Skip to content

Which Polo is a better first car?

Featured Replies

Question is which is better as a first car? Like having better handling, braking, safety etc.. Just overall better for a new driver. Although I have been driving quite a bit on my provisional, before passing my test, so I do have quite a bit of driving experience in 3 different cars so I'm not completely a new driver.

Although insurance is a good £300 cheaper for a 1.0 mk3 than a 1.0 6n... which makes me lean towards a mk3 to save a few ££/year

Which is YOUR opinion on the best for new drivers?

Edited by DavidTiger

  • Replies 25
  • Views 2.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted Images

It depends on what you want from a car.

6n's are usualy comftable and easy to drive, but are a bit bland and boring.

Mk3s are are 10x more fun than a 6n, basicaly because you feel on the edge on country lanes following margret in her micra, usualy uncomftable compared to a 6n though.

Edited by mattpolo5491

  • Author

At first its going to be a daily for a good year or so, until I can afford to insure something better. Then I want something that you can give some beanz down the country roads, obviously a 1.0 aint go much of that but its quick enough..

Comfort.. well the family cars are a Land Rover Discovery which just isn't comfortable at all, and a Ford Cougar with leather seats.. which are reasonable but are still not that comfortable... The mk3 Golf GTi we had was the most comfortable car we've had.

I had a 6n, although having never driven it any more than around my street, I can say it was almost as comfortable as the Golf.

I do like both very much, I look at a nice example of a mk3 and think "I want that"... but then 5 minutes later I see a equally good example of a 6n and think the exact same..

One other reason I'm leaning toward a mk3 is because they're rare around here, and would be unique and stand out from other cars and the vast majority or nutters in their ricey corsa's :lol:

6n's on the other hand are reasonably popular around here, usually old people or young women (no offence 6n drivers :)) but its true to say...

And most of all.. Insurance wise I could insure a mk3 1.3 for the same price as a 6n 1.0!

I know with the above statement you could say I just made the decision myself, but you guys know the cars better than I do so I was looking for some valued opinions :)

Edited by DavidTiger

I have had a mk2 and a 6n2 (not exactly the same but near enough) the mk2 was fun at a safe speed, the 6n2 was fun at higher speeds. I'd buy that mk3.

The older the better. The worse the brakes the better. Manual steering is essential. The feeling of vulnerability is essential. You need your first car to teach you to respect the roads, and deter you from speed. It should be involving to drive, so you embrace a good driving attitude and deter yourself from developing arrogance.

But you don't seem to agree. You want comfort. You want a car that'll be easy to pilot fairly swiftly. I think this is wrong. So it's a matter of preference really.

Just consider this - the more effort you put into anything, the more reward you get out. That's a pretty universal aspect in life.

On my driveway sit two Polos, a '99 6n and an '85 MK2. At the same speeds, on the same roads, the MK2 is far more fun to drive than the 6n (better visibility makes it easier to park, too).

older the better, besides the mk2/3 being lower enhances the sense of speed.

The older the better. The worse the brakes the better. Manual steering is essential. The feeling of vulnerability is essential. You need your first car to teach you to respect the roads, and deter you from speed. It should be involving to drive, so you embrace a good driving attitude and deter yourself from developing arrogance.

But you don't seem to agree. You want comfort. You want a car that'll be easy to pilot fairly swiftly. I think this is wrong. So it's a matter of preference really.

Just consider this - the more effort you put into anything, the more reward you get out. That's a pretty universal aspect in life.

On my driveway sit two Polos, a '99 6n and an '85 MK2. At the same speeds, on the same roads, the MK2 is far more fun to drive than the 6n (better visibility makes it easier to park, too).

Exactly.

Mikey has hit the nail on the head with that.

Mk2 non servo brakes and praying you stop FTW :lol:

I'd say get a 6n just because they are disposable motoring, piss cheap and easily replaced :lol:

breadies are good. great visibilty, which is usefull for parking etc.

