Skip to content

mk2 polo what they like.on.fuel and.how.reliable

Featured Replies

Hey guys in.need.of.a bit.of.help.I'm looking to buy a mk2 polo saloon and I'm just wondering what they are like on fuel.its a 1.0 basically how many miles would i expect to get to £10 and how reliable are they had a 1.3 golf and that was a nightmare with the carb and it was very bad on juice any help.would be great

  • Replies 35
  • Views 5.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

mine was pretty crap, maybe 30mpg. suppose it totally depends on each engine and how its been maintained, best you can hope for really is about 40mpg.

Hi mate

Iv got a mk 2 1.0 4 speed, tbh its pretty bad on fuel, on average £20 at 128.7 a litre gets me about 120 miles. On the flip side of the coin its been very reliable even with the awful carb, obv early cold morning it runs a bit rough and normaly needs a few revs on start up to keep her going but its old lol.

Iv done 10,000 miles 7 months and its only let me down once when the clutch went, and that was my own fault.

Got mine with 65k on the clock with a complete history ( not vw but complete) up to Like 3 years before I got it, hadn't had a oil change since then lol as there was a hell of a lot of carbon lumps in the oil

Hi mate

Iv got a mk 2 1.0 4 speed, tbh its pretty bad on fuel, on average £20 at 128.7 a litre gets me about 120 miles.

People you still need to do your calculations before saying something is bad on fuel!

What you stated above works out at 35mpg which in all honesty I'd be happy with.

What my todays standards is below average if u ask me, my old shagged corsa done 45 in day to day driving and 56 at motorway speeds

The mk 2 can drive half a tank ( £20 ) in 100 miles if i don't drive it like a utter saint 100% of the time

Lol I will rewrite what I ment for the OP, its not great by todays standards but prob not much between it and you are old golf

Half a tank £20? Dream on! Run it properly dry and you'll need to pump over £50 quid back in

On original fuel system, bloody diabolical.

Terrible design of carb and inlet, result is poor economy thanks to an inconsistent fuel mixture and poor atomization. Plus poor reliability of the carb itself.

I converted to individual motorbike carbs, they've proven far more reliable with astonishing fuel economy for me, over several years and many tens of thousands of miles.

It does of course depend how you drive - it's an enjoyable car to drive yet it inspires you to take care and drive in a sensible manner.

its not so much the mpg is poor, its the fucking ridiculous cost of petrol. Average is £1.35 a litre round here (some places £1.40) so a tenner wont get you anywhere. Personally never put less than a score in because the amount the needle moves is depressing!

On original fuel system, bloody diabolical.

Terrible design of carb and inlet, result is poor economy thanks to an inconsistent fuel mixture and poor atomization. Plus poor reliability of the carb itself.

I converted to individual motorbike carbs, they've proven far more reliable with astonishing fuel economy for me, over several years and many tens of thousands of miles.

It does of course depend how you drive - it's an enjoyable car to drive yet it inspires you to take care and drive in a sensible manner.

Agree, see 40MPG all day long, £20 @ 1.33 is about 135 miles.

I'm pissing around with a pierburg on sister mk2 and frankly am half tempted to rip the lot out and bike carb it.

How easy is it to convert to bike carbs? what sort of cost is involved? I'm pulling 42mpg in my mk2 1.0 4 speed with 40k (cost me 100 quid :p) but want a good improvement! is it even possible??!

On original fuel system, bloody diabolical.

Terrible design of carb and inlet, result is poor economy thanks to an inconsistent fuel mixture and poor atomization. Plus poor reliability of the carb itself.

I converted to individual motorbike carbs, they've proven far more reliable with astonishing fuel economy for me, over several years and many tens of thousands of miles.

It does of course depend how you drive - it's an enjoyable car to drive yet it inspires you to take care and drive in a sensible manner.

On original, well maintained fuel system, spot on. My old 1.3 used to be well in the 40mpg's week in week out. The thing is, people expect a 30 year old carb that's never been serviced to work like a brand new fuel injection system.

40mpg is poor for a 1.3 8v (i saw more than that from the daily commute from a 1.6 16v on individual 36.5mm Keihins).

But it's all you'll get from a single-unit on a 4-1 manifold even if brand new, due to the various design flaws the factory cars had. Which is why they did no better.

40 round town, 45+ motorway made me :)

"Terrible design of carb and inlet, result is poor economy thanks to an inconsistent fuel mixture and poor atomization."

Motorbike style variable venturi (slide) carbs are definitely better than fixed choke progressives.

How much of MikeyMk's economy is due to his high compression ratio increasing volumetric efficiency?

But I'm not so sure about the 1-4 inlet manifold is rubbish argument.

