Skip to content

Engine cranes... to buy or not to buy.

Featured Replies

Hey Guys and Girls.

Looking for a little bit of advice really...

Need to do an engine change in the next few weeks. While the engine is out i want to clean up the bay and get it looking respectable.

Is it worth buying a cheapy ebay crane for 115 quid and having that extra control what with there being no time limits.

OR

Do i hire 1 for about 50 quid for a week and just make sure that everything gets done in time... realistically i would only have an hour a night and a weekend to do it so I'm pretty strapped for time.

What do people on here think? Anyone had any experience of cheapy engine hoists? I know in general its "buy cheap, buy twice" but thats why i thought i would see if anyone on here has used/got one?

This is the 1 I'm looking at:

http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/1-TON-FOLDING-HYDRAU...oving_Equipment

Cheers! :-D

Marcus

  • Replies 20
  • Views 2.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

My mate has that same one, I've used it loads of times and its been sweet 8-)

If you can afford the extra 65 quid and have storage space (dont need much tbh) then id buy the crane, you never know when you'll need it again

i rented one for a weekend the first time. was expencive £60,

so next time i thought well in my life time will get used a good few times and i had some space to keep a folding one. so i got a Machine mart one on one of there VAT free nights (£120 for the 1 ton one). been used loads of times and 5 or 6 of my mates have got a loan of it too at times. its a bit of a bitch to transport but makes moving engines about or servicing a doddle.

depends if this is a one of engine change or if you think you will be "playing polo" more often.

Edit: just checked this is the one i got :click me its went up in price over the last 5 years but is very good fits under a lowered polo and the reach is good on it too. it looks identical to the Ebay one so i would buy the Ebay one - for that price and free delivery is a bargain.

Edited by genesisGT

all i will say is hes sold 140 with 99% positive feedback and i cant find a negative about this item

i might get 1 too :)

Get the crane. If you use it three times your already quids in. They are a useful thing to have kicking about.

Depends a bit, if it's a mk1-3, you don't really need one.

Worth looking on eBay too. New-ish 1 tonne cranes generally go for ~£80.

Hey Guys and Girls.

Looking for a little bit of advice really...

Need to do an engine change in the next few weeks. While the engine is out i want to clean up the bay and get it looking respectable.

Is it worth buying a cheapy ebay crane for 115 quid and having that extra control what with there being no time limits.

OR

Do i hire 1 for about 50 quid for a week and just make sure that everything gets done in time... realistically i would only have an hour a night and a weekend to do it so I'm pretty strapped for time.

What do people on here think? Anyone had any experience of cheapy engine hoists? I know in general its "buy cheap, buy twice" but thats why i thought i would see if anyone on here has used/got one?

This is the 1 I'm looking at:

http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/1-TON-FOLDING-HYDRAU...oving_Equipment

Cheers! :-D

Marcus

I use this exact one at work for lifting big things out of machines :)

tie a rope to each lifting eye, put one foot on each suspension strut, put the rope over your shoulders and pick it up, then walk off with the engine :-D

or buy the crane... they really are very handy. i don't have one but i've borrowed my mates many a time.

lol I've just bought one thanks for posting that link bud

  • Author

Looks like i should stop pussyfooting round and just buy the thing! lol.

Might get in contact and push for some commision or something :lol:

lol why not you can but ask lol

never had a look before, but looks exactly like the one I have access to. Been great to use, has helped remove a 3.0L vauxhall senator engine :lol: that thing is biiiiiig but sooo wonderful :-D

Did the Senator have advanced chassis technology?

Depends a bit, if it's a mk1-3, you don't really need one.

Totally. I change engines more often than brake pads,literally. I've done more engine swaps in Fiestas than Polos and still I've never needed a crane.

Its easier to just drop it out,and lift a short engine back in,then put the head on and torque the head bolts in situ. What you need is a nice wide trolley jack (garage one). Costco sell a good one for £80.

shortfitting.jpg

  • Author

Cheers for all the replies.

MikeyMK, thats not an AFH is it? I know there is sweet fuck all room in the bay with an AFH in a Mk3 so thought it would be best to drop the whole engine in. Stupid polo is fucking up now though so it may be a while before anything get dropped in anything! :?

MikeyMK, thats not an AFH is it? I know there is sweet fuck all room in the bay with an AFH in a Mk3 so thought it would be best to drop the whole engine in.

Room is no issue,the short block engines are all the same size. That one is obviously an alloy cylinder block but I've filled it with 1.6 internals,which i then lifted into place before nailing an AFH head and belt drive to it (thanks to the assistance of Rover V6 head bolts). Takes up exactly the same space as a full standard AFH,oil pan is only a few mill' wider.

  • Author

Oh cool. I havnt split my AFH head as of yet... so how hard is it to put the cambelt on when its in situ? Having looked at urs and saf's build threads it looks like there is hardly any room. Would rather get the engine 100% ready and then drop it in as a unit. Or am i bieng over cautious/stupid?

i wouldnt put one on in situ, it would be a bloody nightmare trying to tension everything up with a torque wrench.

dude seriously get a crane, they are sooooooo worth it, spesh if you can bag a cheap one on ebay. adams crane saved my freaking life, as did humers when he lent me his. i owe the lads for lending me them, mind you I've paid em back in man hours!

be overly cautious and check everything twice, would be my word of advise. putting th eengine in and finding youve overlooked something simple is the bain of my existance!

I've put the lupo engine in the mk1 on my own with no crane, but i had a massive trolley jack and a couple of billy big bars. without the huge hydro jack, you dont really stand a chance.

edit:- unless your a complete beefcake like some of the posters above, me i weigh about 9 stone haha so as much as i dont mind carry engines about, id prefer not to be a cripple by the time I'm 40

Edited by grungeisdead

Doing it without a crane maybe okay for SOME people but for the majority of people its gonna be easier with a crane. I've been there balancing engines on a jack and its just not fun, its so much easier to push a handle up and down and the engine to just float out of the car.

I'll do stuff without a crane, but I find it a lot easier to let a tool thats build specifically for the job a lot easier.

If you're after an engine crane, do NOT cheap out on that one from Mantrading (also known as KMS).

http://feedback.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dl...tive&page=1

They're absolute morons, I had to get trading standards involved when they refused to refund me on a faulty unit, whilst attempting to hold me to ransom for the return postage (distance selling regulations forbid this).

These are the typically cheap, hastily built asian imports.

If you're getting one, don't cheap out - you won't regret paying a bit more for a quality lift.

Edited by eshrules

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.