Skip to content

Mk3 Polo or Mk3 Golf?

Featured Replies

I'm selling my mk2 polo in favour of something a bit newer, Having owned a Mk3 Golf before I know how satisfying the cars themselves are and I miss it dearly but having got insurance quotes for both cars (1994/1996 models) i've found that the Golf is £200 - £300 more to insure, all-be-it more of a car, every penny me and my girlfriend save makes our lives a penny more comfortable, but which car would you recommend?

Mk3 Golf or Mk3 Polo?

  • Replies 23
  • Views 1.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

id go for a mk4 polo. I've had a couple of mk3 golfs and they suffer from rot quite bad. mk3 polos are alright but for comfort get a mk4 with power steering etc :)

haven't owned a golf before, but i loved my mk3. You dont need power steering!

You dont need power steering!

my mate can back this up 8-) and his mum as she thought it had power steering :-D

You dont need power steering!

my mate can back this up 8-) and his mum as she thought it had power steering :-D

x3 plus a mk3 polo cheap cheap cheap to run

power steering is for pussies!

get the polo cheaper to fix feel quicker to drive as they dont weigh as much as a bus

mk3 golf's are possibly the biggest piece of shit that vw ever made, i've had a 2 mk3 golfs (poverty spec 1.4 and a vr6) both were horrible to drive and even the vr6 felt under powered lol

i've also owned 3 mk3 polo's (only 2 that i got to drive mind) and they are so much better than the golf

oh and mk3 polo's in no way need power steering

Edited by McLOVIN

and they dont need to go super low either do they guy

yes they do :lol:

mmmmm golfs.

what at least polos make your breath smell nice

golf gets you fit and it's fun and there's no real better way to spend a sunny afternoon.

unless your tiger woods, then there are a lot better ways to keep fit and spend a Sunday afternoon.

I can think of far better things to do on a sunny/sunday afternoon :lol:

  • Author

So the polo is the general favourite as a drivers car, but surely the Golf is safer, more spacious and much MUCH better looking? I'm torn...

much better looking compared to what a unimog the mk3 isnt pretty altough saying that the polo isnt going to win very many beauty comps no sorry I'm wrong the polo is a nicer looking car and better to drive and cheaper to own and easier to drive you got me on the spacious thing though unless you get a loon not really safer i dont think either one would do to well in a serious accident but at least the polo has more going for it

unless its a mk3 gti then polo> golf, & if you want a safer polo with airbags and powersteering etc, yeah just get a 6n! & if you want comfort................get a volvo barge :l If you're thinking of lowering a mk3 polo, unless you have armchairs in there, it won't be the comfort you're after......albiet imo they're nicer looking than mk3 golfs (an ugly void in the golf line if you ask me) but that's just me a bias polo & mk2 golf owner! My friend has a mk3 gti and looks aside they're a nice riding car.

had both, polo is fast and fun to drive, very good about town,

if your going on a long trip ad rather the golf, its more comfy and less rattely, i highly recomend a gti interior, there easy to fit and very comfy

a mk3 polo isn't much different to a mk2 polo to be honest, still "feels" like a much older car than a mk3 golf (it's still basically the same mid 70s design underneath). So if it's something that feels more like a modern car you are after then a mk3 polo isn't going to satisfy that itch in my opinion. MK3 Golfs can rust quite badly so but can 6n polos, I think they are similar in that respect, it depends how they have been looked after.

I've got a mk2 polo(near enough same as mk3), a mate of mine has a mk3 polo, and a mate of mine has a mk3 gti golf. Both polos are smalled and are hard drives, the golf is dropped a bit aswell but is a lot more comfotable. The gti didnt feel that fast tho, and I'm comparing it to mine and my mates 1.3 polos which i was surprised when i had a lil buzz in it. looks wise i prefer the polo, mk2 the most. it depends what your after, golfs are bigger and comfier, polos are smaller and can be a harsh drive if dropped but then they look better :)

the golf is so much more of a car, it's built better, it has wishbones, it's comfortable and spacious.

Stop being a fanny, compromise and get a golf mk2.

Having had a Mk2 and a Mk3 Polo, I would say the Mk2 Polo is better to drive. Also have had a couple of Mk2 Golfs, and they are worlds ahead. I've also had an almost basic spec 20 year old E36 3 series and it's so much better to sit in and drive than any VW up to and including the Mk5 Golf/Jetta :lol:

So if you want a modern feeling car that is still quite old and affordable, it's got to be an E36.

+1 on mk2 golf... don't seem to be rotting away like mk3 golfs, and infinately better (both as a place to be, and by virtue of having proper suspension on the front) than mk2 or 3 polo. I know that doesn't suit your brief of a "newer" car, but with all the options, by most standards, they're all "old" cars, mostly with "high" milage, and for my money, body condition and the level of maintainance it's recieved is key...

My other comment is that from experience, if you're keeping any of these cars, you end up pouring money and work into them (I know there are exceptions!) so think hard an reach the decision YOU're happy with, so that you don't end up with a car that you don't really want that owes you too much to get rid.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.