Skip to content

Polo Mk4 - Mk5

Featured Replies

I'm looking to buy a Mk4 Polo but like the look of the Mk5 (Mk4 Facelift?), which isn't really in budget. There is a few things I'm wanting to know before I decide, hopefully here is where I can get answers.

1) What are the common issues (both mechanically and body wise)?

2) How well do they handle lowered?

3) What parts of a Mk5 will bolt to a Mk4 (I like the front end and bumpers of the Mk5)?

4) How much is a good price for a decent 1.4?

I had a Mk3.5 1.1 Fiesta that got driven into the back of and I'm thinking of getting something a bit different. (Either a Polo or a Mk1 1.4 Clio).

Thanks in advance.

Edited by 1992

  • Replies 24
  • Views 3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Ok well i'll tell you now it'll be cheaper in the long run to buy a 6n2 if your gonna put the front on as it's quite abit of work! Also if you go on www.uk-polos.net there's buyers guides in the respective model sections! Happy hunting!

whatever you do dont buy a mk1 clio.....I've owned a mk1 rt and valver and both are riddled with problems, prone to rust on the arches, sills. There are many design faults that you will find have been purposely incorporated intot the cars design. Why do you think you can get them so cheap???

Got to be honest they are great fun to drive but id seriously stay away...going german was the best thing I've done, seriously more reliable than that french shit

Thanks for the replies.

Pepe: I'll have a look on that site, thanks.

Monkey-man: I'm looking for a car that has a decent 0-60 and handles well and won't change my insaurance too much (Group 4).

the clio is a little rapid through 1st and 2nd il give it that but in terms of practicality il guarantee youd wish you hadnt bought the clio.

I had a tdi straight after the clio, 1.4 tdi that is and it is a far better car, bhp is better, has far more overtaking muscle due to the far higher torque, has a faster top end far more economical. clio rt did about 35 mpg maybe 40 if your lucky, but that was when petrol was like 106.9p a ltr so now youl be looking at like 30 max. whereas even now with the higher priced diesel if i drive the tdi sensibly then il get a 65 to a gallon return.

And the beauty about the tdi is due to the fact it has a turbo with a simple remap and 2.5" bore straight through system, youl be seeing around 120 bhp and it wont harm the fuel economy abit, whereas with a mk1 clio you can carry on dreaming about 120 out of them, even carbed youl be lucky.

*edit* In terms of insurance also the tdi is cheaper that the rt

Edited by Monkey-man

My budget is around £800, might be able to squeeze £900. I don't think I'll be able to get a decent TD of any car for this.

I had a Clio 1.2 rl and it was great but no where near as great as a polo! Id save up abit more matey! Get something a lot better for a couple of hundred quid more!

I can afford a 1.4 "6n" Polo. What do they handle like?

well compared to what mate?? You can pick up some nice mk3 golf td and even the tdi version for around 900 - 1200. But seriously i can promise you you will regret buying a clio lol the amount of time and money i wasted on it,,,unreal.

In the first 10 months of me having my rt, i had to change 3 wheel bearing, 2 rear shocks, alternator belt,alternator,battery,wiper motor twice, fuel level sender and the water pump

well compared to what mate?? You can pick up some nice mk3 golf td and even the tdi version for around 900 - 1200. But seriously i can promise you you will regret buying a clio lol the amount of time and money i wasted on it,,,unreal.

In the first 10 months of me having my rt, i had to change 3 wheel bearing, 2 rear shocks, alternator belt,alternator,battery,wiper motor twice, fuel level sender and the water pump

I do like Mk3 golfs, but the insaurance group is too high on these things. The highest I can afford is a group 5.

I'm not entirely sure on the group of them. How old are you then matey?? You can buy 6n td's for around your budget but have no idea what they are like

I'm 18, been passed since August 2009 and driving since September 2009.

ah right lol i pity you...even though I'm only 2 years older, my insurance is considerably cheaper than that when i first passed my test and I've had 2 claims on my insurance lol

the clio is a little rapid through 1st and 2nd il give it that but in terms of practicality il guarantee youd wish you hadnt bought the clio.

I had a tdi straight after the clio, 1.4 tdi that is and it is a far better car, bhp is better, has far more overtaking muscle due to the far higher torque, has a faster top end far more economical. clio rt did about 35 mpg maybe 40 if your lucky, but that was when petrol was like 106.9p a ltr so now youl be looking at like 30 max. whereas even now with the higher priced diesel if i drive the tdi sensibly then il get a 65 to a gallon return.

