Skip to content

mk5 or mk 4?

Featured Replies

my current mk4 1.4

Photo046.jpg

and the mk5 1.4, this has gold multi spoke wheels on atm tho. it has the kamei grill but i will be buyin a bonnet bra to cover the badge bit in the bonnet.

post-10156-1209203712_thumb.jpg

post-10156-1204908133_thumb.jpg

  • Replies 24
  • Views 1.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

MK5 everytime. Better looking inside and out, generally better engines as long as you steer clear of the pitiful 1.0L lumps. Personally I'd get the gap welded up and painted cause bonnet bras look so chavvy. Well I say that, if it were me I'd keep the VW badge :lol:

Mk4 FTW....... just better lookin .....¿¿ :)

mk 5 mate 8-)

mk4 :D

you should know which you prefer to drive etc?

no contest really... get the mk5!

why would anyone choose a mk4 over the mk5?! the mk5 is better built, better spec'd its a no brainer

MK5 definately.

MK5 Because it looks alot smarter and its a newer car !

Ronal R10's FTW by the way :D

I got a mk4 because i preferred the look of them over the mk5. clearly its not a no brainer, just what you prefer :) and why would you buy something just because its newer?

People spend alot of money doing up mk1 caddys, golfs etc, when they could of just bought something alot newer for the same price, but wheres the fun in that :D

Just the way i look at it anyway :)

Dale.

That Mk5 look pretty smart. Defo mk5 in my opinion every time.

I got a mk4 because i preferred the look of them over the mk5. clearly its not a no brainer, just what you prefer :) and why would you buy something just because its newer?

People spend alot of money doing up mk1 caddys, golfs etc, when they could of just bought something alot newer for the same price, but wheres the fun in that :D

Just the way i look at it anyway :)

Dale.

yea obvioulsy theres fun when doing up something old skool like mk1golfs, caddy etc. but a mk4 polo is alot more modern than them and you may aswell go a little bit newer with a mk5, imo

MK5 !!!!!, and i own a mk4 lool

All you do is make a Mk4 look like a mk5 i.e rear light, splitter, seats door card, the lot so might as well save your money and get 1, i would of got a 6N2 if i could aford to buy a half right 1.4 1 and insured it

But i do love my Mk4

Edited by Po*Low*

Mk5 Even if it's just for the galv shell.

MK5 !!!!!, and i own a mk4 lool

But i do love my Mk4

x2 Apart from i dont love it. piece of shitt lol

Mk5 :thumbsup: mk4 :thumbsdown:

Surely the best polo vs a attempt at a remake its the Mk4 all over lol, better looks, cheaper mods and more possibilites 6n2s aways seemed boring and like your nan owned it :D

  • Author

haha well cheers for the comments people. I'm still not sure. might sell them both and go for the mk1 golf tbf but if not its 1 of them 2

Keep the mk4 Jack!

Its been a good little car :D

Jordan :)

Mk4 mate!!!! even though i like both :)

mk2 golf GTi or mk3 polo GT on bike carbs. think outside the box...

Overall i prefer the MK5`s but these two cars preciselyyy

hmmmm............... MK4 :D

mk 5 man keep the badge fo sho and also mk 4 just look to weird for my likings.

MK5 Because it looks alot smarter and its a newer car !

I hate it when people bring the age of a car into an argument like this as if its a valid point.

As if being newer somehow makes it better.

There are reasons for buying both taking age, general looks and engines out the equation.

Underneath they are pretty much the same car so the handling on both should be about equal.

The Mk5 has a galvanised shell so unless its been very badly treated it should be rust free.

But seeing a clean rust free Mk4 is a rare site these days but they take more effort to keep this way.

I always see people commenting on a Mk5 interior saying it is nicer than a Mk4? I think the Mk5 interior is too bland, rounded and girly for my liking, a Mk4 interior is just right, feels like a nice place to be, not exactly a nice thing to look at but its all you ever need from an interior.

And then there is the gearbox issue, both cars suffer from them but it seems to be more a Mk5 thing than a Mk4 thing.

Personally I'd have a Mk4 over a Mk5 anyday but its your choice and whatever you feel better driving in.

i like them both, but i would go for the mk5 :)

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.