Skip to content

Anyone else noticed this?

Featured Replies

This is one thing that really irritates me. So many great cars are going to waste of late :-( . Especially Mk3 polos. I'm not going to point fingers and name names but why break decent, solid and low mileage cars?? I know it helps keep others on the road, but often the cars that get broken are far nicer than the cars their parts are bought for. Wheres the logic in that :? ??? Its not that they are worth heaps more in bits either, and the time it takes to break them up easily outweighs the possible extra cash. A solid low mileage car is always going to be better than one made up from bits of them, end of. So people, think before you break, and maybe try and sell the car first, after all, its the easy, pain free option. Anyone agree?

  • Replies 22
  • Views 1.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

yup. sickens me to see so many mk2 golf's, corrado's etc being broken. basically there are 2 causes.

1 - people are too tight to fix a car these days (even though they will then buy a newer car that will shed twice as much in value than any repair would have cost)

2 - people trying to sell for too much spit their dummies out when their car wont sell.

2 - people trying to sell for too much spit their dummies out when their car wont sell.

:nod: :nod: :nod:

The price of a 1l 90-94 mk3 polo is now at around £1000. Not just here but elsewhere too. WTF?

Some of them are right sheds too, a few look like new but it is still a 1l 20 year old car.

£1000 would get me a pretty nice Saab 9k 2.3T, Speed, comfort, luxury, the chance of walking away from a crash with an ELK :lol: and money left over for a few select upgrades.

Edited by Cymro

the problem is that all the cars are built to a persons like rather than necessarily to everyones taste.

I'm trying to sell my mk4 at the minute but the problem is that though its a totally scene car, people want to put the work in themselves

sad but true they are often worth more in bits than as one piece.

agree their is alot of mutten dressed as lamb for sale but thats just the age of them - but they are easy to see through 90% of the time! hence the 2 months later bump bump on the posts and the gradual price reduction.

Once you have replaced the brakes , suspension and all the other bits they tend to need at this age etc its usually as much as the car so when folk want to sell they have to remember its done out of the love of the polo not to make money.

have to admit if a polos got a mint rust free shell (real rust free not the the outside looks shiny only the sils are hanging off it) then i think its worth the half reasonable money whether its a fox or a G40. lets face it, its the body work were the money gets eatten if its not right, thats why rat look, matt paint etc takes over as it means it can be made to look uniform for relatively low funds compaired with a back to all original colour respray which is beyond most DIYers including myself. Nothing wrong with it each to their own but sady these cars usually end up with a much shorter life span.

polos are usually starter cars and folk move on to what they view as bigger and better things which is fair enough. but on here you do see alot of people who are spending time (i deliberatley didnt use the word cash as that doesnt always make a good car) and they are making their polos look ace so all is not lost.

All cars are worth more in bits, especially modified stuff. As long as you've got storage you can make a killing breaking certain cars up.

Matt

at least the government scrap-scheme is finished now,shit loads of mk1 & mk2 polos, golfs, minis, and more went to that.

all so somebody could get 2k off a newer car... what they didnt realise was that as soon as it came in to place,

garages everywhere popped £1,800 on top of the price of all their cars.

I've ripped through a donor car to get mine up to spec, and i did feel bad about weighing it in afterwards but it was for a worthy cause, on some Spice Girls tip "when two become one..." ;)

yup. sickens me to see so many mk2 golf's, corrado's etc being broken. basically there are 2 causes.

1 - people are too tight to fix a car these days (even though they will then buy a newer car that will shed twice as much in value than any repair would have cost)

2 - people trying to sell for too much spit their dummies out when their car wont sell.

3 - The car is worth more to sell as parts than complete

It's a no brainer really in that situation surely

Edited by AMD_Man

yup. sickens me to see so many mk2 golf's, corrado's etc being broken. basically there are 2 causes.

1 - people are too tight to fix a car these days (even though they will then buy a newer car that will shed twice as much in value than any repair would have cost)

2 - people trying to sell for too much spit their dummies out when their car wont sell.

