Skip to content

Hypothetical question! (What would you do)

Featured Replies

Hey!!

As you do i was serching through ebay for polo's and what not when i came across this little gem of an ad

First thing first look at the high of the front end. Made me giggle and question how much less my engine weighs compared to the old one as I've got that look going on with percy!

Anyway the question! - What would you do!

Obviously you will put a engine and box in it but the blank canvas how much fun would you have. It only has "DELIVERY MILEAGE". You get it for half the price of what it would have been on the forecourt with a engine and box. Personally i would try shoehorning the golf 170bhp tdi lump into it with the DSG, Bluemotion with attitude or some other silly slogan. Also like to see how my local VW garage would be if they popped the bonnet and found what was hidden :p

Yes i know its LHD and everything but this is only a hypothetical question and too see how imaginative some people are in here. Sooo fire away! :)

TTT

EDIT - MONEY NO QUESTION! SPEND AS MUCH AS YOU WANT! :p

Edited by Toptrumps2

  • Replies 34
  • Views 2.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Depends on how much an engine and gearbox would cost.

If money was taken out of the picture i would definitely try and get a R32 with DSG in there :biggrin:

Edited by rozza92

  • Author

Money no question, spend as much as you want :p

Money no question, spend as much as you want :p

if money were no question, sorry to say it everybody...

ide ditch the polo all together and buy a scirocco...

  • Author
Money no question, spend as much as you want :p

if money were no question, sorry to say it everybody...

ide ditch the polo all together and buy a scirocco...

Hmmmm i think ill change the rules now, I'm sure with enough hammering you could make it look more like a scirocco in one way or another!

rebuilt R32... enough said

  • Author

There is a R32 based motor in the phaeton right?

Giggle and a half if you stuck the w12 in a polo. You will have to have to do alot of shoehorning and most likely have to move the whole dash layout back a foot or 2 but still :p

Edited by Toptrumps2

R32!!

They're bloody ugly, ugliest small hatch around at the minute, so i'd weigh it in.

:o

Thats surprised me that has, not yet heard someone say the new polo is ugly.

The interior on the bluemotion is rank though. Love the boot spoiler though.

Money no object? twin bike engines of some shape. Just for the fun of it

2JZ it tbh. Just for the novelty.

Screw vag engines, id RB26 it, probably wouldnt fit but a guy can dream :)

fuck trying to fit something in...

definitely a rear mounted ls3.

High output diesel for sure, but no way would I have a DSG autospastic bag of wank in it.

Seems pointless going down the 'drivers car' route, so i have reservations with the otherwise obvious 2.0TSi and i cant even see an R36 lump saving it.

So id be looking at doing something different. I dont see diesels as the way forward at all,so that's out.

It depends what the car's to be used for,but id be interested in a solar accumulation electric car. Shared solar/wind charging at the main places of standing,such as both at work and home,and charge stations also offered at retail parks/supermarkets/etc knowing that they can attract more customers (as with offering Wi-fi, toilets etc) would mean it spends over 20hrs a day charging. So with it being used as a second or third car for city commuting/driving,there would be no fuel bill.

A small battery pack would suffice for such a vehicle,and a powerful electric motor would make it very nippy indeed.

So with performance and zero fuel bills to tempt people who dont do long distance,it could be a worthy proposition,and that particular Polo could make for a good quality example to show the way forward.

Hydrogen fuel cell stack in the boot biggest electric motor I can find up front.

the bluemotion looks alot better than most new polos cuz of the sexy grille and spoiler but the wheels are whack

Money no object?... I'd want some thing like an EVO fq360 engine and running gear in it and tune the living shit out of it, fuck pissing about with vag engines :lol:

  • Author

The evo mod sounds fun!!! :) But i would carry on pissing around with VAG engine's wondering if you could fit something from the yellow side of the vag family into the back or something abit Swedish.

DS14 V8? Or a DS11! :) Give it enough torque to rip a house down!

Edited by Toptrumps2

It depends what the car's to be used for,but id be interested in a solar accumulation electric car. Shared solar/wind charging at the main places of standing,such as both at work and home,and charge stations also offered at retail parks/supermarkets/etc knowing that they can attract more customers (as with offering Wi-fi, toilets etc) would mean it spends over 20hrs a day charging. So with it being used as a second or third car for city commuting/driving,there would be no fuel bill.

A small battery pack would suffice for such a vehicle,and a powerful electric motor would make it very nippy indeed.

So with performance and zero fuel bills to tempt people who dont do long distance,it could be a worthy proposition,and that particular Polo could make for a good quality example to show the way forward.

You'd need a lot of solar panels. The roof area of the average 3/4 bed detatched house provides enough space for about 3kW-worth, which would charge the car at the same rate as a standard BS1363 domestic socket.

You'd also want some sort of energy storage at home, as presumably you're out at work during the day when the panels would be harnessing useful energy.

It depends what the car's to be used for,but id be interested in a solar accumulation electric car. Shared solar/wind charging at the main places of standing,such as both at work and home,and charge stations also offered at retail parks/supermarkets/etc knowing that they can attract more customers (as with offering Wi-fi, toilets etc) would mean it spends over 20hrs a day charging. So with it being used as a second or third car for city commuting/driving,there would be no fuel bill.

A small battery pack would suffice for such a vehicle,and a powerful electric motor would make it very nippy indeed.

So with performance and zero fuel bills to tempt people who dont do long distance,it could be a worthy proposition,and that particular Polo could make for a good quality example to show the way forward.

You'd need a lot of solar panels. The roof area of the average 3/4 bed detatched house provides enough space for about 3kW-worth, which would charge the car at the same rate as a standard BS1363 domestic socket.

