Skip to content

which polo?

Featured Replies

mk3 ftw almost indistructable (unless heavily moddified or a g40) plus look so much better than a mk4

Unit you crash it and watch it fold in half.

I'd only get a mk3 if it was a G40.

  • Replies 54
  • Views 3.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

mk3 ftw almost indistructable (unless heavily moddified or a g40) plus look so much better than a mk4

Unit you crash it and watch it fold in half.

I'd only get a mk3 if it was a G40.

To be fair, I would say the Mk4 wouldn't be much better with the amount of rust these things get!

Plus the airbags never seem to go off in them when crashed.. they might be 'newer' than a Mk3 but they are both still old cars.

Only benefit is that Mk4 parts are much easier to source.

  • Author
MK3 1 litre or 1.3 SPI say £500 for a decent one with long T&T?

MK4 1 litre or 1.4 8v id say around £750 for a good one

what do you want to use the car for? If you doing loads of miles just go for a MK4 for comfort etc

ooooh, i guess i best get trying to sell my car then and save up a little :)

That suggests to me you have a budget of less than £750 since you claim you need to save up once you have sold your car.

fair enough, i meant id save up till i sold my car lol :)

mk3 ftw almost indistructable (unless heavily moddified or a g40) plus look so much better than a mk4

Unit you crash it and watch it fold in half.

I'd only get a mk3 if it was a G40.

To be fair, I would say the Mk4 wouldn't be much better with the amount of rust these things get!

Plus the airbags never seem to go off in them when crashed.. they might be 'newer' than a Mk3 but they are both still old cars.

Only benefit is that Mk4 parts are much easier to source.

lol the mk4 is much better in a crash than a mk3! and I didnt realise the only polo that rusts was the mk4 so the rust must be painted on mk1.2.3's??

mk3 ftw almost indistructable (unless heavily moddified or a g40) plus look so much better than a mk4

Unit you crash it and watch it fold in half.

I'd only get a mk3 if it was a G40.

To be fair, I would say the Mk4 wouldn't be much better with the amount of rust these things get!

Plus the airbags never seem to go off in them when crashed.. they might be 'newer' than a Mk3 but they are both still old cars.

Only benefit is that Mk4 parts are much easier to source.

lol the mk4 is much better in a crash than a mk3! and I didnt realise the only polo that rusts was the mk4 so the rust must be painted on mk1.2.3's??

haha i know - i'm not trying to say Mk4 is the only VW that rusts (I've got a beetle lol)

what i meant to say was that compared to newer cars, the differences in a crash between a Mk4 and Mk3 aren't going to be that great.

so if you are buying a Mk4 over a Mk3 just because its 'better in a crash' then its kind of a waste..

i would say from my experience the mk3 is very fun to drive but the mk4 is more comforable but still fun, and the CL has a few more mod cons, both are known to rot and both are cheap to run, both are better made than your pug and both will be lighter to steer than your pug that probably weighs less!, my birds 106, 1.5 diesel is like steering a brick! they are both cool in my opinion (except the breadvans) again in my opinion, have a look round the galleries first see which you prefere and then read up on what problems each has and make you are informed decision!

  • Author
i would say from my experience the mk3 is very fun to drive but the mk4 is more comforable but still fun, and the CL has a few more mod cons, both are known to rot and both are cheap to run, both are better made than your pug and both will be lighter to steer than your pug that probably weighs less!, my birds 106, 1.5 diesel is like steering a brick! they are both cool in my opinion (except the breadvans) again in my opinion, have a look round the galleries first see which you prefere and then read up on what problems each has and make you are informed decision!

cheers probably the best reply I've had. my pug is hard to steer, especially with the alloys i have on it, even on the standard wheels its quite heavy, so its a right hassle to park into a tight space

I own a Mk3 Fox and my Dad has a Mk4 1.4 CL. I prefer the Mk3... feels more natural, prefer the looks. Power steering and abs... you don't NEED those ;).

I have an mk4 1.4l and i wouldn't trade it for a mk3, unless it was a g40 or perhaps a GT coupe. Bear in mind I have the lowest spec one with no abs, no power steering, no electric windows etc. When i crashed it, it held up pretty well, airbag didn't go off though.