3 - cars are worth more in parts

4 - they might not be financially viable to repair

5 - they have ploughed massive amounts of money into it and it's the only way of getting most of it back

6 - it often works out cheaper to buy a doner car for the engine and sell off any thing you don't need

there are shit loads of reasons to break a car

i've ripped loads of usable condition cars apart for the engine, do i feel bad about it? why should i? i got what i wanted off it. unless your gonna pull a 1.4 afh conversion out of your arse and sell it to me for the pittance that it works out to of cost once i've sold of the bits i don't need and weighed in the rest, then your opinion on what i did to the car means nothing :lol:

end of the day once some one pays for a car it's there's to do what they like with, if you have an issue with that then you should of bought it first.

i take it all the people complaining about car's being broken won't be buying any of the parts from them? and no doubt you don't use breakers yards either as you obviously don't agree with the ethics behind them.

most people ask when a cars in the for sale section if it'll be broken.

dibs on suspension etc etc.

i have broken several cars, but often sold the shell on, or put the car back to standard (which is my preferred choice), get the car mot'd and tax, and sell it on for a new lease of life.

i wont scrap a decent shell, rather sell it for the scrap money to an enthusiast. the only car I've had thats met the crusher was a mk3 gt which i could peel the entire sill box section away from the body of the car...

yup. sickens me to see so many mk2 golf's, corrado's etc being broken. basically there are 2 causes.

1 - people are too tight to fix a car these days (even though they will then buy a newer car that will shed twice as much in value than any repair would have cost)

2 - people trying to sell for too much spit their dummies out when their car wont sell.

You mean a totally unique show car's* not worth that money?

*Definition of totally unique: Rattle canned matt black, fitted with a cheap and nasty 200mm suspension kit and had the bumpers taken off

I'd rather split a car and sell it as close to standard as possible. why should someone be able to buy your hard work?

If you dont have any originality or any ideas of what you want to do with a car, and you'd rather just buy one someone has already build for you, then IMO, your in the wrong game.

I hate seeing good cars broken too but as said when some cars get to the stage that they are worth more in parts, also selling a car seems to be a real ballache these days, too many timewasters and maniacs about, people expecting a 20 year old car in concourse, fresh out the box condition for 500 quid, some people just get frustrated after a while, and it's not always the ones asking too much money.

I used to have an Alfa 155, was a member on 155.org, used to break my hart how easily some of these cars got broke, the engine (especialy the 2.0 16V twinspark) was worth more than the whole car in some cases. Seen a cracking red 155 V6 broke because it failed it's MOT on the windscreen and exhaust, that was it ! :cry:

I just bought a MK3 Polo GT to break, it was advertised (on here) as "spares or repairs", did have thoughts about saving it but it realy is a parts car sadly, sills are terrible, they have been trolleyjacked to hell and badly repaired, tailgate is rotten, has rot around the filler cap and windscreen and a bash in the o/s/r wing.

Motor will live on in my Loon though, seats will go in my Genesis.

Nothing wrong with that, I don't mind breaking a rotbox, but I hate breaking cars that could easily be saved.

There's been times when I've turned down cars that were well priced that I was going to buy for breaking because they were too good for what I wanted. :oops:

yup. sickens me to see so many mk2 golf's, corrado's etc being broken. basically there are 2 causes.

1 - people are too tight to fix a car these days (even though they will then buy a newer car that will shed twice as much in value than any repair would have cost)

2 - people trying to sell for too much spit their dummies out when their car wont sell.

You mean a totally unique show car's* not worth that money?

*Definition of totally unique: Rattle canned matt black, fitted with a cheap and nasty 200mm suspension kit and had the bumpers taken off

i mean stuff like good mk2 golfs, corrados etc. up for sale for £500-£1000 more than what they are worth. for example i saw a 5 door small bumpered mk2 16v up for £1600. was solid and fully functioning but nothing special. because it didnt sell, he was breaking it. how would he get near even half what he was asking in parts? whats worth more than a couple of hundred besides the engine on a mk2 with a defect on every panel. would still be bought as a solid daily driver and live on if it was priced sensibly.

Case in point here http://www.clubpolo.co.uk/forum/index.php?...=218743&hl=

The bloke's a bloody idiot who doesn't deserve a nice car IMO, I've honestly got more respect for the two pikeys I watched weigh a coupe s in this morning.

Bit harsh calling him an idiot, he's paid to have a new engine fitted, he's paid to have a brand new carb fitted and he's had 8 people look at it to try and find the problem. It's not like he hasn't put time and money into trying to sort the car out, but there comes a time when you have to draw the line and say enough is enough, for the sake of your bank balance and your sanity.

See this is what happens when some one that isn't magically minded decides they want to drive an old modified car. A problem arises that would he simple enough for some one that knows theses cars to diagnose, but because he doesn't know about them he has to pay some one else to sort it and costs spiral.