And the beauty about the tdi is due to the fact it has a turbo with a simple remap and 2.5" bore straight through system, youl be seeing around 120 bhp and it wont harm the fuel economy abit, whereas with a mk1 clio you can carry on dreaming about 120 out of them, even carbed youl be lucky.

*edit* In terms of insurance also the tdi is cheaper that the rt

What? The MPG doesn't change with the price of petrol lol. If you put a gallon in you will still get the same amount of miles. But say if you put £20 in you would get less miles to that now.

My mate at college used to have a mk1 phase 2 clio 1.2, it was fairly quick but seemed to have no torque, my 1.4 8v is a little bit quicker. As with any car it had issues, leaky sunroof for example (but my polo open air also has this issue). I'd say the clio will probably be more fun to drive, but the Polo will be more reliable and nice to use on a daily basis.

£800-900 is a good amount to buy a 6n 1.4 8v with. You can pick up a fairly low milage, clean example for that.

Glad someone picked up on that, I was away to say.

I had a tdi straight after the clio, 1.4 tdi that is and it is a far better car, bhp is better, has far more overtaking muscle due to the far higher torque, has a faster top end far more economical. clio rt did about 35 mpg maybe 40 if your lucky, but that was when petrol was like 106.9p a ltr so now youl be looking at like 30 max. whereas even now with the higher priced diesel if i drive the tdi sensibly then il get a 65 to a gallon return.

Oh my lord....i laughed so much at that i got a stitch.

Are you for real or just taking the piss mate...how do you figure that out?

I do often wonder at times if some people forgot to go to school?

Either that or they were the people who were "too cool" for school and didn't see the importance of it at the time!

I had a tdi straight after the clio, 1.4 tdi that is and it is a far better car, bhp is better, has far more overtaking muscle due to the far higher torque, has a faster top end far more economical. clio rt did about 35 mpg maybe 40 if your lucky, but that was when petrol was like 106.9p a ltr so now youl be looking at like 30 max. whereas even now with the higher priced diesel if i drive the tdi sensibly then il get a 65 to a gallon return.

Oh my lord....i laughed so much at that i got a stitch.

Are you for real or just taking the piss mate...how do you figure that out?

he must be takin the piss, 106.9p a litre is considerably cheaper than what it is now and 30 mpg id say more like 10 lol

!!!

Many replies lol.

Basically, buy a MK5, not a MK4.

Reason I say is that your planning on making it look like a MK5 anyway, as you've asked about bolt on bits?

The MK5 is a much more solid car in every aspect. Interior is worlds apart in the MK5 compared to the ancient interior styling in the MK4.

The body of a MK5 is also alot more rustproof than a MK4!

Basically, buy a MK5, not a MK4.

Reason I say is that your planning on making it look like a MK5 anyway, as you've asked about bolt on bits?

The MK5 is a much more solid car in every aspect. Interior is worlds apart in the MK5 compared to the ancient interior styling in the MK4.

The body of a MK5 is also alot more rustproof than a MK4!

I would do if I could get one in my budget.

mk5 1 litres are just in your budget, but it will be tacky.

As for speed. mk4 1.4 8v's arnt much faster than the 1 litres, so its worth looking out for look for both.

I've had a mk4 + mk5 and i must say the mk5 handled so much better (even tho there the same chassis design with a bit of front end tinkering on the mk5), Used to roll abit but it still stuck.

the mk4 just seemed worse in everyway, the later the models are better as they fixed niggle things whilst in production.

My girl picked up her Mk4 (6N1) Polo 1.4 8v openair comfortably within your budget, it's a tidy motor and feels pretty nippy thanks to the low weight.

Considering it's got 96k on the clock it drives and handles superbly. All I'd advise is that I've been driving German motor's since 2002 and haven't looked back. High milers are fine if they've been looked after (i.e. serviced regularly and properly). the most important is the timing belt service at 60k (I believe) and regular oil changes. A good indicator that a Polo's been serviced properly is that they've used G12 in the coolant - it's red rather than blue that you find in most other cars (it's an Audi/VW thing).

My mate has a 6N2 on an X plate, and I confess, I prefer the look of it. However, as has been pointed out, they are a facelift of the same chassis so it's gotta be mostly cosmetic changes? Also, after reading these forums the conversion looks like a lot of work, though it does look like you can do a straight swap tail lights, back tailgate and bumper, though those more experienced in the polo world will confirm this either way.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.