Skip to content

car of the year

Featured Replies

  • Replies 53
  • Views 5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Good win for VW.

Even so I'm still to see one actually out on the road. Is it even out yet?

Good win for VW.

Even so I'm still to see one actually out on the road. Is it even out yet?

X2 :?

yeah, someone on here as got one

a bird who works at my local chippy has one.

shes about 20, driving around with L plates on...brand spanking new motor for a first car.

I've only ever seen press demonstrators at work, not seen any others yet.

doesnt someone on here have one??

Good Win :D

Lol at the other finalists. No wonder the Polo won!

they look nice as pie in red i saw 1 the other day - nearly came

there just like the mk6 golf, just not a real polo, too big....but glad it came to VW though

Edited by captin_urbis

i'd say it's the best out of the ones mentioned but I'm very sceptical to it actually being the car of the year.

I don't like newer vag stuff as much as the old, for example I'd much rather have a mini than a new polo.

I almost bought one but that would mean scrapping my mk2 and that would break my heart and besides its cheaper to run a mk2 than spend 11 grand on a mk8

I almost bought one but that would mean scrapping my mk2 and that would break my heart and besides its cheaper to run a mk2 than spend 11 grand on a mk8

And the mk2 will be built better.

I doubt that...

new ones aren't built as good as a B5 20V non turbo you know. . .

quality lol

Heh, shall remember this next time someone slags my car off...

new ones aren't built as good as a B5 20V non turbo you know. . .

Am I missing something?

^^ yeh that lost me aswell tbh, new polo is the best since the mk3, as after mk3 they went abit poo, mk5s are ok though

remember new car parts cheaply made so quality will be taken away. would much rather stick with my mk3 over the new stuff

Just not a fan at all of the latest vag's is all, don't feel the love is there.

Mk5's were the pinnacle of polo's though.

I almost bought one but that would mean scrapping my mk2 and that would break my heart and besides its cheaper to run a mk2 than spend 11 grand on a mk8

And the mk2 will be built better.

I doubt that...

The materials were,and thats only partially why the fifth generation Polo wont last like the second. They've always had a restricted life from conception,only the profiteers are now in greater control.

For not just the owner but all of us,in the trough or not,the £11k is possibly not the biggest expense - its more environmentally friendly to keep the old one,which has paid its factory emissions,instead of polluting the environment heavily by recycling it and building the new one.

New blue motion? Co2 of 89gkm? Its greener to give the ancient 1.3 a full service instead.

The magazines that promote new car sales on behalf of the purely capitalistic car industry (Autocar,What Car,Car,Evo etc etc) dont wanna promote that,do they..

I think you're being overly skeptical, you only have to look at the warranties on a new car to see they're built to last in ways older ones can't manage. Service intervals are longer, reliability is up and even consumables like exhausts are expected to last seven years now, rather than three like an older car. It's actually giving garages a hard time because while the parts are slightly more expensive than they were, they last for ages so cars are coming in less frequently.

The new Polo is galvanised, for a start, so it'll last longer before tinworm sets in. The interior plastics may be made from recycled stuff, but I can't see that it would have a shorter shelf life than a car built in the 1980s. Mechanically, too, I just can't see it. There's more electrical stuff to go wrong, but that's because pre-94 Polos are as well-specced as a Russian prison cell. At worst, your fag lighter might start acting up, if you have one.

I disagree that quality dropped after the Mk3 too - I don't think the Mk3 is that well built. It's better built than, say, an old Peugeot 205 but it's nowhere near Mk2 Golf quality. And neither is the Polo, even the early Mk2s (which were better built than later ones). The Mk4 is definitely better built than a Mk3, and the Mk5 is better again. And my Passat is 100% better made, more solid and safer than the Polo, despite being about 11 years newer.

But from an environmental point of view, yes of course it's better for the environment to run an old car into the ground than buy a new one. I dislike the argument about discarding your smokey old car for a new one to save the ice caps etc. But the Bluemotion will trickle onto the used market eventually, and if you keep running that it'll wind up being better for the environment than an equivalent age Mk2 Polo ever was. 89g/km is equivalent to around 75mpg, and you will never get an old Polo to be that efficient.

Magazines aren't promoting new car sales for the purely capitalistic car industry either - there's actually plenty of skepticism about 'environmentally friendly' new cars and the environmental benefits of upgrading to something new. However, most new car mags are reviewing cars for people who don't actually care. They're out to research and/or buy a new car, not an old one.

Also, the car industry was "purely capitalistic" back when the Mk2 was on sale. It really hasn't changed!

I largely agree. It took many decades of development,by an industrial direction that helped create the need for transport,to get to the MK2 in the first place. And i wouldn't wanna suggest it should've stopped there - it was a flawed model,afterall.

I do have a grudge on the general direction of new cars,they're all far too heavy but that's the choice of the consumers and authorities as well as manufacturers and journalists. If i had a choice it'd be something more like an early Golf with a Polo bluemotion engine which would be swifter and more economical with its circa 820kg weight.

But there is no such choice in the EU and that's annoying (you can get close in some other countries).

I dont buy the warranty argument,though. Cars are being built as disposable items as much as ever,and the long warranties of today mark their scheduled life more clearly. Whereas a warranty used to be for teething its now becoming an important part of the vehicle - and once expired,the expense of modern complex electrical parts renders the car near worthless.

Galvanising bodies with stainless exhausts under them is all very well,but its done now because it sounds impressive. But it aint - my local breakers is full of cars with little or no rust. Brittle plastic parts are useless for the second hand parts buyer (hopeless for Fiat,Renault and Citroen owners),the cars having little to offer but failed Mot certificates in the glovebox or snapped cambelts with silly service quotes in the ashtray.

In the last two years,my brothers old 57 plate Corsa literally fell to bits,just like his 54 plate did. Vinyl skin peeling off the leather steering wheel,door handles falling off,steering geometry went out more often than i do. His old one died because most of the 7,000 tiny brittle plastic clips gave up and dropped items like arch trims and door panels on the road.

Modern cars are shyte. They didn't have to be.

Or did they? We're using materials,and recycling them,far too quickly. But no matter how long we stretch it we'll run out of mineral plastics eventually. The MK2 was made with many virgin materials (and a surprising amount of recycled stuff) but that's not sustainable.

There was a time when carpet was on the options list. But for the over-protected spoilt brats of today,no less than Bose sat-nav surrounded by seven airbags and 41 electric motors will do.

Yeah i blame capitalism but there's a lot of wide content in the word.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.