Skip to content

polo handling mk2 v mk3

Featured Replies

Saloons are heavier than hatchbacks, about 20Kg heavier according to my saloon's brochure.

  • Replies 38
  • Views 3.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Yeh I thought so.

After seeing randombadger69's mk3 g40 next to his mk2 coupe, the mk3 is definately longer at the front.

I can vouch for that, the amount of times I've chucked a jack under the front of the mk3 this week thinking of the mk2 arb mount position, then had to move it 3 inches back :lol:

Saloons are heavier than hatchbacks, about 20Kg heavier according to my saloon's brochure.

I may have crossed spec reference,because figures greatly differ from one example to another. I've got 715kgs for a 1043cc 1985 saloon and 709kgs for a 1043cc 1983 coupe without rear wiper,both from VW brochures. This puts them to within 5kgs in the same year. So i may have noted a 1.3 coupe with the 1.0 saloon - which makes the latter the lighter car.

Unless you are planning on fabricating a different braking system for the mk2, go for a mk3. The servo and MC upgrade options (with little/no fabrication) for the mk3 make it a far better candidate. If you start with a gt/g40 the you already have the rear arb. Any weight difference will be negligable once it's stripped and you have a cage.

I'm sure saloons are heavier than Coupes - they've got a bulkhead between the rear shock towers, a longer boot floor and rear wings. I remember years ago Paul Borthwick (first UK Mk3 G40 saloon) saying they're about 20kg heavier than a coupe..

Cue MikeyMK with the scales to prove me wrong... :lol:

I'm not gonna get the scales out,but according to VW you're wrong and i remembered correctly. This is the handbook for the '88 showing the equivalent saloon as being lighter than the coupe,but for the heavy LHD diesel..

PoloIMp102.jpg

Saloons are heavier than hatchbacks, about 20Kg heavier according to my saloon's brochure.

Yeah,the hatch (squareback) is lightest if only by half that against the 'loon,i suspect the coupe's tailgate and largest frame has something to do with its heaviest weight.

according t te vw user manuel the mk2 loon is lighter than the mk3 coupe n mk3 breadvan.

Is a good point that coupe tailgates are bloody heavy.

I'm not gonna get the scales out,but according to VW you're wrong and i remembered correctly. This is the handbook for the '88 showing the equivalent saloon as being lighter than the coupe,but for the heavy LHD diesel..

I'm only going on what I've been told by other people, I've never taken the time to look into it myself. But that does surprise me, given that a saloon is an extended coupe. Heavy tailgate or not, I can't believe there's more metal in the back of a coupe than there is in a saloon. But the figures say otherwise, so I can't really dispute that.

I'm more surprised about the difference between the coupe and hatch - i can stomach the loon issue.

Sure,the loon has an extra floor extension panel (probably weighs sod all) and has longer quarters (even less),but everything else tells me its lighter. It has the least glass of the trio,and whilst it has a rigid seatback panel there's nothing to the seat itself - whereas the re-inforced assembly in the coupe seat backrest is probably as weighty,if not more so. The boot lid is no match for the tailgate with or without wiper and the coupe has the largest frame around its opening,too.

But the hatch is little different,it just lacks a bit of frame. Yet is at the other end of the scale.

I've weighed two MK2 coupes,on the same scales. The red one was an '88 with sliding steel sunroof,1.6 AEE,bike carbs,firewall sound insulation mat removed,rear wiper,5.5x13 alloys,VWII/200mm drums. It was 765kgs.

The blue one was a non-sunroof '85 with '88 front struts, 1.4 ABD,bike carbs,sound insulation removed,no wiper,5.5x13 steels,VWII/200mm. It was 717kgs.

Handling wise,the red one was easier to slide about,the blue one handling better until it went. Both had little fuel in,and ran the same suspension at that point (literally the same) but different brand/condition tyres.

Not that it does,but if a sliding sunroof makes 50kgs then whether its a hatch/loon/coupe is the last of your worries..

also the loons are slightly wider

MK2 pro's

Front slam panel and valence are welded to the chasis legs and probably make the car stiffer slightly but I never noticed any real difference as soon as a brace or subframe is added which is very noticeable any benefit is gone.

Con, if you bend front welding required where the mK3 front can be un bolted.

Mk3 pro

Much more room for intercoolers

Servo brake

Also at the rear in the boot the inner panel is attached to the rear panel where in the MK3 it kind of ends.

As for weight there is a lot of stuff in the boot hatches, replace it with grp :-)

Hatches are most likely lighter because there's far less to the C-pillars.

Hatches are most likely lighter because there's far less to the C-pillars.

The B-pillars appear to more than make up for it :lol:

Its not all about weight though - a rear ARB makes sense. I dont run one,i got over squatting issues by running hard rear suspension instead,but its only a matter of time before i swap the lighter beam for better ride quality on the straights.

I thought my Mk2 handled really really well, my car straight after crashing it was a Saxo VTR, and I still thought the Coupe S handled well even after having still arguably one of the best handling front drive cars ever. Not to mention the Polo was on standard suspension with tall profile tyres, meaning I could also quite comfortably go off roading.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.