Skip to content

Just wondered ?

Featured Replies

anyone on here rockin a bluemotion ?

bet you could make them a pretty nippy car if you wanted with it being a Tdi

Shame about 3 cylinders and only 6 valves (:

Edited by Josh16v

  • Replies 21
  • Views 1.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Those 3 cylinder engines are lifeless. My mates mums got a normal TDI 3cyl and he says its pants

You'd have to change the tyres, a 'reduced friction tyre' sounds like madness to me!

Would be a good idea as they're a hard compound tyre so you feel every lil bump!

there would honestly be no point whatsoever in even trying.

the engine was built purely as an economy derv. The turbo and fuel pump will be reck solidly set to stay as they are, and to be honest, i doubt the actual engine components are built to withstand very much over its current power output.

fair enough, it's a turbo diesel, but that in no way makes it potentially powerful... diesels are slow, they will always be slower than petrol whether they have a turbo or not... and i'm not a synic of turbo diesels, i drive a 306 Dturbo, and for all it's power and fun, i know it'll never be as fast as its petrol counterpart, no matter how much i wind the pump screw or up the boost or how big an intercooler i have.

bluemotion = slowmotion

there would honestly be no point whatsoever in even trying.

Agree with that.

You would be completely missing the point.

i have a real crush on them cars...but not the engine. id get a standard petrol one and stick the blumotion kit on =]

tdi engines are so much better than petrol engines. The 1,4 tdi engine is such a good engine, loads of torque, good low down pull, cheap to insure and loads to the gallon. So much better than your gt's, 1.4 16vs etc. I've had a g40, lupo gti, 1.4 16v polo etc and my lupo tdi was more fun.

diesels are slow, they will always be slower than petrol whether they have a turbo or not... and i'm not a synic of turbo diesels, i drive a 306 Dturbo, and for all it's power and fun, i know it'll never be as fast as its petrol counterpart, no matter how much i wind the pump screw or up the boost or how big an intercooler i have.

hmm duno about this mate.. think of how much diesel has progressed over the years. i would say more than half the new cars out on the road these days are diesel, and that figure is only going to rise. petrol's days are numbered.

as for performance / power.. look at the Seat Ibizas in BTCC and the Peugeots / Audis in Le Mans. all rocking diesels and they are hardly behind the pack.

agree with everything else said though, only reason i would say mod a bluemotion is as an example to everyone else considering it! just not meant to happen!

my mums 3 cylinder sounds like a lawn mower when you rev it but she has had 75mpg out of it and its only £35 a year to tax it. the bluemotion she looked at but did'nt like the look of it but its free road tax as its under 100 c02 emission or somthing like that

my mates missus has a bluemotion had it since new, it not to slow, more than adaquete for day to day driving, and you wouldnt think its a 3 pot.

if you want performance tho you dont really start off with a 3 pot economy mobile tho

Of course some turbo diesels are getting as good as some of their petrol counterparts - because the counterpart engines are unfair.

Its not fair to compare a charged engine to a normally aspirated one. When a 2.0 turbo diesel proves better than a 2.0 turbo petrol, then i'll be impressed.

That diesels need everything they can get to be worth having says everything. But still they're not,throttle response is typically vacant,and they'll always be out of power by 4.5k rpm so their rev range is limiting. And they churn out soot at any revs,visible during labouring,diesel doesn't burn clean at all. It needs double the compression and still burns too slowly.

Diesels are crap.

Well sumed up mikey, the rev range on disels us the worst thing about them my dads focus has half the revs as my 16v and that just piss's me of plus the amount of lag from the turbo is a jokes, you put your foot down wait for 5 secs then the turbo kicks in then you have to change gear, IMO the cons out weight the pros of a diasel but that's just me I can understand if you do shit loads of miles and don't really care about speed.

