Skip to content

VW Golf vs 320i

Featured Replies

Just wondering what would win at the lights in a drag race

is VW golf mk4 TDi (115bhp)

or the

316i e36 with a 320i engine

what do you think

I think the golf would win

  • Replies 25
  • Views 2.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

win to what, 30?

beemer i reckon and jake a 1/4 mile.....alot lighter and more power per ton. u will have better traction though off the line.

  • Author
beemer i reckon and jake a 1/4 mile.....alot lighter and more power per ton. u will have better traction though off the line.

But the turbo on tr golf kicks in at low revs so wouldn't it pull off quicker, that's what I meant?

So is it an E36 320i or an E36 316i thats been converted to a 320i?

I reckon in a race to 100+ mph it would be pretty even to be honest.

I have an E36 318is and have recently had a play with a Bora TDI 130 and we were pretty even to about 100ish then the Bora shot off.

I recon we would have a similar situation with a 320i and a Golf 115 TDI as they are both a slightly slower version of the cars mentioned above.

And before anyone starts yes I am saying a 320i is slower than a 318is...it is actually fact.

Edited by kwijibo_coupe

yeah...thought i said tht

but with it being only a small turbo, u get all you are low ent torque sudenly then u got to change gear...then a bit of tubolag (possibly) and then u gotta do it again....whereas the beemer will have a longer range on torque....but i do think the bmw would win because its lighter....mk4s are heavy as fuck...i might be wrong though btw

yeah...thought i said tht

but with it being only a small turbo, u get all you are low ent torque sudenly then u got to change gear...then a bit of tubolag (possibly) and then u gotta do it again....whereas the beemer will have a longer range on torque....but i do think the bmw would win because its lighter....mk4s are heavy as fuck...i might be wrong though btw

Your average Mk4 diesel Golf will be about 1100kg ish where as a BMW 320i is 1300kg+

The Mk4 isn't as heavy as everyone makes out, VW just never put the greatest of engines into them.

And the 320i is just a revvy small 6 pot BMW, very little torque really, 150bhp, but it is heavier and you have to rev it.

  • Author
So is it an E36 320i or an E36 316i thats been converted to a 320i?

I reckon in a race to 100+ mph it would be pretty even to be honest.

I have an E36 318is and have recently had a play with a Bora TDI 130 and we were pretty even to about 100ish then the Bora shot off.

I recon we would have a similar situation with a 320i and a Golf 115 TDI as they are both a slightly slower version of the cars mentioned above.

And before anyone starts yes I am saying a 320i is slower than a 318is...it is actually fact.

It's a 316i converted to a 320i

by the way it's a saloon so it would be heavier than the coupe one.

they saloons arnt much hevier than the coupes. it all depends on the driver too though...drag him and find out lol

but the 318 is the 4cyl int it? still a 2L so in this case more torque....to give reason on you are outragous comment lol like i said I'm no expert just going off what i think i know and what people have said lol

So is it an E36 320i or an E36 316i thats been converted to a 320i?

I reckon in a race to 100+ mph it would be pretty even to be honest.

I have an E36 318is and have recently had a play with a Bora TDI 130 and we were pretty even to about 100ish then the Bora shot off.

I recon we would have a similar situation with a 320i and a Golf 115 TDI as they are both a slightly slower version of the cars mentioned above.

And before anyone starts yes I am saying a 320i is slower than a 318is...it is actually fact.

It's a 316i converted to a 320i

by the way it's a saloon so it would be heavier than the coupe one.

To be honest the weight difference between the coupe and the saloon with be very little, talking less than 100kg's so the kind of weight difference that can be made by having a mate with you.

What is the point of the whole question anyway? Seems a random choice of cars and to be neither of them are in any way considered fast, or anything special.

  • Author
So is it an E36 320i or an E36 316i thats been converted to a 320i?

I reckon in a race to 100+ mph it would be pretty even to be honest.

I have an E36 318is and have recently had a play with a Bora TDI 130 and we were pretty even to about 100ish then the Bora shot off.

I recon we would have a similar situation with a 320i and a Golf 115 TDI as they are both a slightly slower version of the cars mentioned above.

And before anyone starts yes I am saying a 320i is slower than a 318is...it is actually fact.

It's a 316i converted to a 320i

by the way it's a saloon so it would be heavier than the coupe one.

To be honest the weight difference between the coupe and the saloon with be very little, talking less than 100kg's so the kind of weight difference that can be made by having a mate with you.

What is the point of the whole question anyway? Seems a random choice of cars and to be neither of them are in any way considered fast, or anything special.

