Skip to content

6n 16v vs mk3 1.3

Featured Replies

just wondering how a mk3 1.3spi compares to a 6n 16v in terms of power/performance?

just sold my 16v and wanna get a mk3 cos its so much cheaper to insure.. i know theres the 45bhp difference but also quite a big weight difference. anyone driven/been in both??

Cheers

  • Replies 22
  • Views 1.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

mk3 more fun , 16v more comfert

mk3 more fun , 16v more comfert

I'm sure you will miss the power. a polo gt is an entertaining little car..... but if your used to more go you will notice it

last year i spent most of the time driving my mates M3 evo......this has mate any car i look at buying seem slow, seriously civic vtis,red top corsa etc all feel kinda gutless in comparisson (obviously thats on a grander scale.....but i remeber the same felling when i went from polo gt,to 205 gti and back into a polo gt agin)

just buy my valver n shop round for you are insurance 8-)

  • Author

oh right fair enough. just sold my valver and was getting a bit bored of it tbh and have always wanted a mk3. i dont drive quickly so I'm not bothered about a small power difference, just wanted to make sure i wouldnt regret the step down..

cheers

oh yeah and id be able to buy and insure a mk3 for the price i sold my last car for :)

Edited by richoco

oh right fair enough. just sold my valver and was getting a bit bored of it tbh and have always wanted a mk3. i dont drive quickly so I'm not bothered about a small power difference, just wanted to make sure i wouldnt regret the step down..

cheers

oh yeah and id be able to buy and insure a mk3 for the price i sold my last car for :)

You will notice a big difference in power.

As you said there is the 45bhp difference with is a 45% drop in power, but the weight difference isnt as drastic, only 200kg at most meaning a 20% drop. So the power to weight ratio has dropped alot as a result of this, so your going from a car with close to 100bhp per ton, to a car with less than 69bhp per ton. Thats a 30% decrease. Personally I'd have gone for a GT instead as the power/weight ratio is closer to a valver and they just seems a little bit more fun.

  • Author

thanks for the advice. ill get looking for a gt i think then.

mk3 more fun , 16v more comfert

I'm sure you will miss the power. a polo gt is an entertaining little car..... but if your used to more go you will notice it

last year i spent most of the time driving my mates M3 evo......this has mate any car i look at buying seem slow, seriously civic vtis,red top corsa etc all feel kinda gutless in comparisson (obviously thats on a grander scale.....but i remeber the same felling when i went from polo gt,to 205 gti and back into a polo gt agin)

What is a m3 evo?

Just wait for a while and see what insurance would be on a G40?

mk3 more fun , 16v more comfert

I'm sure you will miss the power. a polo gt is an entertaining little car..... but if your used to more go you will notice it

last year i spent most of the time driving my mates M3 evo......this has mate any car i look at buying seem slow, seriously civic vtis,red top corsa etc all feel kinda gutless in comparisson (obviously thats on a grander scale.....but i remeber the same felling when i went from polo gt,to 205 gti and back into a polo gt agin)

What is a m3 evo?

M3 Evo was the E36 version of the E46 M3 CSL if you know what I mean?

Basically it was an M3 but with a 3.2 litre straight six instead of the 3.0 and they ALL came with venos(BMW's attempt at V-TEC so I'm lead to believe)

They were quoted to be 320bhp, up 40bhp from the 3.0 M3 but I've heard very few actually get close to that figure and also they have a bad reputation for poor reliability.

i thought the evo was just the facelifted e36 m3, as there are no later 3.0 e36 m3s

they make a GT2 e36 m3 which i thought was more akin to the CSL, although the only difference as far as I'm aware is some flocked interior and they only come in green or imola red

Edited by doug

buy the 1.3 spi and have fun, my other car is a Mitsubishi GTO and to have fun i need to keep 1 eye on the boys in blue and other on fuel gauge.

i find on roads you can have more fun and stay legal in a slower basic car, I'm starting to love the little polo.

is an 8v not allot cheaper to insure than the 16v i would go that way myself

just my opinion

  • Author

The plan was to buy a 1.3spi now, have a bit of fun with it until i can afford to buy and insure a g40. 1.3 will cost me 700 to insure rather than 1500 for a g40 haha.

also i've heard the spi engine is quite easy to squeeze more bhp out of.. Will induction kit, stainless exhaust, gt cam etc make a big difference?

There is quite a big difference, when i put my footdown in my valver with my bf behind me in his 1.3 he gets further back in my rear view mirror very quickly lol.

Tyr Peter Best for insurance, they can be quite good.

Edited by a_d

a mildly tuned gt will be almost as quick and a lot more fun than your valver imo, i even traded a valver for my current mk3 (nz on bike carbs) it felt gutless in comparison but you soon get used to it and they are a lot more fun to throw around :lol: in all honesty tho, get a gt :)

1.3 SPI will just be totally garbage in comparison. Maybe think outside of the VAG group to get more bang for your buck?

The plan was to buy a 1.3spi now, have a bit of fun with it until i can afford to buy and insure a g40. 1.3 will cost me 700 to insure rather than 1500 for a g40 haha.

also i've heard the spi engine is quite easy to squeeze more bhp out of.. Will induction kit, stainless exhaust, gt cam etc make a big difference?

they are. i drove a mates car who had a gt cam, full stainless, modded spi injection using golf 1.4 bits and a gt cam. it was as fast as my stock gt, but nothing on my mildly tweaked g40. it was way more fun though thanks to a front subframe kit, which made it really stick in the bends.

the 16v isnt that much slower than the 6n2 gti.

another one of my buds owned a gti and his bro a 16v and they both said there wasnt much between the 2 cars.

I agree with Kam, a 1.3spi will be horrible in comparison to a 6n 16v, different world in terms of performance.

When you say M3 Evo, I generally think of one of these:

1988%20BMW%20M3%20Evolution%20II.jpg

mk1 golf 8-)

  • Author

Ah thanks for all the help. I've decided to look for a gt now :)

can't wait to get one ha, let me know if you're sellin ;)

Had these written down from before, pretty sure they were right last time i checked.

bhp/ton

mk3 1.0 = 58.4

mk3 1.3 spi = 71.4

mk3 GT = 96.1

6n 16v = 97.6

6n2 GTI = 115.3

mk3 G40 = 136.1

I went from a 1.6 8V to a 1.3 GT. The 1.6 had alot more punch lower down, but ran out of steam very quickly, the GT on the otherhand loves to be revved, really gets a shift on after 5k rpm.

I went in a test drive with a friend in an M3 Evo E36 shape, and didn't think it was that quick? Had a tiptronic box that was so laggy!

The 3.0 M3s feel quicker than the 3.2 Evos as they are slightly peakier, whereas the 3.2 has a much broader spread of torque due to larger capacity and also double vanos. An E36 M3 Evo is as quick as an E46 M3, and will eventually pull away from one.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.