Skip to content

Dissapointed with new Polo

Featured Replies

Just thought I'd collect your thoughts on an issue relating to the new Polo, specifically the base 1.2 model.

I need to replace my current Toyota MR2 Roadster as great car though it is, it just lacks the everyday practicality I now need.

So I fancy the latest Polo and hired one for the day.

(I never feel a quick test drive from a dealers is enough to properly evaluate a car).

Anyway, all in all, knock out.

It feels well put together and surprisingly refined and the icing on the cake was it's handling.

Although low on power, you can tell they've given the little engine plenty of torque low down, meaning it never feels lacking in town and even on the motorway there was decent acceleration from 70mph for quick overtakes where you don't want to be in the fast lane for too long.

I've owned small cars in the past where you need a space the size of an airfield to overtake, and end up having to rev the nuts out of it, by which time fast traffic has caught up and is being held up as you desperately try to summon the speed to get past and out of the way.

Not so with the Polo.

It really is a great performer for it's modest figures.

I took it on a 400 mile round trip to London which is plenty long enough to get a feel from the car.

My journey was mostly motorways, with the odd bit of country lane and built up traffic thrown in, and I kept my speed to between 60-70mph in the NSL's.

It all fell apart for me when it came to measuring fuel consumption.

Over the 400 miles I had the car, I filled up twice and calculated my mpg which averaged out at 41mpg.

Very dissapointing.

I had thought that modern engines had become more economical in recent years, but I beg to differ.

Ah, I hear you say, but that depends on your driving style.

Well yeah, OK, but I have a 10 year old Toyota MR2 Roadster that gives me exactly the same mpg.

:?

Also before that, I owned a Ford Fiesta 1.25 (1996) that regularly returned 45mpg.

I have come to the conclusion that modern small cars have come on leaps and bounds in terms of refinement and handling, but when it comes to fuel efficiency, we're not doing that well in terms of progress.

What a shame.

I was really up for this car, but I was expecting about 50mpg, which is not unreasonable considering my very economic driving style.

Maybe I'm being a bit anal about this, but let's be real.

One of the primary reasons so many people buy small cars is to save money on fuel and this is where this one falls flat on it's face, when it can't beat a 1.8 coupe producing 140bhp.

Could it be the small engine having to contend with the weight.

Would the larger engine be more fuel efficient.

Your thoughts ?

  • Replies 21
  • Views 1.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I have had a few of these over the last couple of months as courtesy cars whilst my gti has been in for a lot of repairs It is one of the most horrible cars I have driven. Wouldn't have one given!

The fuel consumption I noticed too really is poor for such as small car, as for the power you talk about I found none. What sounded to me like I had someone under the engine bay that had a chest infection weasing and coughing lol.

Could it be the small engine having to contend with the weight.

Would the larger engine be more fuel efficient.

Your thoughts ?

Very probable.

Also, new car - is the engine run in? What are the figures from VW on fuel economy?

Maybe you need to learn to drive each car differently to get the best economy?

Maybe you need to learn to drive each car differently to get the best economy?

After 30 years of driving cars and riding bikes of all shapes and sizes, I am well aware of how to get a feel for an engine.

I have owned numerous small cars over the years, and learning to drive, is not an issue.

As I said.

My old Fiesta 1.25 (small car), trounced the Polo.

As regards the first comment.

I totally disagree.

It's all about accepting it for what it is and driving accordingly.

Would the driver of a Lamborghini be justified in saying that the Golf GTI was an asthmatic four wheeled shopping trolley ?

It's all relative.

U asked for peoples thoughts... U got them

tbh you have test driven a polo with not much more power than the originals and twice the weight. not surprised it isnt great on fuel

Its quite simple, as top gear proved with the m3/prius test

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dKTOyiKLARk

With your polo, you're driving it on maybe 75 - 80% of its maximum throttle all the time, whereas if you did the same with your mr2, twice the power, to achieve the same performance/speed you might only need 40-50%, if that.

never buy a small engined car in the name economy, your constantly laboring the engine just to try and get any where, not helped buy the fact even small new car's weigh as much as a small town :lol:

if you want economy get a diesel

never buy a small engined car in the name economy, your constantly laboring the engine just to try and get any where, not helped buy the fact even small new car's weigh as much as a small town :lol:

if you want economy get a diesel

Yeah, lupo TDi ftw !

Diesels are shit,and not economical when driven in the real world. My fiance's '09 207 1.6 diesel uses more fuel than my bike carb'd 1.6 16v Polo,and this is probably because..

A) Its exactly double the weight

B) Its tiny rev range means up to six times more gear changes are required (i once drove my Polo 47miles to work without taking it out of 5th gear).

I used to be a trader,I've owned literally hundreds of cars. And i will never buy another diesel.

Speaking of purchase,she's finally agreed to let it go - i offered her a Ferrari instead,as it'd cost less to own (inc depreciation). She's agreed on an '80s convertible instead,probably a MK1 Golf or 205 CTi but possibly an XR3i if i can find a solid one.

