Skip to content

the difference?

Featured Replies

Hi guys right ideally i want a mk41.4 16v ideally however i've come to realise that all the 16v's are one of two things either bags of shit or redicoulously modified so they go up in price out of my price range :/ this has made me think i might just settle to a 1.4 cl i know theres a vast difference in bhp but i wondered if it affected like accelleration too much? i know obviously the top speed will be different but is it alot slower then then a valver? I've been told the cl isnt actually that bad on accelleration ect so please tell me in a nut shell guys. also whats the difference between the bumpers? I've heard people say valver bumpers are different i cant see it?

cheers lewis

  • Replies 21
  • Views 2.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Different in looks, valvers have bigger bumpers and side skirts. & massively faster.

CL = 60 bhp

valver= 100bhp.

The only reason I'd ever chose a CL over a valver was if I couldn't afford one. Other than that...

bumpers are completely different, 8v are two piece 16v one piece for a start. Chances are, people are claiming their 8v polos are 16 in the for sale ad because they dont know the difference and think it sounds good, this description cracks me up! - link

Valvers are epicly faster than 8 valves.

  • Author

lol ok guys might just wait that bit longer for a valver then, a low mileage untouched 3door one in good nick is a rare thing from what i can tell though :/

The 8v's feel nippy as they have torque low down but alongside a valver they would look very very silly.

I would maybe not worry to much about mileage if I were you, cars are ment to be driven after all, and the average mileage for an early one is around 160,000 miles (based on a 12,500mile a year average). And to be fair 12,500 miles isn't hard to do in a year.

As long as it been looked after, one on that kind of miles should be fine.

  • Author

i see thing is its a first car and tbh as long as it looks nice i'm thinkin it'll be ok i know if i buy a valver tbh i'm gonna wanna do the engine up though :/ and i dont wanna spend that much, plus its the insurance :/ i think me getting in a car as fast as the valver will either get me banned very quick or die horrifically :/

i also want a car now so like i hate waitin for one to come along like as i said a untouched valver is a very rare thing indeed i'm half considerin a cl :/ theres a really nice green one I've seen for 1000 61k miles full service history hmmm hard choice. As long as a cl aint like so slow it just drags behind everything? does it? haha can any cl owners comment :/

For a first car, (as long as you haven't been driving for years in someone elses) will be plenty fast enough. Assuming your mates are all in 1.0's and so on then you'l be quick enough. And like you said, as long as it looks good 8-)

For a first car the 1.4 8v is fine, mine will keep up with my mates 2002 1.2 Corsa, 2006 1.4 Clio etc. so it's not stupidly slow, can overtake alright as well. However, you will soon find yourself wanting something a bit quicker, but then i spose you would even if you bought a valver first.

Edited by patchb

Ye, whatever you get for a first car - you will eventually want something faster :lol:

bumpers are completely different, 8v are two piece 16v one piece for a start. Chances are, people are claiming their 8v polos are 16 in the for sale ad because they dont know the difference and think it sounds good, this description cracks me up! - link

Valvers are epicly faster than 8 valves.

That link's description also states that the 6n advertised is 1391cc. Thats the Golf engine,not the 6n's. So its even the wrong 1.4 8v anyway. :lol:

Different in looks, valvers have bigger bumpers and side skirts. & massively faster.

CL = 60 bhp

valver= 100bhp.

The only reason I'd ever chose a CL over a valver was if I couldn't afford one. Other than that...

Side skirts???????? Errr, no. I think you're thinking of the 6n2.

  • Author

haha cheers guys yeah it depends what comes along i suppose if i see a valver at the right price then i will buy it but i want a untouched polo so i can do it all from scratch myself however i may end up gettins a cl i'm gonna phone up about that 1.4 cl after crimbo see what they say (: just cant wait to have a polo "if you aint scrubbin' you aint dubbin'" as my mate karl would say haha. Thanks for helpin with the cl isnt as slow as my pushbike issue :L

merry christmas guys btw (:

  • Author

out of plain curiosity i just did a insurance quote on a mk 4 1.6 cl and its £20 more tha it'd cost to insure a 1.4cl and £70 cheaper than it would cost me to insure a 1.4 16v and as there 75bhp i may just go for one of them bit more speed and still a mk polo (Y) what you all think guys? it is the same as a 1.4 isnt it?

With the 1.6 8v what you save on the insurance over a 1.4 16v you will spend on the tax. As its over a 1500cc engine the tax will be about £190 a year compared to the £120 of the 1.4 16v.

out of plain curiosity i just did a insurance quote on a mk 4 1.6 cl and its £20 more tha it'd cost to insure a 1.4cl and £70 cheaper than it would cost me to insure a 1.4 16v and as there 75bhp i may just go for one of them bit more speed and still a mk polo (Y) what you all think guys? it is the same as a 1.4 isnt it?

1.6 with bike carbs n exhaust get u close to valver power but with twice asmuch tourqe

  • Author

hah cool tbh mate i'd never use bike carbs and as its a first car tbh I'm not mega bothered about the 100bhp i think 75 will be plenty plus as you said more torque due to the bigger engine . . . also i dont see many 1.6's euro'd tbh so i think it would make a nice change (: they are the same body wise ect are they not?

and ouch about the tax :/ but that means it is basically equal either way then :/ hmmmmmmm difficult choice haha i suppose its what comes along then really

Edited by XxBeefyxX

Fuck it, if you're after acceleration just buy a bike. A 'busa will tear your face off!

  • Author

:lol: prefer a car haha and nah I'm not after anythingly specially quick just thought if its so much less to insure a 1,6 then why not :/ be a bit nippier than a 1.4 cl i imagine ?

haha (:

1.6's aint fast lol. Mine feels torquey low down, but runs out of steam fast, especially after 4k, it's pretty pointless going above it, all it does it make more noise and not move anywhere quicker lol!

I would get a 16v personally, plus they have nicer front bumpers, prefer the 8v rear bumper though personally. I would put bike carbs on mine, if I had a clue what I was doing!

whateva engine your car has u learn to drive differently to accommadate the power or should i say lack of it, I've just gone 4rm a 230bhp 2.0ltr turbo to a bog standard 1.0ltr polo. :sad: it can still do a roads fine (as long as theres a few corners to slow down bigger cars) and lanes its perfect.

the saying is points = prizes, I've gone from vauxhall to vw so the saying must be rite :grin:

i love the olop :biggrin:

  • Author

i see :/ ok well its gonna be one of the 1.4's then depends whats around at the time tbh i want a car asap so i can insure it on ym provisional and get some more practise in so like yeah erm if theres a valver around i'll have it but i doubt there will be knowin my luck tbh

I'd get a valver if it's going to work out the same cost as a 1.6, be more economical too.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.