Skip to content

gti vs g40 vs golf

Featured Replies

1-1.jpg

Let the discussions commence!

  • Replies 57
  • Views 5.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Oh dear god :lol:

Not having that lol , still think a g40 would kill a gti..!

Pointless without the mk2 16v.

I told people that a GTI is faster, but no one believed me. Apparently it was "too obvious" that a G40 - because of course nothings faster than a good old G40 isit - would be faster than a GTI so no one bothered to check the actual figures.

Edited by indy231

Not having that lol , still think a g40 would kill a gti..!

How do you come to such a conclusion?

The GTI is better in everyway possible for driving fast. Corners better, accelarates better, has a greater top end.

dunno the in gear acceleration of the g40 suggests that in a straight line at least, that in any situation on the road bar a drag from the lights the g40 would be significantly quicker

for me, thats what makes a car fast. ie being able to just move your toe and start moving rather than rinsing the gearbox to keep the revs up. but thats why i prefer n/a 6cylinder power rather than boost or revs tbh

Edited by doug

Ticked off in each what is best overall if one hasnt got a number then i missed that section out.

scored on my sheet:

polo g40 7 points

golf 4 1.8t 5 points

polo gti 2 points

golf 4 gti 1 point

golf 3 gti 1 point

last two only got a point each for having biggest engine lol

this is how much i want to end work today lol

Who said it wasn't Indy? I thought most people know it is on paper

Yours a GTi Indy? Fancy settling a score with a G40 owenr :paranoid: Not me, mine doesn't really exist :lol:

Edited by D16RRT

Because people who drive GTIs are lazy and packing pounds, so are heavier thatn the lean G40 driers :-p

Seriously though, figures mean fuck all when they are so close like that, its down to drivers, on the roads in the real world i mean

Listen to the walsh'ster. He knows :nod:

I told people that a GTI is faster, but no one believed me. Apparently it was "too obvious" that a G40 - because of course nothings faster than a good old G40 isit - would be faster than a GTI so no one bothered to check the actual figures.

Which Gti ?

Also most of the time your between 30 and 70 so surely the G40 is quickest by a mile and thats standard?!

Edited by quiksilver_jake

i agree with walshy

its amazing g40's only have 1272 cc's and are 20 years old but still give these cars a run for there money.

G40 FTW

its amazing g40's only have 1272 cc's and are 20 years old but still give these cars a run for there money.

G40 FTW

This guy knows where its at ;) ...

Who said it wasn't Indy? I thought most people know it is on paper

Yours a GTi Indy? Fancy settling a score with a G40 owenr :paranoid: Not me, mine doesn't really exist :lol:

Mine is a mighty 1.4 8V!

Only for another 7 months though!

Because people who drive GTIs are lazy and packing pounds, so are heavier thatn the lean G40 driers :-p

Seriously though, figures mean fuck all when they are so close like that, its down to drivers, on the roads in the real world i mean

No but drivers don't prove which car is faster.

If you put an identical driver in each car, then the one which is faster on paper would be faster in the real world.

should have mk2 gti 8v and 16v on there aswell tbh..

thats just not how it works though. in the 'real world' the chances of you coming across someone with identical driving skill to you in minimal

the gti will be 'easier' to drive faster, and the g40 would require more work. mk3s are not easy to drive fast, but more rewarding and can be made to fly if you have the commitment

as above and what possible relevance is the 2.0 8v spunky mk4 gti? they do a 1.8 20v non turbo mk4 too which again is not worthy of comparison.

Olly

should have mk2 gti 8v and 16v on there aswell tbh..

No need for that one haha

I told people that a GTI is faster, but no one believed me. Apparently it was "too obvious" that a G40 - because of course nothings faster than a good old G40 isit - would be faster than a GTI so no one bothered to check the actual figures.

Dunno where these figures are from though as both VW in the polo brochere and Parkers state the Polo GTi as 8.4.

someone needs to sort this as it's getting annoying.

As for the whole GTI mk2 16V thing, that's not going to be one that gets you really thinking.

I think it needs to be a Loop GTI vs a mk2 16v. That would be fun.

you've got to remember also that around nearly all the G40's left have been modified and are running a lot quicker than those figures :nod: , and most polo GTI's have no more than a induction kit mod (not all). i recon the removal of the butterflies in the throttle body on a G40 would alone bring the acceleration time down a fraction. remember a lot of G40's can now run 0-60 in the low sixes.

but the debate isn't modified, it's standard.

that's the benchmark, you can't really compare modified or you'd have to take each individual car into account.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.