Skip to content

Are most mechanics crap?

Featured Replies

Every time I've taken a car to a mechanic to get some work done they have ALWAYS done a below average job. Is it juts me or are most mechanics utter crap?

Taken my car in today to try and solve an issue, its come back timed up wrong and idling between 1500 and 2000 rpm, worse thing is he hasn't fixed the said issue... I paid £75 for some chump to make my car worse! Deffo going back tomorrow for him to sort it, or do you guys think call it a loss and sort it elsewhere, he obviously doesn't know what he's doing...

Anyone else had similar problems with crap mechanics?

Edited by MrP

  • Replies 39
  • Views 2.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

i wouldnt say all mechanics are crap, I'm a mechanic and i dont agree with you there.

best thing to do is take your car to where the work was carried out because they should sort it for free rather than you having to pay somewhere else to sort there fuck ups.

  • Author

Thats true,

I wasn't meaning to generalise as I know there are some good ones about, I'm just yet to find one, and after 7 years of looking i'm starting to loose faith...

My only worry is that if he couldn't do the work in the first place, what's going to change tomorrow when I take it back?

Anyone else had similar problems with crap mechanics?

Yes :(

Many will tell you they can do the job even though they may not have any idea what they're doing!

I'd take the car back and get them to fix it for free. If they wont, get it fixed elsewhere and claim your money back from the garage that got it wrong!

Not all, just most!

The customer is impossible to please. Sure,being given your car in perfect working order would be ideal,but its not as easy as you'd think. Especially when most of the time the customer hasn't looked after the thing,and it's mission impossible. Certainly within any amount of time that's gonna be profitable.

Take yesterday. I'm glad time did,because it wasn't entirely welcome.

I mean,how hard can it be to replace a thermostat on an '02 Astra? Its a 40 second job on a Polo.

But with the Astra,you have to remove the cambelt,cam pulleys,engine mount.. Its a couple of hours even when everything goes right. And you've still got other cars to do,and you'll do them in a rush,now.

Its a tedious business,especially in an age where everyone wants it perfect and wants it yesterday.

So take it back,but keep your sleeves down if you want to get anywhere.

i must be lucky i know 2 good'uns,you just need to keep looking , ask your mate's or family and see who they use

  • Author
The customer is impossible to please. Sure,being given your car in perfect working order would be ideal,but its not as easy as you'd think. Especially when most of the time the customer hasn't looked after the thing,and it's mission impossible. Certainly within any amount of time that's gonna be profitable.

Take yesterday. I'm glad time did,because it wasn't entirely welcome.

I mean,how hard can it be to replace a thermostat on an '02 Astra? Its a 40 second job on a Polo.

But with the Astra,you have to remove the cambelt,cam pulleys,engine mount.. Its a couple of hours even when everything goes right. And you've still got other cars to do,and you'll do them in a rush,now.

Its a tedious business,especially in an age where everyone wants it perfect and wants it yesterday.

So take it back,but keep your sleeves down if you want to get anywhere.

Good advice!

I agree with what your saying and that is exactly why I went to a specialist who even said they know Polo GT's really well. Only thing that has annoyed me is that I had a 20 min conversation about what work has been done and absolutely ruled out some possibilities, he sounded like he knew what he was talking about and said he was a specialist on these cars... It was timed perfect 1 day before, idle was spot on, all by myself, now the dizzy is FULLY advanced and its idling at about 2k rpm. How can a professional think that it was right?

I just hate being ripped off. £75 is a lot to throw away as a student.

i must be lucky i know 2 good'uns,you just need to keep looking , ask your mate's or family and see who they use

Yeah, i have a mate who's shit hot mechanically and hes very reasonable (i offer him money, he refuses :lol:)

in my experience most are, i'm not sure why and it's one of the reasons i left the trade.

i used to treat every car as my own, greasing all bolts that go back in, refitting everything the way it was intended (wires and hoses in clips etc) and even though i was mainly doing gearboxes give the car a once over and let the customer know what's on it's way out or what to keep an eye on and checked the oil and coolant too. i'd always give the bay a wipe over and little spruce up after i was done.

i wouldn't charge for a job not done regardless of time spent, if i diagnosed a problem - changed that part out and the issue was still there then obviously no charge.

the only time i would charge was if i was given a job to cure a problem - ie 'the clutch is gone olly, can you change it', so i whip the box off to reveal a good clutch and a forked box i'd still charge for the clutch labour.

sunday was a prime examle, a mate asked me to look at his polo 59k fsh top end rattle, no mayo, no overheating, no knocking, no oil pressure so i tell him it sounds like the oil pump. i spent most of sunday changing the pump out on my back on his gravel drive in the rain only for me to start it up and it's exactly the same. result being no charge from me, turns out the head is holed just before the pressure switch internally.

Olly

i took my show car to a local garage (meant to be a specialist) for a major service inc cambelt cost was approx £400 went in running fine came out stalling every time i put my foot on the clutch sort off fixed now the ht leads they had fucked up to the twin coils and the timing was way out. the garage has closed down now thank fuck

I think the problem is, a lot of guys dont know what they're doing, they just know how to do it.