Ok it's because parents got the gold and friends bro has got a 320i e36 and inthink the golf will take it at the start and he thinks otherwise

I know I'm a big fan of straight 6 engines but I supporting the golf

It may be pointless to you but not to me

I'm only asking for your opinions

and I appreciate who has givn their opinions

Edited by S444NDP

haha was joking, but yea the golf might get off the line slightly quicker but the beemer will soon go past!

They are both dog shit slow lol.

Why not google it, surely they both have book figures?

I say the golf, they go ok. My mate had an e30 320i and my 55bhp polo was pretty much as fast, even off the line lol.

  • Author
They are both dog shit slow lol.

Why not google it, surely they both have book figures?

I say the golf, they go ok. My mate had an e30 320i and my 55bhp polo was pretty much as fast, even off the line lol.

Cool

They are both dog shit slow lol.

Why not google it, surely they both have book figures?

I say the golf, they go ok. My mate had an e30 320i and my 55bhp polo was pretty much as fast, even off the line lol.

E30 320s have got about 3 bhp. The E36s have 150 bhp, and a much better set of ratios compared to the E30 as well.

Even though the E36 320is aren't anything special, they are unlikely to have any trouble dusting off a 115 bhp diesel Golf. The Golf will have around 100 bhp per tonne, that's not far off a Polo GT. The BMW will have about 110-115 bhp per tonne, along with better traction, and ultimately more power and usable revs.

bit off topic but seen as though a few people here know what there on about with bmw's, I've got the 316i compact, anyone know where i can get it chipped? or buy one

my mate has a 320i and i have a 318is, he couldnt over take me on a straight drag race

After owning one and being in another 2, the 318iS is a lot faster than BMW suggests. A 320i shouldn't even get a look in once on the move, not till about 130 anyway. I fucking loved mine :D

Even though the E36 320is aren't anything special, they are unlikely to have any trouble dusting off a 115 bhp diesel Golf. The Golf will have around 100 bhp per tonne, that's not far off a Polo GT. The BMW will have about 110-115 bhp per tonne, along with better traction, and ultimately more power and usable revs.

it's not about the bhp figures in the golf though, the bhp may not be far off a GT (well if you consider 40bhp to be not far off) but the golf will have masses more torque.

bhp sells cars, torque wins races...

well that's what some one that know's a shit load more about car's than i ever will said any way :lol:

i'm not saying either will win as i haven't had any experience of either, but comparing bhp figures is never going to prove any thing because your only concentrating on one of many factors.

Edited by McLOVIN

After owning one and being in another 2, the 318iS is a lot faster than BMW suggests. A 320i shouldn't even get a look in once on the move, not till about 130 anyway. I fucking loved mine :D

i hear that!

even though its only 140bhp the m44 has like 180nm or torque, which is a fair bit more than a lot of engines of the same capacity tbh

still lacks power severely though, to make it powerslide in the dry you have to drive like a madman and even then it usually ends in fail :lol:

Even though the E36 320is aren't anything special, they are unlikely to have any trouble dusting off a 115 bhp diesel Golf. The Golf will have around 100 bhp per tonne, that's not far off a Polo GT. The BMW will have about 110-115 bhp per tonne, along with better traction, and ultimately more power and usable revs.

it's not about the bhp figures in the golf though, the bhp may not be far off a GT (well if you consider 40bhp to be not far off) but the golf will have masses more torque.

bhp sells cars, torque wins races...

well that's what some one that know's a shit load more about car's than i ever will said any way :lol:

i'm not saying either will win as i haven't had any experience of either, but comparing bhp figures is never going to prove any thing because your only concentrating on one of many factors.

it will have more torque but i really dont expect much from diesels tbh. you can never use the power!

i raced off the lights down a bypass some guy in a new shape astra diesel, who claimed it was remapped to 190bhp

i was ahead, then he had the inside line of a long corner so ended up at the end of my bonnet then we were doing 120mph and it was time to slow down

now, he was either lying, or the power just isnt useable. only good if youre in gear and overtaking. in my humble opinion of course

After owning one and being in another 2, the 318iS is a lot faster than BMW suggests. A 320i shouldn't even get a look in once on the move, not till about 130 anyway. I fucking loved mine :D

i hear that!

even though its only 140bhp the m44 has like 180nm or torque, which is a fair bit more than a lot of engines of the same capacity tbh

still lacks power severely though, to make it powerslide in the dry you have to drive like a madman and even then it usually ends in fail :lol:

The M42 which is in mine lacks a bit on the low down torque but if the revs are kept up past 4500rpm then it will hold its own against pretty much anything.

Powersliding in the dry is a risky buisness in them though, you usually have to be going well too quick to do it which means if you loose it, its not likely to end well.

www.letstorquebhp.com

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.