My mk4 only has 2 tiny rust patches as well, on the door pillar and rear pillar, so if looked after i don't think they rot that bad really.

no if looked after and garaged etc they will rot slower, but they are the last non galvanised polos so there gonna rust worse than 6n2s and above

if you like actualy driving, mk3, if your abit of a fanny and cant handle it mk4

If you want people to ask why your driving an old banger, get a MK3.

Get a mk5 - If you want to be a complete fag and moan about everything , Unless your getting a gti !?

if your blind, get a mk3

Could say exactly the same for mk4 but, 1.4cl sounds like what your after they are cheap to get coilovers for, cheap tax insurance etc . You dont really want a mk3 unless its a Gt or G40 which it doesnt sound like you have the money for/ can insure?

Jake :)

Edited by quiksilver_jake

if you like actualy driving, mk3, if your abit of a fanny and cant handle it mk4

If you want people to ask why your driving an old banger, get a MK3.

Who gives a fk what other people think? The same people would probably ask why you drive a granny car with a kids climbing frame in the boot. :lol:

I generally avoid mk3's (except GT's.... I don't like G40s) and 4's because compared to a German Mk2, the build isn't all that. I'd get a Mk2, earlier the better on one grounds - rust!

if you like actualy driving, mk3, if your abit of a fanny and cant handle it mk4

If you want people to ask why your driving an old banger, get a MK3.

Who gives a fk what other people think? The same people would probably ask why you drive a granny car with a kids climbing frame in the boot. :lol:

I generally avoid mk3's (except GT's.... I don't like G40s) and 4's because compared to a German Mk2, the build isn't all that. I'd get a Mk2, earlier the better on one grounds - rust!

LOL!!

Mrk4 Nicer Car Alltogether ;)

To add to what someone said earlier

If you actually like driving... keep the 1.1 106. It's quicker than your average non GT/G40 Mk3, it's quicker than any 8v Mk4 bar the 1.6, and even then you'd be surprised. It handles better than any Polo, ever. Probably be more reliable than a Mk4.

To add to what someone said earlier

If you actually like driving... keep the 1.1 106. It's quicker than your average non GT/G40 Mk3, it's quicker than any 8v Mk4 bar the 1.6, and even then you'd be surprised. It handles better than any Polo, ever. Probably be more reliable than a Mk4.

some good points. dont no why your making out that the 106 is a better car than a polo But in no way is a standard 106 faster than a AAU or AAV Mk3. Iv got proof, never mind the NZ engined mk3.

Even the people on here with mk4's seem to favour the mk3's, there a much nicer car to look at standard or with a few mods. Nicer to drive. Tough and reliable. The only reason you would get a 1.4 8v mk4 is if you wanted a comfier ride and abit more luxury. And in no way is the mk3 a banger. If any of them is an old banger its the mk4 6n or mk5 6n2, at least the mk3 might become a classic one day like the older golfs but the mk4 will just rust and be laughed at. Retro polos FTW.

Also another point , you'll actually be liked on this site for having a mk3. Most of the 6n mk4 owners tend to be up the own arse cocks. Just look at the comments that are in favour of a mk4 , now you dont wanna be like that do you? Most of the shit they come out with either doesnt make sence or their trying to pretend that they have actually driven a mk3 before.

Max

Edited by Gozzard-Coupe

If you want people to ask why your driving an old banger, get a MK3.

What's the need for a comment like that? Some of us can't afford to buy/run newer cars. People that think they're superior just cause they have a shit load of money get right up my fuckin nose. Wind your neck in mate.

Anyway, back to the discussion! It's a hard decision I think as they're both good cars; just the Mk3 has slightly less luxuries. However (as has been said before) it is better to drive. If you wanna judge it on looks then standard I think the mk4 is better looking though.

Reliability wise the Mk3 has less to go wrong if you look after it well and get a good example, but again they're pretty evenly matched.

At the end of the day its all about personal preference! Just pick the one which appeals more to you I guess.