I also agree with Mikey. For even more 'involvment'You could get a MK1 895cc. Thats what i had, for 2 years. It would do 75mph, but felt like it would disintegrate over 60 (so i hardly went over 55), had bad wheel wobble, poor brakes, no sound proofing, no head rests, and no rev counter. And would lean onto its door handles when cornering. It was great fun tho. I still miss driving it.

I have a MK3 1.0 now, and its also a great option. It feels much more solid than the MK1, its quiet, and easy to drive, and with a decent lowering kit it handles pretty good too, and its quicker than you'd think when you want it to be ;) Personally i would always buy a MK1, 2 or 3 over a 6N, even though a 6N is superior in every way (apart from looks and coolness)

6N will handle better, stop better and rust better than a Mk3. It's also quieter, more refined, safer, and these days seems to be cheaper than a Mk3. Mk3's probably easier to tune on a budget, but a 6N is loads cheaper to slam on its arse if that's your thing. The Mk3 Polo is more involving/challenging to drive.

I learnt to drive in a 6N when they were brand new, but bought a Mk3 as that's all I could afford - and it was a darn site safer than the Mini I really wanted. The 6N was easier to drive quickly, and more forgiving thanks to brakes that worked. If I'd stacked it, the 6N would've been the one to crash - even in its heyday the Mk3 Polo was an old design. Whilst I understand Mikey's sentiment that as a young driver you need a sense of vulnerability instilling in you, I don't necessarily agree that it's a good reason to buy a Mk3 over a 6N! The average supermini these days is a few hundred kilos heavier than a Mk3, and significantly larger - so chances are, whatever you hit, you lose...

So, to answer your original criteria "Like having better handling, braking, safety etc.", I'd say get a 6N.

handling, braking, safety ... probably a 6n, my brother has one and its a good first car, bit boring, and what mikey said is true and would explain my brothers driving. lol

but personally id go for a mk3 because i dont consider safety when buying a car and the other 2 factors can be upgraded, should hold value better (if rust doesnt get the better of it :-) ), cheaper to insure (classic policy) and just generally cooler, i think

i would choose a mk3 over a 6n, personally i think they look so much better and i have a 1l mk3 and my mate has a 1l 6n and mine nails his just because it so much lighter also a mk3 will increase in value sooner than a 6n. :)

  • Author

Seen a nice mk2 coupe S and its not too far from me, I do like it and its actually cheaper on insurance than the mk3 or 6n and its still a 1.3...

Although I kind of still prefer the mk3.. :lol: I just can bring myself to a choice because when I do I see something else...

I have a mk2 and a mk3 within driving distance from me but I can only go see one because I would be wasting too much of my spending money on fuel.. I'm leaning towards the mk3 because its probably the better of the two and its £200 cheaper..

The mk2 would need some work to getting it to what I want, since it has bucket seats, no rear seats, cherrybomb exhaust.. although providing its not too loud it wouldn't matter too much..

The mk3 however is pretty much standard and has a lot less miles..

The cars in question are these, pictures:

post-36462-1317242255_thumb.jpg

post-36462-1317242265.jpg

Edited by DavidTiger

I'd say get the mk2 (Biased as i used to have one) it may even be better on fuel than the one litre as it wont be struggling to move the car as much. remove the cherry bomb and you'd be onto a winner.

Easily a 6N as i have one, thought it would be horrible to drive when my mother gave it too me (DONT LAUGH (Y)) but i've fallen in love with the bloody thing :) Easy to run, cheap to insure. All you need really :).

I'd go for that mk3, just because that mk2 seems like its been chavved up a bit, so not sure how reliable it would be. Of course it may be fine, but is it worth the risk? Plus if you want to modify, modify the mk3 yourself to suit what you want rather than buying something pre-modified as your first car. Either mk3 or mk2 great first cars though. It's all about the experience of having a basic car and learning to drive properly in it.

Oh and don't worry about miles, it's how well it's been looked after thats important.