You'd also want some sort of energy storage at home, as presumably you're out at work during the day when the panels would be harnessing useful energy.

You appear to have missed most of my post. In fact,its hard to find any part of it you read?

Let me summarise it for others that dont get it..

Say i use my car for work and shopping. This is all in the same town. So i do about ten miles a day.

The car is on charge at home. Its on charge at work. And its on charge at the mall.

Believe me,its not gonna be short of charge.

People moan about electric cars only being able to do 100 miles between charges. Well how far do you need? Drive 300 miles a day in your private car,do you..?

Some do. And for them its not the answer.

But for the 99% of us who dont,its quite viable.

On the contrary Mikey, I happen to have experience of EVs - and I'm talking real, hands-on design and development experience here. I use one several times a week, on the motorway, in town, on country lanes and have used them 100 miles north of the artic circle at -37degC and in +40degC heat elsewhere, so have a fair amount of first-hand experiences of their strengths and weaknesses. They are perfectly viable vehicles for a lot of people if you ignore the purchase price/lease costs - which hopefully will be addressed eventually.

If you only have a small solar array (e.g. roof of a Polo will probably net you about 250W of charge) you'd not have enough power to keep the battery heating mats on in winter, let alone charge the car.

In a vehicle that's much more no-frills (and lighter) than the Nissan LEAF, I can get around 70 miles range in real-life city/town driving - we get over 110 miles range on the standard emissions drivecycles. In winter, if you use the PTC heater, lights, demist etc. sensibly that range can drop to around 50 miles. If you like the cabin toasty enough to wear a T-shirt when it's 0degC outside expect that range to drop further still.

The car in question needs 8 hours to recharge its 26kWh battery from a BS1363 plug at 3kW - note the maths doesn't work out there because it'll show 0% SOC with a couple of kWh left in it, as totally discharging a lithium pack is really not a good idea unless you fancy replacing it regularly. So, 26kWh will comfortably do 50 miles in winter - you only want 10 mile range, so a 6kWh pack should do the job.

All looks feasible for the 250W panel so far - okay it'll take nearly a day to fully charge, but your argument is that it's never fully discharged as it's always plugged in somewhere. Works okay as long as you don't have to dash to the hospital with one of your kids, or find a road's closed on the way home - or find that the charge points are all occupied wherever you're going etc etc. (I have first-hand experience of the last two!). Still, as long as you have another car or contingency plan it's still manageable if not so convenient.

Now, back to the battery heating mats... Charging at 250W (I'm assuming UK mains voltage here) is only just over an amp going in to your battery pack, which isn't enough for the cell chemistry to do any self-heating. You can't charge or discharge a lithium pack below 0degC, otherwise you end up with a thermal event sooner or later - so you have to keep it just above that threshold as a minimum. So, you have to heat the pack - and I know from experience you'll need at least 300W worth of heating for a 6kWh pack to be usable after a soak-down at -5degC. Want it to work at -10degC, you'll need a bit more heating power etc. etc.

An ex-colleague of mine works at a solar panel company working on some interesting looking technology, hopefully within the next 5 years they might have a marketable product that gives a high enough energy density to start making your suggestion worthwhile. We have a 25mph, 25 mile range 1-ton pickup in our line-up that'd be a prime candidate. At the moment though, you do need a decent sized solar array and ideally some energy storage to make it work.

I suppose with most workplaces,most employees are there most of the time. So some will only have one charging allocation. With my work there are four shifts,so there would be plenty of charging there because most people are off work at any one time.

I can see there being problems with enough to go around elsewhere,too. Breakages,vandalism - as long as there's difficulty finding a parking space,its always an issue.

But as traditional shops turn into 24hr online distribution centres,you can expect continued fragmentation of the traditional working week,along with the breakdown of office hours and rush hour.

So having all the demand on charging hubs at one time of day wont be such a problem.

Then there are the electric bikes to help free things up.

And not everyone will use electric. Even privately they wont until its gone through a development revolution.

As long as thousands of people only ever drive their combustion engines whilst cold,i think the market is obvious.

In a nutshell, EVs are logistically more difficult to live with and require a bit more forward-planning than their combustion engined cousins - but that's just because our infrastructure and lifestyle has evolved around petrol and diesel vehicles.

However, once you realise you can do 100 miles for £1.50, a bit of planning of your journeys starts to seem like a small price to pay for the cost savings - and using an EV seems to be getting easier over time as more charge stations pop up.

Biggest barrier is the purchase price or lease costs - though our trial fleet users are paying £190pcm including insurance and maintenance, which is quite keenly priced. Amazingly all of the cars are clocking up higher mileages than we thought - we expected 6-10,000 miles per year average, but most are on target to top 15k - with some on track to exceed 20k. After speaking to a few customers, it seems that they're only using their 'normal' car(s) when they absolutely have to, so the EVs are getting more usage than anticipated.

Had a go on an electric pushbike at the Geneva Motor Show earlier this year. It was awesome fun, if a little pricey at €6k - though the French P.O. were sniffing around them to replace mopeds.

I think there'd be a market for a cheap and light single-seater EV with a 50-60 mile range, but good performance and enough luggage space for some work clobber or a week's food shopping. Like a Sinclair C5 kind of idea, but bigger and not so shit. Sadly it's more achievable for the DIYer than an OEM - we're so restricted by safety regulations it'd end up being the size of a Lupo, or nice and small but the price of a house.

twin suzuki hayabusa 1300cc motor bike engines both with turbo charger one engine powering the front and one powering the rear, wrc body work and then lowered and a nice set of alloys :p

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.