Skip to content

Polo 16v AFH vs MK2 Golf 16v

Featured Replies

which one is quicker?

  • Replies 24
  • Views 2.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Golf all day long

100bhp vs. 147bhp (iir) not much competition really

  • Author

ye that what i thought mate..its just that sum people tell me there not as fast as people say they are.

lol.

The Polo would be dicked heavy haha

The Golf is 139bhp.

Edited by kerrly

The Golf is actually lighter in weight than the Polo. It'd piss all over it.

I had a Mk2 Golf GTI 8v and even that felt quicker in places than the 16v Polo.

Maybe the people who think they aren't fast have driven the chavved up thrashed versions that are actually 8v's badged up as a 16v?

The Polo would do well to take either 8v or 16v mk2 Golf GTI, as has been mentioned already the weight difference alone makes a huge difference.

  • Author

cheers for the info..

I once drove a neighbours mk3 Golf GTi 8v, and even the lardy heavy lump that it was is faster than my 16v.

Polo 16v isn't fast. It just feels fast when you're driving it.

no replacement for displacement

Giorgio once tried to tell me that his GT would beat my 16v golf, i think he was actually being serious as well :lol:

I once drove a neighbours mk3 Golf GTi 8v, and even the lardy heavy lump that it was is faster than my 16v.

Polo 16v isn't fast. It just feels fast when you're driving it.

no mk3 8v's are feking slow..... bro has one, i have more fun in my 1l...

Polo 16v isn't fast. It just feels fast when you're driving it.

i will agree with that, was going to swap my 16v polo for a mk2 16v mates bro took me out in it and i must say the mk2 was soo much faster even with a shagged cv joint

Giorgio once tried to tell me that his GT would beat my 16v golf, i think he was actually being serious as well :lol:

Driving style ;)

  • Author
I once drove a neighbours mk3 Golf GTi 8v, and even the lardy heavy lump that it was is faster than my 16v.

Polo 16v isn't fast. It just feels fast when you're driving it.

my car beats a 8v mk3 gti easily..

^^^ lol, 2l vs 1.4 hummm

Edited by frybert

I once drove a neighbours mk3 Golf GTi 8v, and even the lardy heavy lump that it was is faster than my 16v.

Polo 16v isn't fast. It just feels fast when you're driving it.

my car beats a 8v mk3 gti easily..

Well, either:

(a) the other guy wasn't trying/can't drive

or

(b) there's something seriously wrong with his car

or

© your car has had a serious amount of engine modification.

So which is it?

8v mk3's are shite,they are slow as slugs!to fat and not enough mmmff

Edited by hiner69er

  • Author

well its not hard 2 drive in a straight line is it!!lol

all thats been done 2 mine is 4 branch, decat and induction kit..

and everyone thinks wow 2litre it must be fast..but tbf they dnt deserve the GTI badge.

No way is a Mk3 Golf 8v GTI faster than a 6n 16v. Either it's a shagged valver or a modded 8v, simple. My E36 318is was comfortably faster than a Mk3 8v, and I would say a certain owner on here of a Mk2 8v GTI would admit to being surprised when my IS would sit on it's hoop and get to the point of actually being able to overtake. Given ideal conditions, the 8v would probably have nosed ahead from rest, but it's all over above 50 mph. And to finish that off - the same owner of the GTI also has a 6n 16v, which, believe it or not, was pretty much exactly the same performance as my BMW. This isn't just a one off, the two of us used to be out in our cars all the time together!

So really... the performance of an 8v Mk2 GTI and a 6n 16v aren't as far apart as you'd think. A 6n 16v is actually lighter than a runout 90 spec Mk2 GTI too. Power to weight isn't everything, aerodynamics, gearing, etc, all play a big part.

God knows why I'm slagging Mk2 GTIs though, I think I'm away to get a Mk2 16v! One thing that can be put to rest, is that a Mk2 16v is actually quite a fast car.

mk3 8v gti's are good for..... er... towing. vr6 ftw.

^^^ lol, 2l vs 1.4 hummm

The 2.0 is only an extra 15bhp,and pulling a notably heavier car. I'm with the valver on this one - the MK3 Golf Gti was not a GTi and shouldn't have been badged as one imo. Sport? I doubt it has a sporty character. GT,maybe.

Giorgio once tried to tell me that his GT would beat my 16v golf, i think he was actually being serious as well :lol:

Driving style ;)

in that case Gman would be doubly fucked :lol:

a valver engine with a few mods in an older polo would stand a much greater chance, and i haven't seen giorgio drive like he stole it, even in the G, mind you when you put the foot down all the fuel disappeared out of the back!

charlie on the other hand in a need to get to work cos I'm running late driving, would own most of you, never seen a 1.4 16v lupo move so fast in and out of traffic and damn when she was late in dennis with the fluro wheels, that would have shit most drivers up seeing that in the rear view licking yer bumper!

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.