The thing I don't like about diesels/diesel drivers is how they always go on about low down torque. Well, there aren't many diesels that will pull cleanly from under 1000 rpm (ie, no boost), that's something that a good petrol engine can pull off. Sure, you shouldn't really be labouring like that, but still. I've not got many kind words to say about diesel, other than it's a dirty way of saving money, if you can put up with the countless disadvantages. That said, I wouldn't say no to a 6 pot BMW diesel. Probably because they sound similar to a petrol, almost rev, and are genuinely fast.

Umm ok so I'll bring them up again.. Seat Ibiza in BTCC and the Peugeot's / Audi's in Le Mans racing?

If diesels are still so shit then why are these cars so good? I'm sure it's not just the fact that they have turbos..

Plus VWs most-used engine is their 1.9 TDi diesel engine or whatever it is I'm pretty sure.. why is that?

I very much doubt they'll do quite so well without the turbos,as the petrols have to do without,its blatantly not fair so of course that's why. The diesels need turbos to keep up with n/a petrols so i dont see how you can be so unsure.

And the 1.9 has been in everything,and there's rarely been any other option for those wanting diesel. So lets go along with your claim,with the most popular VW. If you want a petrol Golf,you've got a wide choice of engines. But diesel,and it had to be the 1.9 for so long (now 2.0). Economy is the main factor,few bought them for any other reason,its not like the Caddy's gonna sell with anything else,or like many TDi's were sold with four wheel drive and an R32 bodykit,they're bought for function. And everyone who ordered diesel got the 1.9 because that was the only choice.

Hence that unit being most popular.

Doesn't make it the best engine they've made - thats like saying Akon is the best musician in the world when he was at number one..

I very much doubt they'll do quite so well without the turbos,as the petrols have to do without,its blatantly not fair so of course that's why. The diesels need turbos to keep up with n/a petrols so i dont see how you can be so unsure.

And the 1.9 has been in everything,and there's rarely been any other option for those wanting diesel. So lets go along with your claim,with the most popular VW. If you want a petrol Golf,you've got a wide choice of engines. But diesel,and it had to be the 1.9 for so long (now 2.0). Economy is the main factor,few bought them for any other reason,its not like the Caddy's gonna sell with anything else,or like many TDi's were sold with four wheel drive and an R32 bodykit,they're bought for function. And everyone who ordered diesel got the 1.9 because that was the only choice.

Hence that unit being most popular.

Doesn't make it the best engine they've made - thats like saying Akon is the best musician in the world when he was at number one..

lolage, I love you

For so many of you to say diesels are crap has actually made me laugh. Especially in this day and age, don't you think you are all being pretty close-minded?

OK fair enough on the performance side, but you said it yourself - people buy them for economy. Not everyone wants to pointlessly race around town wasting energy and breaking speed limits. The fact that diesels have a small rev range and low powerband is what makes them so great for economy.

Just because you lot don't think they are 'fast' enough for you.. doesn't make diesels crap in any way. All new eco-projects being designed and considered are designed with diesel / compression-ignition in mind and so just because they aren't as 'revvy' or 'quick' as petrol engines, it doesn't make them shit.

And looking at how they have progressed in comparison with petrol engines, I would most definately say they are the future.

For so many of you to say diesels are crap has actually made me laugh. Especially in this day and age, don't you think you are all being pretty close-minded?

diesels are good for economy and good up to a point for tuning... but the point people are trying to make here is about petrols having more power. like mikey said... like for like, 2 turbo charged engines, same capacity... which is more powerful... petrol or diesel.

yes CWA everything you said is right but i dont think people on here are being close minded... just sceptical as to whether getting power out of a diesel is easier than getting it out of a petrol.

Edited by arron0909

My mate has a BMW 330d coupe and hes just had it chipped and its unreal, will pull from 1000rpm whatever gear your in and up climbs on the motorway etc it shits all over petrols!

Its quicker than the 330i petrol and does 40-45mpg, whats wrong with that?

I like diesel, it has benefits, i also like petrol and they have benefits! If i was buying a car with an option of diesel or petrol i would be hard pressed to choose

fair enough, i think i was a tad off topic anyways

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.