Skip to content

Can I complain to VW UK about this?

Featured Replies

Hello all, just bought a Polo 9n3 GTI. It's 2 weeks out of warranty (it's an 08 with a manufacturing date of 14/03/08). Anyway it needed a service and there was a metallic clicking noise from the drivers side rear suspension top mount.

I wanted to keep the main dealer stamps up to date so rang for a quote. The service was a bit cheeky (£129 for a minor + £109 for brake and AC fluid change - both due). I was told the suspension noise would incur a £75 per hour investigation charge.

After the first hour of investigation they thought they had found the cause but the noise was still there. They then fed the info into a diagnostic tool they have which suggested a known concern of split top mounts. This was another hours labour.

You have to replace the top mounts on both sides. So that's £40 in parts and, yep, another hours labour.

So a minor service, fluid change and a fixed known concern with split top mounts, total bill £504.

I know the car is just out of warranty but is it worth complaining to VW UK about the cost (£266) to fix a known concern that should have been more like £100?

Cheers,

Isaac

  • 3 weeks later...
  • Replies 28
  • Views 4.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Although you have paid an insane amount of money i can not see this website helping you on this one. You should have looked yourself had someone push the back of your car down while you look... rear suspension aint too complex. But the whole diagnostic thing in vw is a little over the top. You could have bought and fitted new suspension for less than £200 the price of the diagnostics. Theres only 3 bolts holding your rear damper struts on.

If its a recall it shouldnt matter because it should've been done before now. If it is a recall kick up a fuss, worse that'll happen is you'll be told no. But keep trying.

£129 for a minor service and £109 for brake and AC seams fair from a main dealer.

£40 plus £75 labour seems fair..

2 hours for diagnosing a known issue i.e. the split top mount. I'd tell them where to go. Firstly they are the dealer and therefore should be the best.. Secondly why did they not initially check the known issues first? It doesn't take 2 hours for a professional to diagnose a top mount. That's obscene.

There is no harm in asking or writing a letter i say, i wouldn't mind writing a letter myself about the standard of service i have recieved from VW with my 9N3 GTI when i had warranty that was almost expired! they acted as if it was a big chor to fix my car and as if they couldn't have cared less because they were not making money! i had a huge argument with someone in the middle of the garage because i thought they treat me like a dick i'll do the same and i demanded i see a certain employee's certificate of compitancy to work on my car because i seen him doing something and i knew fine well he was a salesman and not qualified to, needless to say i won that argument and received all new brake discs to shut me up :) but ever since when i got back they see me and walk the other way!

Hope i didn't go off topic haha

That's the price you pay for keeping up the vw service stamps unfortunately. They probably already had a good idea what the problem was, but fixing it straight away would of lost them £166 in lost business, think I'm being cynical? Why didn't they use this diagnostics tool straight away?

I can't see vw giving a toss about this tbh, its probably company policy to do this sort of thing, Alfterall they did exactly as you asked and investigated the problem, I take it there was no grantee given on how long it would take to find the problem? sounds like a typical garage scam to me.

If it takes them 2 hours to not be able to spot a top mount's defective, they really, really shouldn't be mending cars for a living.

Can i just say here that a lot of comments seem to be putting the blame on the tech's. I work as an apprentis for mazda and the guys in the workshop are great and sales/reception are good too, but dont forget we dont deal with customers so alot of problems can quite easily be the paper pushers, not always incomptent workers. (But not saying everyone is a workshop is brilliant cz weve had some right dicks :L)

People in car sales garages like Vw or any other company thats floating on the stock market dont do proper car mechanics, if you have noticed they are now technicians.. So they do diagnostics and then replace like for like.

And how much extra is your car worth after 3 years with a FVWSH over one that does not have a full VW service history? I bet its peanuts!

I never got to a dealers i do all my own work and i can guarantee who ever gets my car will get a bargain, mechanically sound well looked after and fully maintained! Thats something that you dont get even with a full VW service history.

P.S. If anyone is so bothered about the stamps get a rubber stamp made up haha

Custom Rubber Stamps

BOOM! For £40 you too could replicate a VW stamp and do your own servicing..... (who is to know its all fake) who checks?

I aint saying do this but its certainly a cheaper option?

When you buy a car do you check with a dealer to make sure that all servicing is legit?

If it takes them 2 hours to not be able to spot a top mount's defective, they really, really shouldn't be mending cars for a living.

I bet even i wouldnt miss that. Its not as though they weren't given a huuuge hint to begin with. rear clicking noise at the back? We'll start at the front then :lol:

I wont even use my local VW as i think they're all jokers!

Can i just say here that a lot of comments seem to be putting the blame on the tech's. I work as an apprentis for mazda and the guys in the workshop are great and sales/reception are good too, but dont forget we dont deal with customers so alot of problems can quite easily be the paper pushers, not always incomptent workers. (But not saying everyone is a workshop is brilliant cz weve had some right dicks :L)

+1 not always the techy`s fault.

tbf you got nothing to lose, and id make a big thing of asking them what this diagnostic tool is and why it wasnt used first.

Probably looked on Club Polo.

The dealers have a list of known faults and how much VW will contribute to fixing them. They cover things like dodgy coil packs on 20V turbo engines. (I know this as I read the letter on the sales guys desk when I was waiting in reception once). These apply regardless of the warranty but they don't volunteer to pay. It's worth complaining to VW - say that you were told its a known fault (i.e. part is unfit for purpose) and ask for a contribution to the cost as the car is barely out of warranty and you consider what you were charged to be excessive anyway. You may need to be persistent as they will try to fob you off. If the mileage on the car isn't particularly high that will count in your favour.