  • Author
in my experience most are, i'm not sure why and it's one of the reasons i left the trade.

i used to treat every car as my own, greasing all bolts that go back in, refitting everything the way it was intended (wires and hoses in clips etc) and even though i was mainly doing gearboxes give the car a once over and let the customer know what's on it's way out or what to keep an eye on and checked the oil and coolant too. i'd always give the bay a wipe over and little spruce up after i was done.

i wouldn't charge for a job not done regardless of time spent, if i diagnosed a problem - changed that part out and the issue was still there then obviously no charge.

the only time i would charge was if i was given a job to cure a problem - ie 'the clutch is gone olly, can you change it', so i whip the box off to reveal a good clutch and a forked box i'd still charge for the clutch labour.

sunday was a prime examle, a mate asked me to look at his polo 59k fsh top end rattle, no mayo, no overheating, no knocking, no oil pressure so i tell him it sounds like the oil pump. i spent most of sunday changing the pump out on my back on his gravel drive in the rain only for me to start it up and it's exactly the same. result being no charge from me, turns out the head is holed just before the pressure switch internally.

Olly

Why can't everyone be like you! I don't want to be charged for something that hasn't been done. Its ridiculous. Everything he's done I could have done within 20 mins, I got charged 1.5 hrs labour to get my car back worse than it was. I'm going back in tomorrow and asking him very politely to sort it or I'll be wanting a refund, partial at best. I understand that it's his business and time is money etc, but i'm paying him to fix the problem, not just look for it.

I think the problem is, a lot of guys dont know what they're doing, they just know how to do it.

Yep, Your probably right, I know how to change a clutch for example and know how to do it perfect on a polo, but to do it on a renault, I'd probably mess it up somewhere!

Have to agree with the crap mechanics.

If its not damage to the car, its a shoddy job.

I know a lad that works on my GTi at VW. He knows his stuff and he's a car enthusiast so looks after the motor while its there.

Its just the back street garages that want to make easy money and generally inexperienced cheap mechanics.

Its just the back street garages that want to make easy money and generally inexperienced cheap mechanics.

You can also apply that to the main dealer though. When i had a flat spot on my R32 (A known software bug) the dealers tried to tell me otherwise. I allready knew there was an ecu update available and had to insist they did it! I'm lucky that i have a couple of mates in the trade,plus have two local garages i know i can trust.

buy a haynes manual and do it yourself! I hate paying garages unless I really have to, Id rather do it myself :)

Lucky for me I've got a good mechanic local to me, plus i've got a mate who's a VW specialist and helps me out alot!

  • Author
buy a haynes manual and do it yourself! I hate paying garages unless I really have to, Id rather do it myself :)

I normally do, but I've tried everything to solve this issue so thought I'd go see a professional. Wrong!

fortunatly i know a cracking mechanic me lol but i take my car to a backstreet garage because the guys are the best at there trade they will even let me pay in installments my saloon is going in tomorrow the work will probably cost alot but i know the jobs done right and done to a high standard if its not to major ill fix it but working were i do i dont have alot of time for my motors now

  • Author

Called the mechanic today, he practically fobbed me off saying the car wasn't running right and he knew it was idling bad after he advanced the timing (but gave me the car back and charged me anyway - thanks!) and the earliest he can see me is next Thursday. Strange how he could fit me in the same day first time around.... but then takes over a week to fix an issue he put on the car.. Obviously he doesn't give a shit and just doesn't want to do the job. I'm not playing cat and mouse with him.

I strongly advise not to use G & S Autos - 26A Monk Bridge Road, Leeds, LS6 4ER.

Edited by MrP

I strongly advise not to use G & S Autos - 26A Monk Bridge Road, Leeds, LS6 4ER.

no offense mate but shame on you for naming and shaming a buisness NO MATTER what they done!

he might of just been a prick to you and noone else for some reason but to give his adress on a public forum is bang out imo!

if it stops someone else getting ripped off by them then its worth it?

why would the guy be a prick to just one person for no reason. they've fucked up his car and are being awkward about sorting it. if it was near me, i'd like to know not to take my car there too. it's not like he's not given them a chance to sort it out.

unfortunatley half arsed work from trained mechanics has made me resort to monkeying around with my car more and doing most of the work(like the bloody exhaust, the butcher work with the replacement cat and more). Ok fine, I might do something wrong, but I fix it and I learn something new. If I really can't solve the problem, I take the car to somebody who can. Then why not take it there in the first place? a.) that good mechanic is usually in a shed miles away b.)I like to monkey around with my car.

Edited by MehMan

I strongly advise not to use G & S Autos - 26A Monk Bridge Road, Leeds, LS6 4ER.

no offense mate but shame on you for naming and shaming a buisness NO MATTER what they done!

he might of just been a prick to you and noone else for some reason but to give his adress on a public forum is bang out imo!

not really you can give internet reviews etc and say whatever you want, and as said above me if its for the greater good then y not??? if someone was to say only use that firm no one would bat an eyelid!

I strongly advise not to use G & S Autos - 26A Monk Bridge Road, Leeds, LS6 4ER.

no offense mate but shame on you for naming and shaming a buisness NO MATTER what they done!

he might of just been a prick to you and noone else for some reason but to give his adress on a public forum is bang out imo!

not really you can give internet reviews etc and say whatever you want, and as said above me if its for the greater good then y not??? if someone was to say only use that firm no one would bat an eyelid!

Na mate you obviously dont get my point so fuck it!

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.