Skip to content

g40 or golf gti?

Featured Replies

G40 buy a good one and you will never look back..... but if you're pretending to be sensible you might sell it and buy a diesel :lol:

Golfs are awesome but there is something about the tinny, small, simpleness of polos that makes them so much more fun. Having driven a mk2 golf ABF and my old G40 i would get in my old G40 over the golf every day of the week.

Both good cars.

  • Replies 48
  • Views 3.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

G40 buy a good one and you will never look back..... but if you're pretending to be sensible you might sell it and buy a diesel :lol:

Golfs are awesome but there is something about the tinny, small, simpleness of polos that makes them so much more fun. Having driven a mk2 golf ABF and my old G40 i would get in my old G40 over the golf every day of the week becuase I'm a jewish nancy boy.

Both good cars.

Fixed it for you.

Off topic but did you ever find your golf?

Off topic but did you ever find your golf?

Did I fuck! :lol:

I'm presuming it's in pieces or it was shipped off to some Romanian druglord who's cruising around his ghetto looking badass.

Not heard a peep off the police. My insurance company are being slack with giving me a fair valuation too. I'm driving a Fiat 500 at the moment and look like a right bender!

I'd say MK2 GTi.

But then id want a G40 as a weekend toy. If I was to live with one everyday it would be the golf. They both rust to buggery, and there are poor examples of both around, I'd try find a clean MK2 Gti, preferebly with a period GTi Engineering conversion 8-)

Got to be the golf for me (although i own 3 polo's - 2 G40's)

Had a 2.0 abf 16v 6 speed about 9 years ago now, and it shifted, suprised a few people. Always thought i was stupid to sell it and buy a VR.

If you get bored with the 16v you could always drop a 20v in and have some proper boosted fun ;)

I'd love to be sensible and say if I had the money right now I'd go for the Mk2 GTI 16v as it is quicker, handles better and is better looking than the G40.

But if you were to place both cars infront of me and ask me to choose I'd choose the G40, have a quick drive of one and you will want one, its as simple as that.

My Mk2 valver get spanked by Saf in his deathbox/polo/hairdryer :-p:lol:

G40's dont handle, MK2 GTI's do.

G40's are quick as fook and subtle, Mk2 GTi's are not especially quick & common.

Your call dude

I stand corrected then!!!

Been in a couple of mk2 ABFs and KRs etc, compared to a '40 they really did not feel as quick!

I'm sure i remember reading somewhere that the G40 had the same, if not marginally faster 0 - 60 time than a G60? Presumably due to the weight ratio?

Not that that makes much of a difference i know lol...................

Joe

G40's hit 60 in second gear. It's a bit of a cheat for pub talk. If you want the satisfaction of tuning a car and getting bang for your buck go for the G40.

G40s are great because of the flaws. It makes them very easy to improve, and it keeps you on your toes.

Right, I'm aware what I'm about to say will sound REALLY pretentious and sycophantic but...

I've driven somewhere in the region of 250 cars through work, ranging from weedy little city cars to retarded machinery that reacts to what you do with the pedals faster than you can process what's happening. And yet, I get behind the wheel of my car and every time I drive it I love it.

Yes it's crude, yes it's not exactly world class on the handling front, but it's HUGE fun to drive. The noise, the torque, the surprised faces you get from passengers and other cars when you drop the pedal into the carpet and the little tin can rockets off towards the horizon... priceless.

Now if we're comparing it to a Mk2 Golf, then the best analogy I can come up with is the difference between a Scirocco R and Golf R.

Now the Golf R is the better car, by far. It's got more power, four wheel drive and it takes everything in its stride. If you pointed it at a country road you'd arrive at the other end very, very quickly and with no drama.

Of course, the Scirocco R isn't slow, but it's only front wheel drive. This has the advantage of making all the controls feel lighter from within the car, the throttle feels sharper and it's an absolute hooligan on the road. Floor it, the DSG drops a couple of cogs and you wheelspin and torque steer torwards the horizon.

And you know what, it's more fun because of it. You wouldn't be that much slower than the Golf, but boy would you be grinning from ear to ear. The inferior car is sometimes better because it's more fun, and fast cars should by their very nature be fun to drive.

G40s are great because of the flaws. It makes them very easy to improve, and it keeps you on your toes.

Right, I'm aware what I'm about to say will sound REALLY pretentious and sycophantic but...

I've driven somewhere in the region of 250 cars through work, ranging from weedy little city cars to retarded machinery that reacts to what you do with the pedals faster than you can process what's happening. And yet, I get behind the wheel of my car and every time I drive it I love it.

Yes it's crude, yes it's not exactly world class on the handling front, but it's HUGE fun to drive. The noise, the torque, the surprised faces you get from passengers and other cars when you drop the pedal into the carpet and the little tin can rockets off towards the horizon... priceless.

Now if we're comparing it to a Mk2 Golf, then the best analogy I can come up with is the difference between a Scirocco R and Golf R.

Now the Golf R is the better car, by far. It's got more power, four wheel drive and it takes everything in its stride. If you pointed it at a country road you'd arrive at the other end very, very quickly and with no drama.

Of course, the Scirocco R isn't slow, but it's only front wheel drive. This has the advantage of making all the controls feel lighter from within the car, the throttle feels sharper and it's an absolute hooligan on the road. Floor it, the DSG drops a couple of cogs and you wheelspin and torque steer torwards the horizon.

