Skip to content

Dilema - MOT failure pay up or scrap?

Featured Replies

I need to make a quick decision on this, do I spend the £1,500+ getting my GTi thru it's MOT :x (suspension all needs replacing) or do I scrap it. If I scrap it what are the major parts worth?

- Engine (99k FSH)

- Gearbox (recon at 75k, oil change at 90k)

- Full heated leather interior (it would need to be sold with the boot mounted region free DVD player+remote) as the head rests have screens mounted

- Pioneer AVIC-D3 sat nav dvd player + ipod connector + bluetooth h/free + pioneer boot mounted 6 stack cd + power amp

- 16" split rim bbs

It's a 2001 (51 plated) 5 door - thanks

  • Replies 30
  • Views 1.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

£1500? i'd bung some coilies on it and i reckon any other minor bits i'd be quoting £500 with parts take it somewhere else bud!

Olly

scrap?!? why on earth would you do that, surely it's worth way more than £1500? Anyway fitting complete new suspension shouldn't cost anywhere near 1500, what exactly wants replacing? what does the fail sheet say?

£1500 for "all" suspension? which bits exactly, for £1500 you could buy a whole car

or scrap it id say you would be lucky to get over £700 for the bits, then including the time effort removing them, i say fix it, or sell it as it is

Coilovers are £200 and fitting can be done by pretty much anyone in a weekend, shouldn't cost anywhere near £1500.

Thats assuming you have broken springs or knackered shocks.

as above - worst case is bushes and topmounts aswell as shocks etc, £200 for coily's £150 max for all bushes etc and £150 max to fit the lot!

Olly

For fifteen hundred quid I would hope to be getting an H&R fully adjustable set of coilovers :-o Is suspension all it needs?

/\/\ Probably better doing it that way, get all the bushes and build the coilies up then its just a simple case of swapping everything over.

You undo two bolts and a nut to remove a front shock and one bolt and one nut to remove a rear shock.

Actually the easiest thing in the world.

  • Author

they are quoting me £1,200 for springs/shocks/mounts/bearings (ok these are the geniune parts, i tried GSF but they simple don't stock the parts) - the shock mounts are the problems - however there are no mounts currently - they are describing it as "like a cup and a rounded piramid" - plus it needs lambda probe (£260) and possibly a replacement front light as it won't auto adjust - so it might go north of £1500.

no way - the top mounts don't really wear on a 6n2, the bearing plate can give up though. the other parts can be sourced cheaper.

those prices are ridiculous, source the parts yourself from somewhere like GSF or ECP or even get an uprated lowering kit.

Utter tosh.

Take it to another place to get the work sorted. You only have their word for the extent of the work required and they may just be scamming bastards. I'm sure someone on here could recommend a polo friendly garage or at least an honest garage locally to you.

I know someone who's wife took their car to a local kwikfit or ats or whatever it was called and they tried to and they tried to shit her up by saying that her suspension and brakes were shot and they couldn't really allow her to remove it from the garage for her own safety. Her husband fecked them off and collected it and it needed a set of front disks and pads!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Get the fail sheet off them and get them to demonstrate the faults to someone in the know.

  • Author

polo6n2g40 - thanks for those links mate

The garage is actually my local main VW dealer - I know you pay a premium but i've generally used them in the past for my various VW's and I have never had any issues any the costs don't really work out being much more than the independents quote me - i'm going to try and take day off an go and see them/car tomorrow - and they said they are more than happy to fit the non-VW parts (without warranty) if I want.

Now i'm over the shock i'll get it fixed up

yeh that sounds like a silly price, loads of garages are scaming bastards, i remember when my thermo stat went the garage it was at said it was the head gasket and wanted £1500 to change it and skim the head, told them to fuck off and got another garage to change the stat and houseing for £90. that why i try to do every thing myself or my mate as he knows alot more than me lol.

I've been to garages like that before and thats the last time I used them.

Get a final price for all the parts you need from GSF plus a crate or 2 of beer and there might be some people on here willing to give you a hand one weekend.

Absolute joke buddy, take it elsewhere or fit a new set of replacement suspension. Even getting an upgraded kit would be a wise choice :)

id go elsewhere too ...prob trying to pull your pants down

are you sure its not advisorys they're trying to get you to have done?

as said gsf and the like will supply all new dampers , mounts and bushes for a couple of hundred , i very doubt they're all faulty though

main dealers will charge a fortune, you're best off taking it to an independent specialist.

I'll give you £1500 for it right now

1500 quid is about rigtht for a main dealer

mate i wouldnt bother that seems way too much, main dealers always take the piss, for example.

had a VW transporter a 52 plate (2 years old at the time) and it was on a private plate that made it a 'P' reg, took it in for some work, cant remember what, and because the private plate was on a VW sharan a couple years before that, and had been in the garage, they rang up and said a big list of all this work that needed doing as they'd just looked at the reg and said a vehicle needed new brakes cambelt ect ect, they hadn't even taken a look at it!!

i got a mate who got me clutch and fitted it for £75 and while he was at it put new discs and pads on the front....

so id say get the parts and pay some1 to do it or have a go at it urself. either way i wudnt pay £1500

Pretty sure if you source the parts yourself someone off here will fit them for a reasonable price.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.