Edited by Polo Will

  • Author

I do agree the mk2 has a bit of a 'chav' look to it but that's all easily removable, find myself a standard GT interior, a decent exhaust and possibly remove that eyelid and I'd be onto a good base to work off since its already lowered 40mm allround and on alloys (although not great but it does at least have alloys)..

It has 148k miles but I need to have a better speak to the guy about its history etc..But it was used as a daily so the miles are expected to be high..

I have until probably Mon-Tue to finally make a decision to which one to go and have a look at, But then it whichever one might not be as good as it sounds and I'd have to spend more money to see the other...

I sound like a right tight a*se :lol: but the less money I spend on fuel the more I have to buy the car :)

i have a 6n...and i think id still prefer a mk3.

maybe louder/shitter, but it makes up for the in the fun factor, modern cars are shit

The older the better. The worse the brakes the better. Manual steering is essential. The feeling of vulnerability is essential. You need your first car to teach you to respect the roads, and deter you from speed. It should be involving to drive, so you embrace a good driving attitude and deter yourself from developing arrogance.

But you don't seem to agree. You want comfort. You want a car that'll be easy to pilot fairly swiftly. I think this is wrong. So it's a matter of preference really.

Just consider this - the more effort you put into anything, the more reward you get out. That's a pretty universal aspect in life.

On my driveway sit two Polos, a '99 6n and an '85 MK2. At the same speeds, on the same roads, the MK2 is far more fun to drive than the 6n (better visibility makes it easier to park, too).

Absolutely agree

Also worth considering is that the mk2 will only go up in value. I don't see this so much with the 6N's (maybe in another 10 years).

mk2/3 breddy , and i have a great one for sale , ...love to =keep it butm cant justify it

come and see ? x

The older the better. The worse the brakes the better. Manual steering is essential. The feeling of vulnerability is essential. You need your first car to teach you to respect the roads, and deter you from speed. It should be involving to drive, so you embrace a good driving attitude and deter yourself from developing arrogance.

But you don't seem to agree. You want comfort. You want a car that'll be easy to pilot fairly swiftly. I think this is wrong. So it's a matter of preference really.

Just consider this - the more effort you put into anything, the more reward you get out. That's a pretty universal aspect in life.

On my driveway sit two Polos, a '99 6n and an '85 MK2. At the same speeds, on the same roads, the MK2 is far more fun to drive than the 6n (better visibility makes it easier to park, too).

Absolutely agree

Also worth considering is that the mk2 will only go up in value. I don't see this so much with the 6N's (maybe in another 10 years).

mk2/3 breddy , and i have a great one for sale , ...love to =keep it butm cant justify it

come and see ? x

The older the better. The worse the brakes the better. Manual steering is essential. The feeling of vulnerability is essential. You need your first car to teach you to respect the roads, and deter you from speed. It should be involving to drive, so you embrace a good driving attitude and deter yourself from developing arrogance.

But you don't seem to agree. You want comfort. You want a car that'll be easy to pilot fairly swiftly. I think this is wrong. So it's a matter of preference really.

Just consider this - the more effort you put into anything, the more reward you get out. That's a pretty universal aspect in life.

On my driveway sit two Polos, a '99 6n and an '85 MK2. At the same speeds, on the same roads, the MK2 is far more fun to drive than the 6n (better visibility makes it easier to park, too).

Absolutely agree

Also worth considering is that the mk2 will only go up in value. I don't see this so much with the 6N's (maybe in another 10 years).

I'm going to have to agree with Mikey too, my first car was a MK2 1.3 Golf.

Leaned like fck round every corner, and shortly after you could guarantee the front would be all over the place.

Brakes were useless and although it was almost completely rust free, I never fancied crashing it.

No air bags either of course.

It taught me to respect the roads a lot more than I would have done getting straight in to the 6N2 I have now. And I'm so glad I had it. I honestly believe I'm a better driver for it now - better than I would be if I'd had a 6N2 sooner.

It was a fun car to drive too, because it was so useless to handle. And it hasn't turned me into an old woman, I still have some fun driving, I just respect the roads much more now - like I drive "smarter".

HTH.

mk3 polo gt, job done

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.