Skip to content

car of the year

Featured Replies

The Mk2's full of brittle plastics though - the indicator stalks for starters. My brother's Mk2 had a mild case of leprosy, I remember various bits of trim were broken/hanging off that and it wasn't very high mileage. Just old...

It's true what you're saying about parts prices though. Airbags are a captive part (OE manufacturer only - come on would you buy anywhere else) and £500 each. Technically they're supposed to be replaced every 10-15 years to ensure they work. By the time a small car gets to that age, even if it's only got a couple of airbags they're going to be worth a sizeable amount of the cost of the car.

And that screws up repair costs too. Apparently HID headlights for a Citroen C4 Picasso are £800 a side! Have a front end bump and you're talking £1600 before you even get onto airbags, bumper parts and labour costs. I know from my trade journo days that there's been a marked increase in the number of cars being written off because of this, not because of quality issues but because of high value parts and more expensive materials (ultra high strength steel and aluminium for example) being used more in new cars. Hence, yes, you'll find newer cars in scrap yards because they're uneconomical to repair at a younger age. But manufacturers are aiming to cut this - look at the way leading edges of bonnets are pushed back further from the point of impact to cut repair costs. It helps running costs (lower insurance) and makes it more likely to be repaired in an accident, hence more parts sales to bodyshops.

My point is, you'll find issues with new cars but you'll find just as many if not more with an old car. And I reckon if you compare a new Polo in 20 years to the way a Mk2 is now, I'd be surprised if the Mk8 hasn't lasted better than the Mk2. Just like I'd say if your brother were comparing his Corsas to an old Nova, he'd find the same thing.

Also, car manufacturers are cutting their kerb weights at the moment to save fuel. The Mk8 Polo is almost 10% lighter than the Mk7, that's equivalent to the weight of a fat passenger, yet it's safer and better equipped. Don't underestimate the engineering that goes into new cars, and that has to because of regulations. I know they're all similar shapes etc (tbh though, the Mk2 Polo and Mk2 Golf are very similar so that's nothing new) and some people don't want all the gadgets but they are incredibly well screwed together and I can't see why they wouldn't last.

I'm not stating preference here, just personal experience. I prefer old cars, I love my old Polo and I will never sell it, but I've spent a lot of time testing new cars and I've found them to be very very well engineered. Yes there's competition which pushes ever more gadgetry and safety stuff in there, but all mainstream car manufacturers are here to make money. They're businesses. If Ford fit a billion airbags to the new Fiesta, VW have do to the same to the new Polo.

If you want a new car without all the bollocks by the way, the Aygo/C1/107 is the place to be. Proper no-frills motoring, low weight and it's got everything you need in a town car. I think they're brilliant, love driving them too. Not the fastest thing in the world, but economical, cheap to repair (look at where the panel gaps are, they're designed to crumple only a few sacrificial parts in an accident which brings the insurance down) and I think they're characterful too in a world of big heavy stuff.

Edited by Alex

  • Replies 53
  • Views 5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Not a fan of the modern VW's or cars in general. Everything seems to be getting too big, bulky and bland. Lots of cars looking alomst identical.

There is a grey brand new polo that must live near me as i have seen it about quite a bit. Looks nice but not for me.

Plus i'm a poor ass tramp :-)

Not a fan of the modern VW's or cars in general. Everything seems to be getting too big, bulky and bland. Lots of cars looking alomst identical.

There is a grey brand new polo that must live near me as i have seen it about quite a bit. Looks nice but not for me.

Plus i'm a poor ass tramp :-)

But your Mk2 Polo looks like a small bumper Mk2 Golf, no?

And a bit like a Mk1 Fiesta?

xr2_004.jpg

Cars of a certain era always look similar.

It's nothing new!

Good point that man^^^ Guess its just these modern designs i don't like. I'm stuck in the past, i'm not hip or cool or up to date :cry:

All preference and progress i guess. Cars getting more powerful but still built like they used to would be a disaster so i guess the size of all new cars is relative. I just don't like it.

Thats why mk3 polos are cool in my eyes as they are a little bit away from other cars at that time. I had a mk2 and was always had a soft spot for my friends mk3 polos :-(

I don't have the polo anymore. I drive a pickup truck :-)

Edited by demolover

A lot of plastics in modern cars are skinned - junk plastic with a virgin skin on it. This isn't just the case in cars,but most things - from the telly housing to the shampoo bottle. They're often not as they appear,so feel? The stalks in mine feel like they could hold a bag of spuds,yet they're only designed for a fingertip.

The flip side is that parts need to be of such high visual quality now that its normal for twenty percent of components coming off the production line to never make it onto a car. A pin-head dot on a lens is enough to fail the QC so factory emissions these days are higher than they need to be and higher than people realise. And yet the landfill hidden under the skin/paint can be crap.

You wont find me in an Agro because I've seen the boot space. Wide though,granted. Good for carrying curtain poles.

And i like the tailgate for it being a step in the right direction.

Being able to see a small child behind the car is quite important i think,yet ever shrinking rear windows are the trend,and height is ironically the increasing choice for stupidly trendy school-run parents.

Otherwise,the front transverse engine followed by two front seats followed by rear bench followed by boot cube layout makes a lot of sense. If buying a new car,id continue with this. So the car is always gonna be a similar shape,framed around this. I totally prefer the new Polo's sensible and tidy shape to the mess most of its competitors look like.

To be fair i really like it would love one as a daily its like the Golf's younger Bro and the Golf aint bad looking to be fair ..

Clearly better built than a Mk2 Polo aswell .. Shit some of you guys make me laugth ..

Personally Mk1-2 the 6N2 and this new polo are the only cars that cut it for me , Gone of Mk3's although the G-Lader is a win !

