Skip to content

£3k high mileage polo gti or low mileage pug 206 gti

Featured Replies

My mate is after a new car he has about £3k to spend and hes torn between a 206 gti 2.0 or a polo gti 1.6. I'm sure theres plenty of pros and cons to both cars, however they seem to have similar spec although I believe the 206 has part leather and slightly better peformance. What would you buy with £3k out of these and what are the pros and cons to both.....

  • Replies 13
  • Views 1.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Definately not a 206 GTI unless it's a 180. The normal 136 bhp 206 GTIs are quite gutless but the 180s certainly go alright. I'd have a GTI 180 over a Polo GTI, but a Polo GTI over a base GTI.

Incidentally what's the mileage on the Polo?

I think he needs to drive both before making that decision, you'll find it hard on here to get help, as some people will be huge 6N2 GTi fans, and others will start waffling about GTi gearboxes, which is a legitimate point in itself.

I like the 206 GTi's and have heard good things about the 180's performance but personally I'd go for a 6N2 GTi as a) I am blinkered and b) my dad has a 206 and the pedals are so close together I find it difficult to drive plus the interior ain't great either, however these problems may have been rectified on later models? I am unsure.

  • Author

It just seems pretty difficult to pick up a polo gti with low mileage i.e. less than 80k for less than £3k whereas you can get a 206 gti with less than 60k on for less than £3k. I own a polo gti and love it and yes the build quality is argueably better than the 206's but in terms of the performance handling and fun factor I think the 206 gti will be better?

It seems your not really clued up as to what 'high' mileage is.

The average milage for the youngest 6n2 Polo GTI is around 112,000miles, so finding one with around 80,000 miles is low mileage in my eyes.

And you can't compare cars just on mileage alone.

Who is to say the Pug hasn't done all its 60,000 miles on the red line and being raced off every set of traffic lights in the county.

Whereas the Polo may have 80,000 miles but it might have a more comprehensive history and been driving alot better than the Pug.

I agree with what FoleE said about the pedals in the 206, also my feet touch the steering column which I hate, and are all round very small inside. If it was me I would go for the polo.

However as said, best bet is for him to test drive both and see which he prefer to drive, performance wise etc

You probably won't get very un-biased opinions on this matter from a Polo forum...

Polo GTI everytime. Those 206s feel so naff inside. Even the high spec ones feel cheap.

Wonder if you asked this on a Pug forum what they would say??

  • Author

It is probably the wrong place to ask, hes now bought it though anyway...... he opted for the 206 gti

He managed to get a 2001 example in immaculate condition for only £2250 (was priced at £2700 originaly) and its only done 32k from new. For a polo gti of similiar mileage which would be as rare as rocking horse shit youve gota be looking at about 4k. He's got all the features of a polo gti (apart from xenons) plus half leather, better performance, but yes build quality is probably worse and its french bla bla bla, like I said originally pros and cons to both but hes got a lot of car for the money there. Thanks for the comments / opinions

To be fair, off the fence now the Pug build is terrible, no where near a patch on the VW.

So the Olop gets my vote, it maybe a bit slower, but if you are unlucky enough to hit something, at least the VW will hold together better.

clio ph1 172 and the rest towards insurance

i agree with a few people stating how badly built the 206 is. ok don't get me wrong, its fantastic car in performance state but i would go for the polo GTI. Only reason because you get a whole lot more car for your money, it'll last longer than a 206 (depending how it has been driven mind you) & a polo GTI will most likely hold its value more.

These are the main things i consider when buying a car but your may be different.

I used to own a Saxo VTR & 206, both were very fun cars to drive but they do get very tatty even mines were looked after. Now being a VW owner i find i'd never touch them again, only because the amount of problems that arised when i owned both french cars. The Polo feels a fantastic car all round

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.