Skip to content

g40 or golf gti?

Featured Replies

I've always dreamed of owning a mk1 golf gti or mk2 for many years then i learned about the polo g40 and have wanted one ever since mainly due to how understated they are.

if you had cash now for either what would you have? and why?

  • Replies 48
  • Views 3.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Boost.

Boost.

x2

g-smiles all the way

Had 8v and 16v Golfs and a G40...No contest...G40 :thumbsup:

booooooost

Never driven either but been passenger in 3 different GTIs and a G40. Boost is definitely the way to go!

The sensible choice is a mk2 gti, but it's not always about being sensible. The Mk2 Golf was the world's first boring eurobox.

If a Mk2 GTI would work for you, then the clever choice is an audi coupe.

  • Author

sure they can be made to look good though, i'd have a mk1 over a mk2 its just the price difference is pretty huge if you want a nice mk1 gti and the value a mk1 gti and g40 would hold or even gain compared to a mk2 would be pretty big

Mk1 Golf G40 is the best of all worlds :nod:

Mk1 Golf G40 is the best of all worlds :nod:

kool-aid-man.jpg

Was gonna say, G40 the Mk1 :-D

G40 all the way

Mk1 G60 even better...

I'd love to be sensible and say if I had the money right now I'd go for the Mk2 GTI 16v as it is quicker, handles better and is better looking than the G40.

But if you were to place both cars infront of me and ask me to choose I'd choose the G40, have a quick drive of one and you will want one, its as simple as that.

I'd love to be sensible and say if I had the money right now I'd go for the Mk2 GTI 16v as it is quicker, handles better and is better looking than the G40.

But if you were to place both cars infront of me and ask me to choose I'd choose the G40, have a quick drive of one and you will want one, its as simple as that.

In my experience a Mk2 16v would be embarrassed at the lights by a G40 and i wouldnt say it's better looking. Agreed on the handling side though unless the polo's had a bit of work done.

Get a G40 - You probably cant afford a mk1 GTI unless you're wadded and mk2's are common as muck.

I'd love to be sensible and say if I had the money right now I'd go for the Mk2 GTI 16v as it is quicker, handles better and is better looking than the G40.

But if you were to place both cars infront of me and ask me to choose I'd choose the G40, have a quick drive of one and you will want one, its as simple as that.

In my experience a Mk2 16v would be embarrassed at the lights by a G40 and i wouldnt say it's better looking. Agreed on the handling side though unless the polo's had a bit of work done.

Get a G40 - You probably cant afford a mk1 GTI unless you're wadded and mk2's are common as muck.

A decent G's gonna set you back around the same as a decent GTI!

Mk1 G60 even better...

Hmmm, I'd have to disagree there. My mate had a g60 cabby that was close to 200bhp and it was surprisingly docile to be in, it went ok but didn't even chuck you into the seat a bit when booted which suprize me.

Mk2 16v is superior to the mk1 gti in every way but scene tax

I'd probably choose the g40 over a 16v tho just because I've never owned one and wouldn't mind giving it a go at some point but buying a g40 isn't some thing that should be taken lightly, they do seem to need to be maintained well and costs can soon spiral if some thing does go wrong (seen it happen on here many times over the years).

I'd love to be sensible and say if I had the money right now I'd go for the Mk2 GTI 16v as it is quicker, handles better and is better looking than the G40.

But if you were to place both cars infront of me and ask me to choose I'd choose the G40, have a quick drive of one and you will want one, its as simple as that.

In my experience a Mk2 16v would be embarrassed at the lights by a G40 and i wouldnt say it's better looking. Agreed on the handling side though unless the polo's had a bit of work done.

Get a G40 - You probably cant afford a mk1 GTI unless you're wadded and mk2's are common as muck.

A decent G's gonna set you back around the same as a decent GTI!

You can pick a decent G40 up for £2.5K, maybe less. If you want a well looked after Mk1 GTI you're looking at £4 - 5K seemingly. Mk2 GTI's can still be had for cheap as chips although clean stockers are going up in value now.

I'd love to be sensible and say if I had the money right now I'd go for the Mk2 GTI 16v as it is quicker, handles better and is better looking than the G40.

But if you were to place both cars infront of me and ask me to choose I'd choose the G40, have a quick drive of one and you will want one, its as simple as that.

In my experience a Mk2 16v would be embarrassed at the lights by a G40 and i wouldnt say it's better looking. Agreed on the handling side though unless the polo's had a bit of work done.

Get a G40 - You probably cant afford a mk1 GTI unless you're wadded and mk2's are common as muck.

A decent G's gonna set you back around the same as a decent GTI!

You can pick a decent G40 up for £2.5K, maybe less. If you want a well looked after Mk1 GTI you're looking at £4 - 5K seemingly. Mk2 GTI's can still be had for cheap as chips although clean stockers are going up in value now.

I'd say your well off with you mk1 gti valuation, you can still pick up good ones for 2.5k and under. The only ones I've seen going for like 5k are either highly modified or mint series 1's

Like for like g40's and mk1 gti's don't seem to be far off each other in terms of value until you get to stuff like the series 1's ect and the scene tax comes into play

Edited by McLOVIN

In my experience a Mk2 16v would be embarrassed at the lights by a G40.

Not really, standard v standard the Golf will win.

If you want to look good and go round corners then a MkII 16v is the car to have. If you want to go fast then a G40 with the basic chip n pulley is the ticket.

In my experience a Mk2 16v would be embarrassed at the lights by a G40.

Not really, standard v standard the Golf will win.

Truth.

I stand corrected then!!!

Been in a couple of mk2 ABFs and KRs etc, compared to a '40 they really did not feel as quick!

I'm sure i remember reading somewhere that the G40 had the same, if not marginally faster 0 - 60 time than a G60? Presumably due to the weight ratio?

Not that that makes much of a difference i know lol...................

Joe

Mk1 G60 even better...

This!

I've driven a high powered subframed G40.

I've also been in a stock low mileage G40.

I've driven Mk1 GTi's

I've driven Mk2 8v's, 16v's and ABF's.

Stock G40 and stock MK2 16v is close acceleration wise. Top end, braking/handling the golf nails it.

Highly modified 170+ bhp G40 on subframe with 256mm brakes and eibach shocks/springs vs Mk2 170bhp ABF on standard brakes and cheap coilovers. Acceleration is the same. Top end the ABF nails it, handling and braking the golf nails it. And the golf was on crap coilovers and standard brakes.

The G40 was more raw and thus felt faster. In the real world the golf is better. The golf is a better base to start with. Parts are more common and cheaper. The G40 is more exclusive.

Both are great cars and drive completely differently. It all depends on what you want?

Edited by EnthusiastOwned™

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.