Skip to content

gti vs g40 vs golf

Featured Replies

Not having that lol , still think a g40 would kill a gti..!

done and done, look at the power to weight ratios

  • Replies 57
  • Views 5.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

power to weight eventually gives way to raw power though

Forget that - the point is that even if a gti is slightly quicker we would all rather be whining along in a shopping trolley tbh......

Edited by Olly S

no, I'd rather be in the GTI, but I am getting old.

Forget that - the point is that even if a gti is slightly quicker we would all rather be whining along in a shopping trolley tbh......

word

According to those figures the GTI is faster to 60 and it ends there. They get to 70 at the same time and the G40 in gear figures are substantially better. That said, the GTI will handle and stop better than a stock G40.

The GTI is quick without the compromise on equipment but he G40 is also way more tuneable for much less money than the GTI and the gearboxes are made from better quality chocolate.

Would come down to driver preference tbh

I think this is a job for The Stig tbh, shall i ask him? :lol:

I think this is a job for The Stig tbh, shall i ask him? :lol:

Sorry but i'm busy Laura... :lol::lol:

I told people that a GTI is faster, but no one believed me. Apparently it was "too obvious" that a G40 - because of course nothings faster than a good old G40 isit - would be faster than a GTI so no one bothered to check the actual figures.

Not having that lol , still think a g40 would kill a gti..!

How do you come to such a conclusion?

The GTI is better in everyway possible for driving fast. Corners better, accelarates better, has a greater top end.

You have obviously just looked at the 0-60 time and decided that a GTI is better in everyway than a G40.

Look at the important figures, the 'races' that are most likely to happen in real life, the in gear rolling start races.

The in gear acceleration figures show the G40 is up to 2 seconds quicker than a GTI between certain speeds.

And also another important figure, the bhp per tonne figure, notice how the G40 has the highest of the lot...and it is the oldest car on the list by far. Thats why people rave about them, thats why they are so good!!

  • Author
I told people that a GTI is faster, but no one believed me. Apparently it was "too obvious" that a G40 - because of course nothings faster than a good old G40 isit - would be faster than a GTI so no one bothered to check the actual figures.

Dunno where these figures are from though as both VW in the polo brochere and Parkers state the Polo GTi as 8.4.

They're from 'Volkswagen Driver' Magazine... Issue 1, dated June 2000.

Theres a full polo gti review plus a 3 page polo gti vs golf gti feature.

Good find, got it off eBay. 99p.

I told people that a GTI is faster, but no one believed me. Apparently it was "too obvious" that a G40 - because of course nothings faster than a good old G40 isit - would be faster than a GTI so no one bothered to check the actual figures.

Dunno where these figures are from though as both VW in the polo brochere and Parkers state the Polo GTi as 8.4.

They're from 'Volkswagen Driver' Magazine... Issue 1, dated June 2000.

Theres a full polo gti review plus a 3 page polo gti vs golf gti feature.

Good find, got it off eBay. 99p.

Thing is every car is different.

There may be people on here with a very strong GTI which can do 0-60 in under VW's claims, and there will be those that won't be able to get close to the claims.

I fully believe though in a proper drag race a G40 would get off the line quicker and despite the GTI being quicker to 60 it wouldn't be enough to get infront of the G40.

Edited by kwijibo_coupe

it depends which website you go on to find which is quicker.

copied from letstorquebhp.com

Volkswagen Polo 1.6 Gti 9.43

Volkswagen Polo 1.8 GTI 8.91

Volkswagen Polo G40 7.74

my valver was as quick as my mates GTi

it's hard to compare two cars which are totally different.

G40.

People who go off 0-60 figures to say a car is better/faster are daft tbh. As aleady mentioned, a G40 from a rolling start will kill off a 6n2 GTi in literally seconds.

A lot of people on here probably don't realise that VW actually restricted the power of a G40 so that it didn't surpass their flag ship Golf GTI sales at the time. Take away this restriction in the stock airbox, and i reckon the G40 would be pushing 120bhp.

6n2 GTi's dont deserve a gti status, just like VW didn't think the mk3 GT didn't :!:

People who go off 0-60 figures to say a car is better/faster are daft tbh. As aleady mentioned, a G40 from a rolling start will kill off a 6n2 GTi in literally seconds.

A lot of people on here probably don't realise that VW actually restricted the power of a G40 so that it didn't surpass their flag ship Golf GTI sales at the time. Take away this restriction in the stock airbox, and i reckon the G40 would be pushing 120bhp.

6n2 GTi's dont deserve a gti status, just like VW didn't think the mk3 GT didn't :!:

Well fucking said mate. Bravo.

This is stupid :lol:

I'm with whoever said loop gti though someone get some figures up for that it's alot more fun than the 6n2 gti, its gotta be down on abit of weight aswell

Edited by Ian.Southall

  • Author
People who go off 0-60 figures to say a car is better/faster are daft tbh. As aleady mentioned, a G40 from a rolling start will kill off a 6n2 GTi in literally seconds.

A lot of people on here probably don't realise that VW actually restricted the power of a G40 so that it didn't surpass their flag ship Golf GTI sales at the time. Take away this restriction in the stock airbox, and i reckon the G40 would be pushing 120bhp.

6n2 GTi's dont deserve a gti status, just like VW didn't think the mk3 GT didn't :!:

i reckon it does deserve its badge if it can compete with its big brother the golf.

plus, for all the advantages of the gti;

climate control,

galvanised body,

better headlights,

better interior,

better handling,

and so fourth and so on

which the ancient g40 doesn't have... u can have your extra second or two.

i suppose for the hardcore enthusiasts a mint g40 is something special, but as a daily driver, jesus, id rather have a 1.0 mk5... never mind a gti model!

anyway this is off the point! haha.

"cough" looser.

Someones never driven a G if he'd rather have a 1.0 mk5 :lol:

"cough" looser.

at the end of the day, when you drive a proper car you realise how crap the mk3 polo as an everyday car really is

but as a daily driver, jesus, id rather have a 1.0 mk5...

Over a G40...would you really?

but as a daily driver, jesus, id rather have a 1.0 mk5...

Over a G40...would you really?

He is just kidding himself as i thought the figures would prove the Mk5 GTi was the tits.

I own a G40 for what it is. If I wanted a modern car for a daily drive, i wouldn't own a polo.......I have an A4.

but as a daily driver, jesus, id rather have a 1.0 mk5...

Over a G40...would you really?

He is just kidding himself as i thought the figures would prove the Mk5 GTi was the tits.

Maybe he's including the 6n2GTi in that answer aswell... :lol::lol::lol:

This is stupid :lol:

I'm with whoever said loop gti though someone get some figures up for that it's alot more fun than the 6n2 gti, its gotta be down on abit of weight aswell

The Lupo GTI has an extra 20kg over the 6n2 GTI so I have heard, its not as light as you'd expect it to be anyway.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.