The stalks in mine feel like they could hold a bag of spuds,yet they're only designed for a fingertip.

The spindly little plastic stalks in a Mk2 would struggle to hold a single spud, let alone a bag! They're tiny! :lol:

Well thanks guys, I have just ordred one. Had a test drive liked it and VW gave a good deal so I put my name down.

I like the 5 star ncap and the ESP as standard (now correct me if I am wrong but the mk2 did not get these).

I like the look of them as well 1056_1255434782.jpg I ordered a three door as the look different to the 5 door

Edited by cl coupe

Am I missing something? How can you win car of the year 2010 in December 2009?

It's a marketing thing really - VW get to slap a "Car of the Year 2010" sticker in the back of every new Polo they sell next year. Sounds more current than being last year's car of the year.

I see.

I got a red mk2 coupe S and theres a mk1 fiesta (also in red) that regularly parks next to me in my village. Gets a bit confusing when I'm bleary eyed in the morning lol.

Is it just me or is the new Scirocco now nothing to look at since the Golf and Polo got the same front end?

I like the 5 star ncap and the ESP as standard (now correct me if I am wrong but the mk2 did not get these).

I dont want them,i dont need stabilisers because I'm a grown-up and i can drive. And more the point,i wish to maintain the responsibility to do so - and dont support such aids.

Anti-stall and auto-park are probably the worst ones,and i believe they should be illegal on tuition cars. ESP only really differs by being more intentionally abused. Auto-braking is likely to be more commonly abused as it becomes more popular,though.

I've already thrown my 2p in about the flaw with making cars easy to abuse,and the attitude some drivers of such cars are developing,so i'll not go back into that one.

But to say that if i pull onto a roundabout and somone abusing their handling aids come flying round too fast for me to get out of the way,and their driver aids fail to stop them hitting me,i'll ensure they think twice before claiming against me and increasing my insurance.

With you on that, I've got experience, sense and roadcraft. Yes, I like ABS and don't deny that, but I'm not too bothered about the rest of it. As for airbags and NCAP ratings, to be honest, I don't normally use them :)

The stalks in mine feel like they could hold a bag of spuds,yet they're only designed for a fingertip.

The spindly little plastic stalks in a Mk2 would struggle to hold a single spud, let alone a bag! They're tiny! :lol:

I sill haven't got enough spuds to do this test properly,but that's 5kgs (2x 2.5kg bags) and if your fingertip manages to exceed that (i weigh 60kgs so that's 1/12th my bodyweight) then thats pure abuse. Still,i pushed down harder,about another bag,confident it wasn't anywhere near breaking :lol:

05122009095.jpg

With you on that, I've got experience, sense and roadcraft. Yes, I like ABS and don't deny that, but I'm not too bothered about the rest of it. As for airbags and NCAP ratings, to be honest, I don't normally use them :)

I've had a couple of crashes in my time. One was a frontal into a Transporter van in 1992,and i was in a 1983 Escort. I got out with nothing to worry about but whether i bent the solid plastic steering wheel.

The other was in a car based on it - a 1990 XR3i,where i T-boned a Fiesta at 60mph,tearing the car open like a sardine can. Again,the only physical affect it had on me was that i had to walk 100 yards up the road to the other car.

Now call me lucky,but its made perfect sense for me not to carry 500kgs of N-Cap bullshit about with me in my circa 300,000 miles of driving,which takes us right back to the harsh environmental impact of the modern car.

The stalks in mine feel like they could hold a bag of spuds,yet they're only designed for a fingertip.

The spindly little plastic stalks in a Mk2 would struggle to hold a single spud, let alone a bag! They're tiny! :lol:

I sill haven't got enough spuds to do this test properly,but that's 5kgs (2x 2.5kg bags) and if your fingertip manages to exceed that (i weigh 60kgs so that's 1/12th my bodyweight) then thats pure abuse. Still,i pushed down harder,about another bag,confident it wasn't anywhere near breaking :lol:

05122009095.jpg

classic! :lol:

you must of been confident of success mikey, that could of easily gone wrong :-p:lol:

^^ Never doubted it - almost bulletproof,that car. :nod:

Remember though,that stalk's 21 years old - imagine doing that to the stalk of a MK1 Fiat Uno..

That picture :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

Mikey you legand ! You actually went out and backed up your what seamed to be obsured comment with photographic evidence ..

You my man are a legand ! 8-)

I also want your engine always have and always will :D

Mikey you legand ! You actually went out and backed up your what seamed to be obsured comment with photographic evidence ..

You my man are a legand ! 8-)

x2 :lol: :lol:

Thank you.. ..thank you.. .. I wanna thank my parents,workmates,my girlfriend,.. :lol:

But seriously,getting back to the plot,this new car the topic's all about - best Polo since the 6n2,me thinks. Not seen a 3dr in the flesh yet (saw a 5dr two weeks before intro), recon i might like it. For what it is,anyway.

I have a Fox at the moment and I wanted another Polo since I sold my mk3 (it was my first car as well).

I can drive and touch wood, I have not had a crash. I like the fact that I have the electrical bits to help if someone else gets it wrong. I think the traction control means I can drive to work on snow (OK we don't have much) without cracking out the snow socks. ((I live in a very hilly aria))

I have got caught up in the new car every 3 years now. So the new Polo is a big step up for me (from a polo mk3 - fiat punto - fox - new polo) I had a hitch with the punto although the 1.2 was quite nice (the rest about the car was c"^p).

I have got to wait a wile for the car, but I got a good deal.

"There was a time when carpet was on the options list. But for the over-protected spoilt brats of today,no less than Bose sat-nav surrounded by seven airbags and 41 electric motors will do."

nail and head :thumbsup:

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.