If you want people to ask why your driving an old banger, get a MK3.

What's the need for a comment like that? Some of us can't afford to buy/run newer cars. People that think they're superior just cause they have a shit load of money get right up my fuckin nose. Wind your neck in mate.

I could afford something else - but bought a mk3 :lol:

If you want people to ask why your driving an old banger, get a MK3.

What's the need for a comment like that? Some of us can't afford to buy/run newer cars. People that think they're superior just cause they have a shit load of money get right up my fuckin nose. Wind your neck in mate.

I could afford something else - but bought a mk3 :lol:

Haha so could I, mk3 ftw :unibrow:

The power steering is heavy,

The same people would probably ask why you drive a granny car with a kids climbing frame in the boot. :lol:

If any of them is an old banger its the mk4 6n or mk5 6n2, at least the mk3 might become a classic one day like the older golfs but the mk4 will just rust and be laughed at. Retro polos FTW.

Also another point , you'll actually be liked on this site for having a mk3. Most of the 6n mk4 owners tend to be up the own arse cocks. Just look at the comments that are in favour of a mk4 , now you dont wanna be like that do you? Most of the shit they come out with either doesnt make sence or their trying to pretend that they have actually driven a mk3 before.

Max

For me, these are the funniest posts in the whole thread :lol::lol:

Oh god. MK3 Vs MK4 :lol:

Indy, there's really no need is there? lol

The rust argument... Yes MK3's rust. but you may notice they have lest rust and are on average 3-4 years older than a MK4. That sorts that :lol:

Insurance wise, they are going to be around the same.

Engine's. The Mk3 1.3 spi is an awesome little engine. Hasnt got much grunt but its still fun. and uses bugger all petrol.

The MK4 1.4 8v I would say feels more sluggish than a 1.3 spi does.

As for looks. I think they both look awful until they are lightly modded tbh lol. And both require around the same money to get them looking better.

MK4's have the advantage with lowering as you can get coilies for cheap. But different mods for a MK3 can be cheaper than the same for a MK4

On average they are pretty much both the same.

MK3 is more fun to drive but doesn't have the luxuries

MK4 is the opposite.

However. said luxuries can be fitted to a MK3 for not too much.

PAS obv isnt really do-able but I've never felt the need for it in mine.

CL is a easy job and if your fecking lucky you could stumble across a MK3 with factory leccy windows.

What a thread.

look at it like this: on visiting the scrappy why is it that upon entering the VW section I see rows of mk4's, there's an entire avenue of them there and then sitting there is 1 white mk3.

You can visit any scrappy and find mk4's but all mk3 owners know that its a lucky day if you find one.

mk3's came treated with anti-rust stuff from the factory, mk4's had rust leaving the factory. :lol:

can anyone explain to me why the drivers door on red mk4s always seems to be rusty?

If you want people to ask why your driving an old banger, get a MK3.

What's the need for a comment like that? Some of us can't afford to buy/run newer cars. People that think they're superior just cause they have a shit load of money get right up my fuckin nose. Wind your neck in mate.

I could afford something else - but bought a mk3 :lol:

Haha so could I, mk3 ftw :unibrow:

Same :thumbsup: :biggrin:

Edited by Cymro

What a thread.

look at it like this: on visiting the scrappy why is it that upon entering the VW section I see rows of mk4's, there's an entire avenue of them there and then sitting there is 1 white mk3.

Well.. because they've already been crushed...

VW sold more Mk4's than Mk3's, and in any case how often do you still see other mk3's on the road? I only ever see them at VW meets :lol:

Mk4's are still everywhere.. for now.

My 6N has no rust btw :-)

IBTL

My MK3 has no rust....

I keep seeing more and more MK3's tbh. my mates mom has a breadvan aswell haha.

And there's something that would annoy me. They are everywhere. I wouldn't want a car that was everywhere.

My MK3 has no rust....

I keep seeing more and more MK3's tbh. my mates mom has a breadvan aswell haha.

And there's something that would annoy me. They are everywhere. I wouldn't want a car that was everywhere.

Youve just contradicted yourself like fook :lol:

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.