Modern diesel? They're being pushed on us hard by the 'establishment' but even a sheep can see the establishment is taking the piss.

Edit - its a 207 not a 307. Still looks like Stallones mum.

Edited by MikeyMK

I think people think because they've got a little 1.2, it should be great on fuel, but it's not when the car weights a fair lump, that and the Top Gear test!

I can barely get 40 mpg out of my 1.0 6n2, and i feel sorry for that little engine! It has to get it's neck rung every time i want to go anywhere. Once it's up to speed it's fine - so long as don't need to change down, accelerate or outmanoeuvre anyone! 8-)

I guess the polo is getting to the size where a 1.4 is the smallest engine to return any kind of performance/fuel consumption.

i work for vw in service department

the amount of pepole that complain about the mpg of the new is unbelivable, its that bad that we even have pepole bringing them in to investigate poor fuel mpg.

like the new golf gti "its mpg is shit because its a beefed up 1.4" my g40 must do about 20mpg and thats me driving like a muppet.

there improve on build quality and reliabilty but add weight! thats were it comes from.

if the mpg and weight could be sorted then your onto a winner

I think people think because they've got a little 1.2, it should be great on fuel, but it's not when the car weights a fair lump, that and the Top Gear test!

I can barely get 40 mpg out of my 1.0 6n2, and i feel sorry for that little engine! It has to get it's neck rung every time i want to go anywhere. Once it's up to speed it's fine - so long as don't need to change down, accelerate or outmanoeuvre anyone! 8-)

I guess the polo is getting to the size where a 1.4 is the smallest engine to return any kind of performance/fuel consumption.

my girlfriend sold her 1.06n2 becasue the mpg was soooo terible, then bought the 1.4 6n2 wich was better,then i sold her my gti (mapped) wich was even better than that

All my mates at uni had Fiestas and Corsas etc, one had a 3cyl 2005 reg Polo, they were all crap on fuel compared to my 1.3spi Polo I had at the time.

Reading through this thread, I agree that:

1. Weight is a killer for fuel economy

2. People moan too much about fuel economy when they've gone and bought a car that weighs the same as a house

3. If you're that concerned, buy a diesel, which are crap but better on fuel than petrols.

You bound to get crap mpg from a demo car as its more than likely been abused, I return about 40mpg on average from my rocco but if you want mega mpg from cruising, get a diesel :-)

I've been working in Rugby all week (85 mile round commute from my house) and still have half a tank left after doing 330 miles (roughly 21 litres used)

The new Polo 1.2 weighs 1550Kg gross weight, the 6n with a 1.4 16v Engine Weighs 1025kg but will probably return around the same mpg due to the weight.. 525kg is a hell of a lot extra to pull. Its a no brainer..

The new Polo 1.2 weighs 1550Kg gross weight, the 6n with a 1.4 16v Engine Weighs 1025kg but will probably return around the same mpg due to the weight.. 525kg is a hell of a lot extra to pull. Its a no brainer..

Thats alot of weight! I got my 1.0 in the name of economy, This might only be because its stripped and has been serviced its whole life but its so economical! And it currently has no airfilter to speak of and an incomplete exhaust lol. Not to mention i haven't inflated the tyres properly either!

It defo comes down to weight... My 6n must only weight 800kg atm. So its almost half the weight of a new Polo.

Time to start stripping new Polos more often =P

The new Polo 1.2 weighs 1550Kg gross weight, the 6n with a 1.4 16v Engine Weighs 1025kg but will probably return around the same mpg due to the weight.. 525kg is a hell of a lot extra to pull. Its a no brainer..

Ha, who told you that? That's more than a Mk5 R32! I think you'll find even the new Polo GTI is under 1100 kg so there's a very big possibility the basic 1.2 is close to a tonne, if anything lighter than a 6n/6n2 due to more modern construction methods and materials.

Is gross weight not it's fully laden weight?

according to the VW website, new polos range between 1067kgs and 1269kgs unladen weights between the base-spec model and the 180PS TSI with DSG gearbox.

I've never driven a current shape polo but my mum used to have a previous model 1.2 and you had to really push the engine to keep it going at a reasonable speed, especially on the motorway, a bigger engine car would be more economical on the motorway.

http://www.parkers.co.uk/cars/reviews/volk...009.aspx?page=7

Gives the weight of a basic 5dr as 1067 kg, I remember the blurb VW released saying that they would make it lighter than the previous gen which it is just (1100 kg).

My Gti weighs more than it at 1084 kg.

another point is that to make a small, low powered engined, car nice to drive around small roads (i.e. in built up areas) they put a closer ratio gearbox on. Without that it'd be horrendously slow and not nice to drive. This means that on the motorway the engine will be revving higher and using more fuel. The same car with a bigger, more powerful engine will be nice to drive with longer gears which means more economy on motorway. If you are wanting to do a lot of motorway driving then a bigger engined one would be better suited. I'd be interested to see if you find different if you try out a bigger engined one for a while.

tdi is the way forward

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.