Skip to content

Not happy

Featured Replies

I work for a private school and as you can imagine plenty of 4x4 s being driven into the school to drop off the little darlings but unfortunely this afternoon my car became a casaulty in the car park with an X5 being reversed into the front wing despite having sensors on her bumper and camera .

The problem i have is she does not want to claim through insurance because she does not want her no claims hit and give cash instead (Prob thking being a 14 yr old Polo it will only be a few quid to sort ) but after a visit to the body shop tonight we are talking near £400 but have not had it in writing . I dont wish to scrap it as have low milage and good body work but i can see this is going to cause a problem when she gets hit with the bill :cry:

Ill try and get some photos up when i get to the body shop tomorrow (fingers crossed )

  • Replies 44
  • Views 4.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

dont worry at all you aint done a thing wrong, smile at her and say pay the bill, or go through insurance, it is your choice :D

£400 for a front wing.... man just go scrappy and find one the same colour and get a receipt and ask her for cash done. Jesh!

her husband isn't going to be happy

Private school? She can afford £400 then.

my mum had a similar thing happen to her; wingmirror was knocked off and the other person assumed it would cost 40 odd quid so said he'd pay cash but turned out to be more like £200 as it was a new car. still paid up, didnt seem bothered at all

Cant you just say that the place were you want to do it is £400, they can phone and confirm (hand over the number) or they can try and find somewhere that your happy with.

Edited by hb1

  • Author

She put her hands up to it after some finger pointing by some parents but thought it would only be the front headlight and indicator but after closer inspection we are talking front grill and straighten front wing and respray on bumper ( maybe i should milk it and get some touch ups done while there LOL )but she will want to see the break down of the bill so probably wont get away with it .

Must admit though I'm glad it was the VW instead of the Fiat as that would of def been a write off :)

someone knocked in to my polo. Dented the wing and broke the indicator. The insurance wanted to right it off but i managed to convince them to fit a new wing, paint it and i would do the rest.

Get a receipt wrote up, go scrappy for the bits you need. call it £300 compensation for the ballache of having to go through the effort of fixing your car.

^thats talking sense polos are a relativly easy fix

  • Author

Ill see when i give her the bill as dont fancy trying to get a colour match and being a perfectionist i would want it done properly and as i see it i didnt cause the accident so why put up with second best if she can afford to send her boy to private school

Just claim it through insurance no matter how big her boobs are.

Edited by daveb142

Fair enough, if you want it absolutely spot on. good luck with it!

yeah. women driving their kids to school are getting worse i swear, one pulled out on me when i was on my scooter, i went slap bang into the side of her, she was then crying like 'oh my god i could have killed you, my sons are your age' etc etc, all apologetic, then she was going to pay for my scooter as i only dented her door, until she then said it would cost £2000 to repair.. it was a 51 plate discovery!! and somehow she ended up claiming over £9000?!! how does that work, (i know that cause i almost got my car insurance cancelled over it, they said i didnt declare everything, but i had no idea she did this :|)

oh and then today at a busy junction, a woman couldnt be bothered to wait to be let out so she pulled out, drove down the opposite side of the road, cut me up and pushed me up the curb, then waved her hands at me because I stopped??

sorry, i had to rant somewhere and being this a thread about parents going to/from school, it seemed the right place lol

i would just tell her how much it is going to be or tell her its going through the insurance. her choice. I'm sure she can fork out the £400 tho if she can pay school fees.

4x4 drivers annoy me, i saw one reverse into a parked car,he got out, looked at it and drove off!! i took his plate and found the guy who owned the now dented car (only in a little local shop) and happily passed on the number plate, bloody 4x4 man thinking he can get away with it!

Blag her, say it messed up the slam panel and its gunna cost near to £800. Posh people fucking wind me up, hope it gets sorted soon mate!

Take it to some good bodyshops. Get some quotes and tell her she can either cough it up herself or go through insurance. End of the day shes crashed into your car and doesn't want to lose her no claims. Its her fault and she will have to decide if she wants to spend her own money or the insurance companies. I also hope you got the names and numbers of the witnesses cause if she does go through insurance having random people who will point in the finger at her will always help.

Your other option is if your pretty handy you can get the quotes and do a cash on lui repair. Which is where the insurance company pays you the money quoted by the bodyshops and you can go spend it on the car yourself. Its only really worth doing it that way if your hand with cars. Other wise you end up just spending it all at the bodyshop anyway. Plus if they encounter any other problems you'd have to pay for that out of your own pocket. Where as if it was through insurance the insurance company would front it.

There is a flip side to this coin though, friend of mine was parked for about 3 hours while out shopping. Some young mother driver was pulling out of the parking spot opposite and dented the back of his car by accident. She waited about 40mins for him to come back to apologise and give him her insurance details. She nearly missed him as she was sat in her car and didn't notice him get into his and start to drive off.

You could tell the damage looked like it would be a new bumper job but, my kind hearted mate decided that since she waited in the car with baby for so long he just said don't worry about it. She was all worried thinking if she had drove off and only left a note it might blow away and the police would come after her. (lol)

Dude,

I would tell your insurance company pronto, explain the situation that the woman wants to pay cash and for them not to follow it up at the moment. That way at least you have started a record going. Like wise for witnesses, get all their details just in case and start to build a file up.

If this gets nasty, which is could easily, she might tell you to piss off if you come to her with a £400 bill. At least then you will have all the provisions in order to go through insurance.

Likewise, you don't have to get nasty with her. Just go to a few body shops (ones you trust), I would get a least 3 quotes showing similar prices, most garages will happily pen it down on paper for you. Then show her them so she knows your not taking the piss. if she still disagrees with the price just give her the ultimatum; cash or insurance. it's her call. BUT don't wait around for her.

£400 for a front wing.... man just go scrappy and find one the same colour and get a receipt and ask her for cash done. Jesh!

He said he had a car with good bodywork before.

Why should it suffer now just because some woman can't drive her husbands X5?

A similar thing happend to me a couple years ago in my valver.

I was reversed into in a McDonalds car park by a bloke in an 08 plate Zafira. He saw I was driving 'just' a T reg Polo and offered me cash on the spot for the damage.

I told him no, I had a perfect car before you hit it, I deserve a perfect car once its repaired not just a cheap dent pull out job.

Anyway the next day I call him up with a quote of £1200 to fix the car and his answer was just as I expected "Oh the cars not worth that much is it?" I told him I don't care what the repair costs or how much my car is worth, I just want the job done. So he ended up getting his insurance involved as it was slightly more than the £200 he could afford on the spot.

So to the OP, just stick to your guns, tell your insurance to expect a phone call from her insurance and get your car valued from a bodyshop you know and trust. Don't worry about what the woman in the X5 thinks, its her fault she can't drive her useless car.

If it wasnt your fault, you shouldnt be made to suffer or pay for anything, claim through the insurance! You know it makes sense ;)

she probably does think it'll only cost a few bob to fix because it's an "old" car but what she fails to realise is that bodyshop labour rates are the same whether your car is 14 years or 14 minutes old! Just tell her that if she doesn't like the amount and then say she is free to either pay it herself or go through insurance. Like DK said, you've done nothing wrong so you shouldn't be worrying about this too much.

Just sting her with the nice £400 bill :thumbsup::badgrin:

Make sure you update us on the details though, this will make a very good thread!

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.