looking to get a polo but I'm torn between the mk3 or mk4 could anybody give me the pro's and con's of each one, how they are to drive etc...

bearing in mind i would be using it everyday to go to work :)

thanks :)

gazzzie

  • Replies 54
  • Views 3.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

What models you gona be looking at? what can you insure for example you comparing a 1.4 8v & 1.3 SPI or a GT and 1.4 16v?

  • Author
I'm currently looking to get a polo but I'm torn between the mk3 or mk4 could anybody give me the pro's and con's of each one, how they are to drive etc...

bearing in mind i would be using it everyday to go to work :)

thanks :)

gazzzie

dont think i would be going for a gt or 16v, i currently drive a 106 1.1 :( so i'd want something with PAS and electric windows :p as my car is base spec although i did change the interior :)

If u want those mod cons its gona have to be a MK4 then "CL" spec or higher

  • Author
I'm currently looking to get a polo but I'm torn between the mk3 or mk4 could anybody give me the pro's and con's of each one, how they are to drive etc...

bearing in mind i would be using it everyday to go to work :)

thanks :)

gazzzie

dont think i would be going for a gt or 16v, i currently drive a 106 1.1 :( so i'd want something with PAS and electric windows :p as my car is base spec although i did change the interior :)

thanks, but i really like the look of the mk3 seems to have a meaner look about it. i suppose i could live without the luxuries if it drives nice

Going on wanting PAS and electric windows, a Mk4 is the obvious choice.

Other than that, I can't really say anything as I like them both. This is going to be such a crazy thread come this evening lol.. I think you have just sparked off another Mk3 / Mk4 debate.. pretty WWIII :lol:

If you want it for speed/nippiness, I would get a Mk3 as they are much lighter with similar grunt, but with a Mk4 you get a few more creature comforts that are associated with 'newer' cars. All depends on what you want.

  • Author
Going on wanting PAS and electric windows, a Mk4 is the obvious choice.

Other than that, I can't really say anything as I like them both. This is going to be such a crazy thread come this evening lol.. I think you have just sparked off another Mk3 / Mk4 debate.. pretty WWIII :lol:

If you want it for speed/nippiness, I would get a Mk3 as they are much lighter with similar grunt, but with a Mk4 you get a few more creature comforts that are associated with 'newer' cars. All depends on what you want.

oh dear. :D what sort of prices would i be looking at for a decentish mk3 compared to the mk4?

MK3 1 litre or 1.3 SPI say £500 for a decent one with long T&T?

MK4 1 litre or 1.4 8v id say around £750 for a good one

what do you want to use the car for? If you doing loads of miles just go for a MK4 for comfort etc

  • Author

ooooh, i guess i best get trying to sell my car then and save up a little :)

The mk3 is more fun to drive than a mk4 (standard vs standard)

The mk3 feels more like a car, very basic but they don't need luxuries like PAS or EW, they are a light car so have light steering and windy windows aren't that hard to use.

A mk4 will give you your luxuries and may be comfier day to day but they aren't really fun...and they suffer badly from the rust bug and don't look as nice as a standard mk3.

if you like actualy driving, mk3, if your abit of a fanny and cant handle it mk4

oh dear this thread is gonna start yet another debate!!!

if you like actualy driving, mk3, if your abit of a fanny and cant handle it mk4

If you want people to ask why your driving an old banger, get a MK3.

if you like actualy driving, mk3, if your abit of a fanny and cant handle it mk4

If you want people to ask why your driving an old banger, get a MK3.

OOOOHHH!

its on now lol.

seriously though, the Mk4 is the shittest car I have ever driven. The power steering is heavy, the clutch is dull and you can't feel the bite, the throttle is either on or off and takes a good second to respond.

i haven't even driven a Mk3 and I would say it's a better car to drive!

if you like actualy driving, mk3, if your abit of a fanny and cant handle it mk4

If you want people to ask why your driving an old banger, get a MK3.

if your an insecure pansy get a mk4

I've had a quick tuned gt and i have a quick tuned 16v

imo a minter of a mk3 is a win always!!!!!!

if you like actualy driving, mk3, if your abit of a fanny and cant handle it mk4

If you want people to ask why your driving an old banger, get a MK3.

if your an insecure pansy get a mk4

i thought indy had a mk5

regardless

everyone on this forum is a fag

if your blind, get a mk3

Fuck them both, and go for a MKII. Better looks, but practically the same car as the MKIII

Retro Rides FTW!

mk3 ftw almost indistructable (unless heavily moddified or a g40) plus look so much better than a mk4

so i'd want something with PAS and electric windows

So surely there is only one car for him, on his budget, the mk4...

  • Author
so i'd want something with PAS and electric windows

So surely there is only one car for him, on his budget, the mk4...

i never said anything about my budget lol from what i've read i'm thinking more about a mk3

having owned both, mk4 engine and box seemed nicer, but on the whole the mk3 was nicer to drive

MK3 1 litre or 1.3 SPI say £500 for a decent one with long T&T?

MK4 1 litre or 1.4 8v id say around £750 for a good one

what do you want to use the car for? If you doing loads of miles just go for a MK4 for comfort etc

ooooh, i guess i best get trying to sell my car then and save up a little :)

That suggests to me you have a budget of less than £750 since you claim you need to save up once you have sold your car.

MK3 1 litre or 1.3 SPI say £500 for a decent one with long T&T?

MK4 1 litre or 1.4 8v id say around £750 for a good one

what do you want to use the car for? If you doing loads of miles just go for a MK4 for comfort etc

ooooh, i guess i best get trying to sell my car then and save up a little :)

That suggests to me you have a budget of less than £750 since you claim you need to save up once you have sold your car.

Yeah but he could also be on a budget of less than £500.. and then the Mk4 wouldn't be suitable at all.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.