And you know what, it's more fun because of it. You wouldn't be that much slower than the Golf, but boy would you be grinning from ear to ear. The inferior car is sometimes better because it's more fun, and fast cars should by their very nature be fun to drive.

Wow, you should work for a car magazine...

Wow, you should work for a car magazine...

Now there's an idea! :lol:

Alex, where have you gone since Max Power?

  • Author

tbh i want to own each of them, i think it would soley depend on what turned out when i was ready to buy. the whole reason i put this thread up is cos i've seen some good examples of all three, only thing that puts off mk2's is that i havnt seen one with under a 100k

Why would that put you off? My old 16v had over 180k on it on the last mot before I bought it and at some point in the 11 months from then till me getting it it was clocked so no idea what the actually mileage was by that point. Even with that high mileage it drove absolutely fantastic, every thing felt nice and tight and the engine sounded smooth and pulled like a train.

I'd worry more about how well try a car has been looked after rather than the miles on the clock, high miles does not bother them as long long as they have been showed a bit of love.

G40 all the way, I'm not just saying that because i own one beacuse i have driven a mk2 gti, i know it sounds all gay and that but its the way it makes you feel, it never fails to put a smile on my face, if you want a reliable semi quick car which looks good and easy to cosmeticaly modify then pick the mk2 gti

but if you want to pull up at a set of traffic lights and there happens to be a dick head in his £20.000 civic type r stick your foot down and you will be laughing all the way home haha

G40 all the way, I'm not just saying that because i own one beacuse i have driven a mk2 gti, i know it sounds all gay and that but its the way it makes you feel, it never fails to put a smile on my face, if you want a reliable semi quick car which looks good and easy to cosmeticaly modify then pick the mk2 gti

but if you want to pull up at a set of traffic lights and there happens to be a dick head in his £20.000 civic type r stick your foot down and you will be wheel spinning all the way home haha

Fixed

Off topic but did you ever find your golf?

Did I fuck! :lol:

I'm presuming it's in pieces or it was shipped off to some Romanian druglord who's cruising around his ghetto looking badass.

Not heard a peep off the police. My insurance company are being slack with giving me a fair valuation too. I'm driving a Fiat 500 at the moment and look like a right bender!

Gutted :-(

What are they offering you for the golf? I think my mate got some thing like £1800 for his 16v when it got nicked even tho there was no way he could get a similar spec/condition one for that sort of cash to replace it. Insurance companies suck ass tbh.

Off topic but did you ever find your golf?

Did I fuck! :lol:

I'm presuming it's in pieces or it was shipped off to some Romanian druglord who's cruising around his ghetto looking badass.

Not heard a peep off the police. My insurance company are being slack with giving me a fair valuation too. I'm driving a Fiat 500 at the moment and look like a right bender!

Gutted :-(

What are they offering you for the golf? I think my mate got some thing like £1800 for his 16v when it got nicked even tho there was no way he could get a similar spec/condition one for that sort of cash to replace it. Insurance companies suck ass tbh.

I know, I'm gutted, I've lost the love for cars now, i'm even considering a new euro box for hassle free motoring. :crybaby:

Erm... I'll let you know the amount when it's over.. I don't know who's watching! :ninja:

But yeah, it's not enough to replace the car I had fully insured with them. I was always under the impression they have to replace what you insured. I've sent off a very detailed dispute letter, photo's and about a billion receipts. I will fight them; I do NOT pay excessive premiums for them to belittle me over by a few grand which is nothing to them but everything to me.

I'm just waiting on an answer. I have a minimum figure I'll take. Wish me luck!

cheaper to tax, rarer, and you get to smoke people and then see thier faces when they ask you whats in it, and you say a 1.3! priceless.

plus you get to smoke bike carb'd ABF's! woop

I'd love to be sensible and say if I had the money right now I'd go for the Mk2 GTI 16v as it is quicker, handles better and is better looking than the G40.

But if you were to place both cars infront of me and ask me to choose I'd choose the G40, have a quick drive of one and you will want one, its as simple as that.

My Mk2 valver get spanked by Saf in his deathbox/polo/hairdryer :-p:lol:

G40's dont handle, MK2 GTI's do.

G40's are quick as fook and subtle, Mk2 GTi's are not especially quick & common.

Your call dude

Edited by grungeisdead

Mk1 GTI!!!

Alex, where have you gone since Max Power?

I'm now motoring editor at Fleet World, which is a trade mag for the fleet industry. Spend my time testing cars and writing about what's coming soon from the manufacturers. Was driving around on the Austrian border in a Jag XF R yesterday. That was fun. 8-)

cheaper to tax, rarer, and you get to smoke people and then see thier faces when they ask you whats in it, and you say a 1.3! priceless.

plus you get to smoke bike carb'd ABF's! woop

I'd love to be sensible and say if I had the money right now I'd go for the Mk2 GTI 16v as it is quicker, handles better and is better looking than the G40.

But if you were to place both cars infront of me and ask me to choose I'd choose the G40, have a quick drive of one and you will want one, its as simple as that.

My Mk2 valver get spanked by Saf in his deathbox/polo/hairdryer :-p:lol:

G40's dont handle, MK2 GTI's do.

G40's are quick as fook and subtle, Mk2 GTi's are not especially quick & common.

Your call dude

Damn you and your ebay superchargers!!!!

:p :evil: :evil:

hahaha the mk2 does look pimp as fuck, but small bumpered mk2s for the win!

hahaha the mk2 does look pimp as fuck, but small bumpered mk2s for the win!

I have small bumpers.....Y U NOT KNOW THIS? :lol:

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.