Skip to content

Selling up and moving on...

Featured Replies

Well, my 1996 polo saloon is up for sale and I have just bought a 2003 mondeo tdci 130 ghia x.

I have to say that my experience with VW's hasn't exactly been pain free, and I do wonder what they were thinking sometimes in relation to most of the petrol engines they fit, they all seem to be very underpowered excluding the GTi's etc (and even they feel like they should be faster).

Does anybody else ever feel like getting something like a newer diesel? Or do you lot love your polos too much?

I will miss it i'm sure (i did when i sold my mk3 for a golf), but for someone reason I can't help but feel that its for the best as I plan to be enjoying my 130bhp along with the constant 50+mpg for a long time yet :ninja: :-D

  • Replies 33
  • Views 3.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I drive a lot of that sort of thing for work, and much as it pains me to say it, diesels are the way forward in modern cars, mainly cause they're that bloody heavy :badgrin:

Its the dilema facing most polo owners i'm sure. Most of the older polos are not ideal for daily commutes, condition of roads, bad winters etc in my opinion. I remember taking my g40 in for work and borrowing a curtesy car and marvelling at how it had brakes that worked!! I love the mk3 gt and g40 but could never imagine using one as a daily again. Much prefer the mod cons of climate control, abs and pwer steering etc + 45mpg from a tdi. With petrol prices as they are and insurance these cheap 1.4 tdis are the way forward with the g40 for the weekend.

to be fair a lot has happend betwean 1996 and 2003..

for a start back in 1996 diesels where still tractor engines nothing like diesel engines today..

ye i will agree with you that there engines are slow but its not all about power.. my 1.4 8v has 173k on it and i can still get 50mpg out it and to be fair there is not meny cars these days thay will realy get you that (inless its a diesel)

or eaven get you over 100k. engies now a days are to soft

Edited by 13kpologt

The car i want to get next will be a diesel. I want the polo 6R 1.2 bluemotion... For nothing other than it's mpg! Even though it's only 1.2 it is still going to be more pokey than my current one soooo no brainer :p

you won't go far wrong with your new motor, they are good cars albit very dull. i had my mates focus tdci for a bit and after a couple of days the novalty of good mpg had warn off and i couldn't wait to get back in to my golf

as for vw putting under powered petrol engines in their car's, you obviously haven't driven many ford :lol:

I love my polo and i am a mechanic and personaly would stay well clear of the new diesel's as they have D.P.F filter's which when they go wrong cost a fortune and in my experience i have seen alot of them! I may be biased when i say this but the older car's are easier to fix and cheaper to keep on the road and easier for people who are not too sure what they are doing to keep them going! And i do 60 mile's a day in my mk3 polo and has been all the way up to scotland and all the way down to cornwall with no problem's!

have a citroen diesel as a back up car to my daily mk3 loon which will stay my daily until it can no longer be fixed which will be a long time yet

I drive a lot of that sort of thing for work, and much as it pains me to say it, diesels are the way forward in modern cars, mainly cause they're that bloody heavy :badgrin:

Yeah. Hate to say it, but when it comes to a big heavy modern car, diesels do make sense. The Caddy's engine at work is pretty nice.

i went from 3 diesels Focus TDCi, Golf GT TDi, A3 SLine DSG TDi toooooooo, a Leon Cupra, it likes to drink a bit more but is far more fun than any of the diesels i've owned. For short trips you cannot beat a small petrol car for lots of motorways then at a push diesel although i'm not sure i would ever go back to derv power. Modern diesel have got too complicated and break all too easy. Thats the reason i've got the Polo, cheap to run as a daily hack :)

I wouldn't have my diesel any other way, unless it was a petrol V8.

how many miles has said mondingle done?

I've heard of expensive problems at around 80/90k on the diesel engines

I like driving diesels, and some manufacturers have developed some incredible levels of refinement - try any 6 cyl BMW oil burner! I've just got myself a golf IV with a PD engine and it is very very good, and the big torque rush in any gear is utterly addictive, but they do require a different driving style, and certainly favour the smoother driver! I suspect it'll be a few more weeks before i settle into a consistent style in this car.

On another note, i test drove a few other diesel 2ish litre cars and i have to say, no-one builds dervs like ze germans! I drove a mazda 6 diesel and it was honestly the most boring and un-stimulating car i've ever been in!

i love my polo too much :-D

but if i were to buy a desial i cetainly would not be a ford ;)

VAG all the way :-p

well i went to a modern diesel funny enought a mondeo tdci 130 and regreted it as these cars are common on fuel injectors and

common rail fuel pump.

£1000 in repairs and sold it a week ago and went back to the same model golf tdi i had before mondeo.

The problem with modern diesels is the power band is like 1500 revs long - you may have 130bhp but its only in one spot so its pretty useless.

Using the 207 for my 40-odd mile commute is hard work,truck drivers on B-roads change gear less often.. Use the Polo or 306 2.0 16v cab and i can do most of the journey in 5th gear (all A and B roads,no motorways).

As a result,the petrol's cost isn't a factor - the 1.6 16v MK2 Polo is better on fuel for my commute than the 207 1.6 diesel! Diesels are crap.