Another thing; your warranty should be 3 years from date of registration (which may be what you meant), not date of manufacture.

Gearbox went on my mums auto Astra caused by leaky radiator (which was a recalled part) was gonna cost £2800 to fix. At first Vauxhall said they wouldnt pay anything. Once we CC'd watchdog into the emails they soon agreed to pay 90% of the bill so that may help :)

Gearbox went on my mums auto Astra caused by leaky radiator (which was a recalled part) was gonna cost £2800 to fix. At first Vauxhall said they wouldnt pay anything. Once we CC'd watchdog into the emails they soon agreed to pay 90% of the bill so that may help :)

Genuis 8-)

The dealers have a list of known faults and how much VW will contribute to fixing them. They cover things like dodgy coil packs on 20V turbo engines. (I know this as I read the letter on the sales guys desk when I was waiting in reception once). These apply regardless of the warranty but they don't volunteer to pay. It's worth complaining to VW - say that you were told its a known fault (i.e. part is unfit for purpose) and ask for a contribution to the cost as the car is barely out of warranty and you consider what you were charged to be excessive anyway. You may need to be persistent as they will try to fob you off. If the mileage on the car isn't particularly high that will count in your favour.

Another thing; your warranty should be 3 years from date of registration (which may be what you meant), not date of manufacture.

Theres actually a recall on the coil packs now (the push fit one fitted to mk4`s an mk5`s) would be beast to check with vw the exact specs tho, and what you are referring to is good will, tends to come in to play if the cars out of warranty and when the customer has stayed loyal to the brand.

  • 4 weeks later...

I complained to VW about an issue with my passat (diesel injectors failed). It was out of warranty but I got a 70% contribution to the cost.

You can call them up - ask your dealer for 'VW customer services' phone number and log a complaint. Explain how disapointed you are and that you feel you paid too much compared to a non VW garage and see what happens.

I complained to VW about an issue with my passat (diesel injectors failed). It was out of warranty but I got a 70% contribution to the cost.

You can call them up - ask your dealer for 'VW customer services' phone number and log a complaint. Explain how disapointed you are and that you feel you paid too much compared to a non VW garage and see what happens.

2.0 Tdi by any chance, the injectors are not much short of £500 each, and then they reccomend the loom is replaced as well. Could have been quite costly, if you didn`t get the good will, but to the OP you have got nothing to lose from logging a complaint and you may even gain something so its definetly worth a shout.

I complained to VW about an issue with my passat (diesel injectors failed). It was out of warranty but I got a 70% contribution to the cost.

You can call them up - ask your dealer for 'VW customer services' phone number and log a complaint. Explain how disapointed you are and that you feel you paid too much compared to a non VW garage and see what happens.

2.0 Tdi by any chance, the injectors are not much short of £500 each, and then they reccomend the loom is replaced as well. Could have been quite costly, if you didn`t get the good will, but to the OP you have got nothing to lose from logging a complaint and you may even gain something so its definetly worth a shout.

You knows it. 2 separate events each time 2 injectors failed. The first time they replaced my loom. Spanked me about £1000 all in - and that's after the 70% goodwill contribution from VW

VW 2.0 tdi's between 2005 & 2008 are a time bomb - I'd advise anybody to leave well aloan. Interestingly Audi's seem to be OK!

I complained to VW about an issue with my passat (diesel injectors failed). It was out of warranty but I got a 70% contribution to the cost.

You can call them up - ask your dealer for 'VW customer services' phone number and log a complaint. Explain how disapointed you are and that you feel you paid too much compared to a non VW garage and see what happens.

2.0 Tdi by any chance, the injectors are not much short of £500 each, and then they reccomend the loom is replaced as well. Could have been quite costly, if you didn`t get the good will, but to the OP you have got nothing to lose from logging a complaint and you may even gain something so its definetly worth a shout.

You knows it. 2 separate events each time 2 injectors failed. The first time they replaced my loom. Spanked me about £1000 all in - and that's after the 70% goodwill contribution from VW

VW 2.0 tdi's between 2005 & 2008 are a time bomb - I'd advise anybody to leave well aloan. Interestingly Audi's seem to be OK!

I work at vw, and as soon as you see one pull up on a tow truck you know exactly what it needs :lol: its a shame because they are a really nice car otherwise, and had no experience with audi`s, VW supposedly being the inferior version an all haha.

Do you recon they will do a recall on the Siemens PD injectors like they have done on the coil packs for the 1.8T?

buy a 20 year old polo shit box, whatevers broken i bet it wont cost more than a tenner to fix :lol:

I wouldnt like to say RAW, anythings possible haha

And that man above talks sense, its also quite nice to get in my shitter an not feel like I'm at work haha.

  • 2 months later...

Other than servicing, if I ever have a problem i do loads of Internet searches first for the same issue. With modern cars its generally the same weak point from model to model.

then I get a trusted local garage to do the fix - and maintain just servicing at the main dealer who want best part of £100 for looking at the car.

However, the points above are very poignant - taking 2 hours to spot a common fault is ridiculous. I would complain and not take any crap about their procedures.

Servicing costs were cheap though.

Did anything ever come of this I'm still intrigued to see what this diagnostic tool is.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.