Skip to content

gti vs g40 vs golf

Featured Replies

This is silly, G40- handsdown! No need for a topic about it id say! lol

  • Replies 57
  • Views 5.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

The Lupo GTI has an extra 20kg over the 6n2 GTI so I have heard, its not as light as you'd expect it to be anyway.

woah

comment-friday-damn.jpg

Edited by Ian.Southall

  • Author
but as a daily driver, jesus, id rather have a 1.0 mk5...

Over a G40...would you really?

He is just kidding himself as i thought the figures would prove the Mk5 GTi was the tits.

Maybe he's including the 6n2GTi in that answer aswell... :lol::lol::lol:

would i really? yes, as I've already mentioned... for reliability, comfort etc. don't really wanna be in an old car ready to fall apart.

I'm just kidding myself? thought the figures would prove the Mk5 GTi was the tits? yes, definately! for me, on my budget, its most certainly the tits! and i love it. so yes you are correct, the figures werent to prove this though, so sorry u got that part wrong. i think its the tits anyway :-D

he's including the 6n2GTi in that answer? i used the 1.0 mk5 as an example

I'm just kidding myself? thought the figures would prove the Mk5 GTi was the tits? yes, definately! for me, on my budget, its most certainly the tits!

until you get your ass handed to you by some one in a mk2 golf 16v who has a budget that's less than a quarter the size of yours :lol:

I'm just kidding myself? thought the figures would prove the Mk5 GTi was the tits? yes, definately! for me, on my budget, its most certainly the tits!

until you get your ass handed to you by some one in a mk2 golf 16v who has a budget that's less than a quarter the size of yours :lol:

:lol:

My bro's £250 16v was the tits, its engine on 205k now is in his current Mk2.

We even had an old Passat GT (1.8 16v) for a few months before selling which cost £90 due to being on 236k.

but as a daily driver, jesus, id rather have a 1.0 mk5...

Over a G40...would you really?

He is just kidding himself as i thought the figures would prove the Mk5 GTi was the tits.

Maybe he's including the 6n2GTi in that answer aswell... :lol::lol::lol:

would i really? yes, as I've already mentioned... for reliability, comfort etc. don't really wanna be in an old car ready to fall apart.

I'm just kidding myself? thought the figures would prove the Mk5 GTi was the tits? yes, definately! for me, on my budget, its most certainly the tits! and i love it. so yes you are correct, the figures werent to prove this though, so sorry u got that part wrong. i think its the tits anyway :-D

he's including the 6n2GTi in that answer? i used the 1.0 mk5 as an example

Got to LOL at that. Get a standard G40 and a standard Mk5 GTI, on similar mileages, and hands down the G40 would drive for longer than the GTI without breaking down. Did you know that you can get 6 figure mileages from a G40 gearbox? Shocking, I know.

The Lupo GTI has an extra 20kg over the 6n2 GTI so I have heard, its not as light as you'd expect it to be anyway.

Lupo GTI = 978kg

Polo GTI = 1084kg

The Lupo's got lightweight panels to keep the kerb weight down, the Polo hasn't.

TBH 'on paper' figures don't say much. The G40 has less weight to get moving (it had the fastest in gear acceleration times in its class according to a road test I've got upstairs) and will eat the GTI for breakfast off the mark. While actual power will eventually take over from the power/weight advantage the GTI has only got an extra 12bhp, so that's not going to help much.

The GTI has a better chassis, which will make a difference on twisty roads, and ultimately yes it's a better built, better equipped car (not that this is the point of a performance-related thread). But the G40 will always be more responsive to a heavy right foot, feel more raw and give a greater impression of speed compared to the GTI. So on top of being faster it'll give you more of a buzz in the process.

Owt wrong with using one as a daily either, I used mine for years. But I do a lot of miles and wanted a barge to keep the miles off the aging G40.

  • Author

well that pissed on MY bonfire!

:-D

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.