Skip to content

Polo or Corsa?

Featured Replies

When my daughter was looking for her first car I told her if she bought a corsa or nova I would have nothing to do with it - in the end we found a high miler - 122k - 99 CL with great bodywork but slightly noisy/leaky engine, apart from some fun and games with a duff thermostat I'm pleased with the decision especially as two of her friends who own low mileage corsas have had probs - one has to go in to get the camchain changed at £450 (Vauxhall main dealer) and the other had ecu probs - shouldn't get too smug as something might go wrong but she still loves her rattly old polo - hopefully sort the rattles out this w/e as I'm changing the tappets and cam belt..

  • Replies 32
  • Views 3.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Obviously I'd say polo as it's all i have owned.

My older brother had a Corsa C (got it from my mum) and to be fair to it, it was an excellent car that he could rely on. It never broke down and wasn't expensive to maintain (although he seldom serviced it) and he absolutely shagged the thing as he didn't really care about it. Still, it never died. Well not until he stacked it into the back of a van that wasn't indicating when he wasn't paying enough attention. Now it's dead and he has an old polo :-D Funny old world.

Corsa.

and he absolutely shagged the thing as he didn't really care about it.

My%20Car%20Is%20My%20Lover_%20Strangelov

^^ :lol: Can't beat a bit of organic polish for that mirror shine.

I had 2 corsas, a 1.2 prefacelift which wasnt too bad, pretty boring but was my first car, then i had a 1.4 exclusiv with full heated leather climate control and the works, lovely car and did look nice but cost me £3200 and had been absolutely shagged, ended up hitting a badger and then the following weak gearbox went at 90k miles, so sold it for bits on ebay and made £1300 back.

then came the ratty 6n, the oldest, leakiest, cheapest, rusty'est (lol?) but by far the best car of all 3.

gimme a dub over any vauxhall...

this was mine after the accident looking abit sorry for itself!

img0182qm.jpg

Uploaded with ImageShack.us

Around where i live every one has a corsa, its upsetting really, as for the modified scene for corsa bs, goes as far as 60mm springs, a spoiler and "cav slabs"

And as for Corsa Cs every one i have come across has needed the chain tensioning, as it taps furiously, and they're ridiculously over priced, for a high mileaged one

Polo all the way

you know this is forum is called "club polo" right? lol

Polos aside, Corsas can fuck off for the rest of their life.

There literally isn't an insult in the dictionary to describe Corsas.

I valet my uncles 60 plate Corsa the other day. There is already rust proofing dripping from the inside of the door, the door shuts were covered in mud (behind the doors) and the carpet was near impossible to vacuum because it was so cheap.

Oh, and it has next to no power low down. I floored it in first and fuck all happened.

Edited by MattLoaf

As a daily driver, I've had 2 Polo's, Golf, Corsa, & a KA.

From my experience, never get a KA - EVER.

Corsa's are okay but mine suffered from balljoint & bush issues every other month and it was completely standard and drove sensibly.

Polos are just generally robust and reliable, that's why they suit everyone, so I'd recommend a Polo - or atleast a VeeDub fullstop. :-D

VauxhallCorsa.png

When I was 18 I had a 1.6 sport corsa b which I loved, until it started burning a litre of oil every 100 miles

Currently drive a corsa d 'design' lol 1.3 cdti 6 speed, not a bad car an quite nippy for what it is but not setting world on fire

Probably had more grief overall from the polos I owned than the corsas :-)

driven a '08 corsa 1.2, what a bag of shit may as well not even have a first gear, dangerously slow if you dont rag it

Not had any experience with Corsas thankfully, but for some reason I have a burning hatred for all the local scallywags lol that drive them. THEIR EVERYWHERE!

Polo

After working at a vauxhall dealership ill never own one.

Out of curiosity, wouldn't a corsa be more expensive to insure due to the "boy racer effect"?

I got a 58 plate Corsa Eco-Flex Diesel...does nearly 70mph.

Out of curiosity what mpg do you get out of the Eco flex? Mpg isn't so great on my normal diesel one but I do generally drive it flat out from cold to tuning it off, because as a company car it would be rude not to lol

Out of curiosity, wouldn't a corsa be more expensive to insure due to the "boy racer effect"?

That and the fact they are simply a more common choice for young drivers thus they are in accidents, modified etc more than other cars; it's one of the main reasons I ended up in a Polo rather than something from the 'obvious' first car range (Corsas, small Peugeots etc).

Corsas are cheaply made and built to be affordable. Like Kias. And Citroens.

They are within reach of millions when new, but they're a poor choice used.

The Polo isn't as far greater quality as it once was. It has to be attainable to a competitive degree with its rivals. The margins have closed somewhat. But not entirely - the Polo is a better car, and should carry off a higher premium as a result.

You choose from that.

it's probably already been said, but if you ask on a forum about polos, the answer is generally gonna be polo =P

oh, and polo. corsas are okay.. but boring, and i've never seen a modified one that i like..

  • Author

It was just a statement really - we've never had a vw in the family before and I'm really impressed with the build quality of her polo and the way its obviously taken a beating in its life and still ploughs on (esp in corners lol) - very comfy but the handling is not great - my primera outhandles it, and nearly everything else on the road! - I was thinking about replacing the prim with a Mazda 6 (awesome value for money and a real drivers car) but am seriously considering a Golf GT 150 diesel based on experience with the Polo -

I have had a Corsa B in the past and liked it. I don't remember it ever letting me down once, which is more than can be said about ANY of the VW's I have owned.

It was just a statement really

oh right, fair enough =P

You cant deny, as much as i hate to say it - theres something about the roar of a 16v corsa b thats appealing...

Edited by Tramp

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.