I'm going to take a wild stab in the dark here and guess that Judging by some of the replies in that add when asked to sell as a whole he asked for what he priced it as in parts which retrowagen didn't want to pay? And why shouldn't he ask for what he was hoping to get breaking it seems as that's what he was doing with it, like he says its worth more in parts. No doubt that with all the money he must of chucked at it having engines and the like fitted it owes him a lot more than he would ever get for it, so why shouldn't take the route that will see him get as much of that money back as he can?

genesisGT hit the nail on the head

"Once you have replaced the brakes , suspension and all the other bits they tend to need at this age etc its usually as much as the car so when folk want to sell they have to remember its done out of the love of the polo not to make money."

You've got two types of dubber in this world. Those who do it out of love and those who do it for the ££.

Those who do it for the ££ have zero respect from me, I'd sooner see a daily on the road being driven as it should be, maintained by the owners own fair hands than some trailer queen showcar that's had endless ££ thrown at it.

Unfortunately, the same 50/50 split can too often be seen in the market, be it cars or parts - for every 10 good guys, there's one ready to screw you over for as much as he can grab and it saddens me to the core.

But such is the pitfall of being involved in such a passionate community.

You've got two types of dubber in this world. Those who do it out of love and those who do it for the ££.

i wouldnt say they do it for the money, as i don't see how they are making money from spending dollar, building a car, then breaking it 12 months later cos they are bored of it. I would say that they see the car as a fashion accesory more than anything and want to get as much as their investment back as possible.

You can always spot someone who is truely into their cars. They wont be wearing box fresh nikes, they'll be scruffy buggers with oil stained mits.

Granted there are folk, who specifically buy good cars, just to break them, but so long as people are willing to buy the parts, other people will keep breaking them.

So where do I fall in your 50/50 split? I build and maintain all my cars myself on tight budgets and i'll often give up spare parts or my time to help out fellow dubbers, but I'm not so well off that I can afford to let sentiment get in the way of my hobby. If its a choice between spending 300 on a engine conversion, or spending 400 on a whole car to break and effectively cut the cost of the conversion to around 100 then I'm gonna do it.

End of the day feeding my family and keeping a roof above our heads will always come before my cars which means money for my hobby is always tight. I do what I do how I do so I can actually have a hobby, if people don't like that then fine, but I'm sure your hypocrisy will come shining through if I ever have a part from a car i've broke that you need :lol:

So where do I fall in your 50/50 split? I build and maintain all my cars myself on tight budgets and i'll often give up spare parts or my time to help out fellow dubbers, but I'm not so well off that I can afford to let sentiment get in the way of my hobby. If its a choice between spending 300 on a engine conversion, or spending 400 on a whole car to break and effectively cut the cost of the conversion to around 100 then I'm gonna do it.

End of the day feeding my family and keeping a roof above our heads will always come before my cars which means money for my hobby is always tight. I do what I do how I do so I can actually have a hobby, if people don't like that then fine, but I'm sure your hypocrisy will come shining through if I ever have a part from a car i've broke that you need :lol:

You are one I'd consider to be doing 'it' out of love.

I too am on a budget, I too maintain my cheap little car myself, I too have broken donar cars to make good for others, I too will dedicate time and parts to other dubbers alike. I've spent hours vagcom scanning, diagnosing and helping to repair faults on other peoples cars.

My post's been taken out of context.

I wasn't suggesting for one minute that those who break cars or consider that to be more economical than keeping it on the road aren't dubbers.

I was criticising those who think they're able to charge over the odds for something because they consider it 'rare' or because they've spent a fortune modifying it.

I was criticising those who I've met that are simply out to screw the next person over - it taints the whole 'ethos' of dubbing - we're supposed to help each other out, not screw each other over.

Edited by eshrules

It's not even the money, it's just some people do things that stretch them because they want to, and others want things handed to them on a plate.

You're the first sort Guy, total embodiment of the "I reckon I can fit that engine in there." kind of person, the others are the sort that'll post up "How much will a garage want to change the fuel pump on my mk2?" then when they get told it's a 5 minute job withg an allen key, keey asking the same question, turn down offers of help, then pay a garage £100 to do it. Then when the garage puts the hoses on the wrong way round, decide it's not repairable. Then the car they've just spend £100's on, having bought it off someone who's put years of their life into it ends up getting dumped on their mum's drive as they "break it for spares" ie, sell the indicators off it and give the rest to the scrapman 10 years later.

Yeah, it's safe to say they piss me off.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.