Skip to content

vw polo mk2 CRASH TEST

Featured Replies

just found this on you tube

I'm gettin a helmet :shock:

  • Replies 34
  • Views 5.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

shit son! might aswell write a will before i drive the polo anymore.... haha

time to bubble wrap the steering wheel i think..

:o wow that sucks. Atleast we can count on 1 thing:

6n beats Golf :lol:

think you may need a new face after a crash in a mk2!

Well I'm glad i dont have a mk2 anymore.

And to be doubly fair, 90km per hour (56mph) is quite a bit faster than the usual Euro NCAP crash tests. That's a motorway collision or someone straying onto your side of the road.

If you compare it to the Rover 100, tested at 40mph, it's not awful. E36 BMW is pretty scary too!

Lol yeah just watched the rover 100 test, its pretty horrific hahah.

But if you think about it, 60mph crash is the equivalent of a head on collision on a 30mph road. And not a lot of people stick to 30mph any way, if you was both doing say about 35mph then that would be a combined speed of 70mph! So basically the same as doing 70mph into a stationary object lol.

But it's also worth remembering that most drivers stand on the brakes before an impact so unless both fall asleep and drive headlong into one another then 56mph is unlikely.

Hence Euro NCAP being at 40.

Don't get me wrong I'm not saying Polos are the pinnacle of road safety but compared to other cars they aren't bad. My Dad had a serious accident involving a third party in a stolen Cavalier. He was drivng our old Mk2 breadie. The Polo was a state, but my Dad walked away with whiplash.

Considering the Polo chassis design dates back to the 70s, and even the Mk2/2F shell was born in the early 80s they're not awful. Wouldn't be my first choice if I had to have an accident though.

Fair point Alex, its still quite surprising how bad some modern cars are.

I do sometimes feel that a mk2 polo would be better than some new car anyway because of the amount of plastic on newer cars lol, e.g. if a mk2 polo T-boned a 6n2 or somehting, i wouldn't mind betting that the 6n2 would come out worse than the mk2 :lol:

The thing they concentrate most on now is the interior of the car, things like knee impact and shit like that, I remeber seeing a stacked vectra on a 55 plate, the brake pedal had repositioned itself in the dash at the expense of the drivers foot and ankle :paranoid:

If I'm honest i dont think about it, i know its gonna hurt if i crash my mk3 - but if i lived my life shitting myself incase it does id never drive it, or for that matter never leave the house. What if i get run over? thats gonna hurt just as much :lol:

Yeah you should see the equivalent Fiesta/Nova/Panda/Metro, the Polo was relatively good in its day for what it was.

Those days were about keeping the cars light,due to oil supply issues. Not just the 70s but the 60s too,so its how cars evolved. Weight became less of an issue in the 80s,so by the early 90s safety became an available demand.

These days,cars are generally a massive 50-80% heavier,some over double the weight,packed with all the safety technology learnt since. This afforded by far more efficient engines which can pull the extra weight without using more fuel.

I question if such safe cars,or safe feeling,create arrogant driving through a false sense of security. You cant make cars foolproof,so i value the vulnerability i feel in my MK2, helps me to stay cautious. And i think the more efficient engines of today should be put into lighter cars. But then oil sales will drop,and we cant have that..

compare:

light years ahead. good to see.

But if you think about it, 60mph crash is the equivalent of a head on collision on a 30mph road. And not a lot of people stick to 30mph any way, if you was both doing say about 35mph then that would be a combined speed of 70mph! So basically the same as doing 70mph into a stationary object lol.

:lol: sorry to disprove you, but Mythbusters proved otherwise ;)

http://mythbustersresults.com/mythssion-control

In their small scale tests, the Mythbusters compressed clay at 1x and 2x speeds. Their results showed that two objects hitting each other at 1x speed will cause 1x damage. In their full scale tests, the Mythbusters crashed two cars into a wall at 50 and 100 mph as references. They then had two cars going at 50 mph collide into each other. After surveying the results, it was clear that the two cars suffered damage identical to the car that crashed into the wall at 50 mph. The Mythbusters explained that was possible through Newton’s third law of motion. Although the total force was doubled by having two cars, that force also had to be divided between both cars during the crash.

Will have to watch the rover one :)

compare:

light years ahead. good to see.

They should've cable tied the hubcaps on...

didn't completely read the previous posts so sorry if somebody has said it, but head on collisions don't actually give the combined speed/forces that everyone thinks they do, if two cars hit at 30mph each they both get affected the same as a single car in a 30mph crash. they tested it on mythbusters too

(the start bit is individual cars to show you different speed crashes, the head on collision bit is a couple minutes later)

Edit: just seen a post above :x

Edited by owengd97b

:lol: sorry owen :) just love Mythbusters and this one has stuck with me :D glad you could find a video though, I couldn't

The rover one was horrid, never driving one of those! Love how quickly the beemer stops :D

If you do crash, make sure you argue with a driving coffin though! old style Saxo is horrendous!

Edited by NEPolo

The polo was one of the safest cars at the time as it was one of the first chassis designrd with crumple zones other than the drivers knees believe it or not

Dam That makes you think :tear:

Sorry to anyone with one but in a camper, your fucked big time.

Well everyone is apprently.

Another view of it, easy way to make a trailer i guess.

That T3 test is nasty, looks like its going straight through the wall!

Peugeot 205 is pretty bad

Matt.

That 205 is crashing into a tree though, not a deformable offset. Even modern cars into a tree are going to hurt.

If you want to see a truly terrifying video, check this out: (Sierra vs tree)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AbQinWMg_7M

Stick with it. They test it at 50, 70 and 90km/h. The build up to 90km/h and the slow-mo replay of that test is worth the wait, trust me. I was like "fuck, didn't expect that..."

I question if such safe cars,or safe feeling,create arrogant driving through a false sense of security. You cant make cars foolproof,so i value the vulnerability i feel in my MK2, helps me to stay cautious. And i think the more efficient engines of today should be put into lighter cars. But then oil sales will drop,and we cant have that..

Quoted for truth.

I think it's ironic when you see urban Mums in their SUV tanks, bought to protect their kids, then they're doing retarded speeds down the road because they think they've got the safety thing checked and they'll be fine.

It's not enough to assume you've got a five star car, and therefore you'll be fine in an accident. Side impact is still an issue, but getting better, and there are so many variables to consider. Have a crash at motorway speeds, in ANYTHING, and you'll not come off well. Regardless of how well you wrap yourself in a UHSS steel passenger shell with a billion airbags, the force exerted on a human body as it comes to a stop from over 70mph can cause all sorts of internal injuries.

Difference is, in a 'safer' new car you'll have a less mashed up corpse.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.