I love my polo and i am a mechanic and personaly would stay well clear of the new diesel's as they have D.P.F filter's which when they go wrong cost a fortune and in my experience i have seen alot of them! I may be biased when i say this but the older car's are easier to fix and cheaper to keep on the road and easier for people who are not too sure what they are doing to keep them going! And i do 60 mile's a day in my mk3 polo and has been all the way up to scotland and all the way down to cornwall with no problem's!

I go along with that my missus has a new Corsa and being 15 yrs younger you would of expected more reliable but since ownership its been in and out the dealership with various probs ranging from electrical demons and mechanics ,you are right with old motors at least you can do most things on yr average driveway but looking under hers its a mass of plastic and everythg needed to be hooked up on a diagnostic machine to tell you where the problems lie give me an old car any day as she is starting to wish she did . :cry:

Modern diesels are so over rated its getting really annoying now.

They demand more money than the equivilent petrol car in terms of initial buying price, fuel cost and tax. So taking that into account you are already many £ out of pocket than the bloke next door who has bought a petrol car.

Then we get on to why you bought a diesel, the supposed economy. Yes they are all advertised to get at least 50MPG, but has anyone actually worked out what their actual economy figure is? I'll bet its less than 50MPG. My Dad's 320d for example was advertised at returning 60+MPG on a combined cycle. For as long as he has had it now, even on a long motorway run the most it's done is 52MPG...I've got more out of a valver!

The reason for this poor economy is simple, diesel cars are useless in anything that resembles traffic. Because you will be speeding up and slowing down constantly, meaning you will be on the boost everytime you accelerate because the turbo kicks in at what like 5rpm or something? Even just a tiny bit of traffic everyday will hurt your economy.

So in my eyes unless you live at one end of a motorway and work at the other with no city/traffic driving then buy a petrol and learn how to drive it. Modern petrol engined cars can still achieve the economy figures of diesels and as I said above, will be cheaper to buy, fuel and tax.

I've got 2 VAG Derv's - Touran PD105 & a Skoda Fabia VRS. The fabia has had quite a bit of bits done to it - remap, exhaust filter etc. it maybe around the 170-180bhp mark & have around 340lb/ft or tourque. The horizon cames at you quickly if you want it to - and mid-range overtakes are very fast. But it has no soul! My old G40 had less power, less torque and was loads smaller - but driving that was an experience every time you turned the key (if it started or didnt break) The G40 use to get an easy 33mpg - the Fabia & the Touran both get around 40-55mpg depending on the drive. Diesel hate stop start motoring - town driving kills MPG levels. If you live in a town and only take the car out shopping etc - then buy a petrol.

To put another spin on things i still like how petrol engine smell and sound - a diesel has nothing on an old petrol motor

]As well as my Polo I have a Bora 1.9 TDI and I love it. The fuel economy's great and the performance isn't bad either with potential for lots more. I would put that engine in my Polo at the drop of a hat if I could!

Edit: And the year that my Bora is means that it's lower tax than all the others! And because it's a Bora it's cheaper than buying a Golf - so all in all, not expensive to run really.

Edited by Spade

Modern diesels are so over rated its getting really annoying now.

They demand more money than the equivilent petrol car in terms of initial buying price, fuel cost and tax. So taking that into account you are already many £ out of pocket than the bloke next door who has bought a petrol car.

Then we get on to why you bought a diesel, the supposed economy. Yes they are all advertised to get at least 50MPG, but has anyone actually worked out what their actual economy figure is? I'll bet its less than 50MPG. My Dad's 320d for example was advertised at returning 60+MPG on a combined cycle. For as long as he has had it now, even on a long motorway run the most it's done is 52MPG...I've got more out of a valver!

The reason for this poor economy is simple, diesel cars are useless in anything that resembles traffic. Because you will be speeding up and slowing down constantly, meaning you will be on the boost everytime you accelerate because the turbo kicks in at what like 5rpm or something? Even just a tiny bit of traffic everyday will hurt your economy.

So in my eyes unless you live at one end of a motorway and work at the other with no city/traffic driving then buy a petrol and learn how to drive it. Modern petrol engined cars can still achieve the economy figures of diesels and as I said above, will be cheaper to buy, fuel and tax.

Not really sure how you figured that Diesel cars are more expensive to tax?

A lot of diesels are in the lowest band. Obviously, like any other engine, the more emissions the more tax :/

And is your Dads 320 new? Because Diesel engines never return great economy until they've bedded in after several thousand miles

I'm by no means biased, i always stand by the idea of a diesel car being far better than the actual reality of them.

However, my Dads 525D was very nice to drive.

i sold my polo 2 weeks ago and totally miss it! it was only a coupe 1ltr but still the best car iv had so much fun! iv just bought a 1990 ford sierra sapphy so hope she guna be up there with the polo, sadly i dont think it will polo all they way miss u baby :crybaby: ye i know soppy bastard aint i

I'd rather have a sapphire than a 1 liter polo any day, I had one back in my youth and they are shot loads of fun! Look nice with some tidy wheels and a healthy drop make a massive difference 8-)

ye wet roundabouts are fun, i bought it today tidy as fook only 1.6 version but i saw it and thought yep thats mine! no rust or rot anywhere, on the look for some nice wheels for it but duno what i want yet lol!

You`ve bought a Ford Mondeo, that`s not cool in many ways. I take it your about 40 with a wife and kids

VW do lots of diesel engine cars, I`ll always own a VW

Edited by Dakota

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.