Sufficiently heated distributing manifold there will be adequate emulsified fuel and air and cylinder pressure differences are averaged out, so yes one cylinder may be richer and one leaner than ideal

but surely less than a half of a percent. I agree more fuel will be consumed on overrun when 1 carb per cylinder would cut flow to idle for each, but only a few plenum volumes worth.

Distributing manifold can also exhibit intake pulse resonance -

where closing inlet valve before the compression stroke produced pressure wave reflects into opening valve of another cylinder on intake stroke.

eg

http://horsepowercalculators.net/intake-ma...manifold-design

(though that web page stupidly calls it supercharging)

I think the 1-3-4-2 firing order is not just for reducing vibration.

It makes more shorter paths between cylinders on their next intake stroke.

Anyway, enough of the theory - these are the VW published DIN 70030 fuel economy figures for Mk2 Polo's from 1988 in Litres per 100 km.

With Cat

Engine.................90km/h....120km/h....Urban

Carb

33kW 4 speed........5.7...........7.8........7.8

........5 speed.......5.7...........7.8........8.0

40kW 4 speed.......5.5...........7.4.........7.9

.........4+e............5.0...........6.9.........7.9

Injection

40kW 4 speed........5.7............7.8.........8.3

........4+e..............5.2............7.3.........8.3

Without Cat

Carb

33kW 4 speed........5.6...........7.6........7.6

.........5 speed.......5.6............7.6.......7.8

37&40kW 4 speed...5.4..........7.2.........7.7

..........4+e............4.9...........6.7........7.7

55kW 4 speed........5.3...........7.1........7.8

........5 speed........5.3...........7.1........8.0

Diesel

33kW 5 speed..........4.4...........6.4........6.1

Even the worst Urban measure is 34mpg and the best ignoring diesel (at constant 56mph) is 57mpg

Edited by dvderlm

A lot of people forget how squashy and expandable air is. Draw a bicycle pump forward and back, then do it with your finger over the valve, you still have most of the movement. This is of course, how the engine is varied in power ultimately - for a 1.4 engine, you have up to 1.4 litres to use, yet you usually only use about 500cc and never get to the full 1.4 litres because there will always be vacuum in the engine even with no air filter. This is relevant because a less restrictive inlet system reduces vacuum and let's you use more of the engine's cc's.

A 4-1 manifold is full of mixture at any point, it holds quite a lot in relation to a cylinder, and all that is open to any of the ports. So when you shut the throttle off completely, you still have nearly all that fuel and air available even to just one cylinder. This reflects how much excess you have to throw away everytime you restrict the throttle. It's effectively economy lag, and it happens regularly whilst driving.

This itself isn't the issue as such but leads me onto one - as the various cylinders suck at different times, you have fuel/air mixture literally being snatched from one part of the manifold to another. The chambers need to be narrow to keep the air speed right up, in order to help stop fuel falling out the air, which it inevitably does anyway during the process of trying to decide what cylinder to go to. This restricts the engine considerably at higher rpm.

Not that it was well mixed in the first place, due to the hosepipe-in-an-airduct design of the carb.. to be honest, the manifold probably does more to mix the fuel than the carb does!

Flat slide individual bike carbs have a surprisingly different process going on.

The automatically governing slides keep air speed at maximum at all times, yet with no inlet restriction. The fuel is blown off a fuel-coated pin instead of carried from the end of a pipe, so it's taken down in spray form. The air space is exclusive to one cylinder, doesn't need to travel as far, and so the chamber can be many times bigger and yet still suffer less expansion and drop losses, plus each cylinder enjoys exclusive dosing of this considerably better mixed fuel/air whether at very low or very high rpm.

Words are all very well, but in practice it's far more impressive.

^^^I'm just happy that it starts when I want it to and moves forward at various speeds when I press my right foot down. :lol:

Yeah i've found them utterly reliable for daily use all year round, engines starting in a second flat, with a balancing check-hone ideal every oil change. They need stainless pilot jet valves if you're gonna use them with E85 or cheap fuel containing ethanol, otherwise they corrode and seize up.

Note - do not fit carbs bigger than the inlet valve/s opening, otherwise the engine struggles to control the carbs properly - this is why people running 600s+ on a GT lump complain of poor economy etc.

That combined with the usual mistake of tuning them predominantly for performance. Get it right and it'll perform optimum anyway.

You forgot poor reliability as well.

The amount of complaints in regards to bike carbs being un-reliable on certain car forums is amazing.

In my experience, they've been a lot more reliable than the SPI system and at the moment about 2000% more reliable than the pierburg 1B on the mk2.

My mate ran a '77 Derby (you heard!) way back in the day, he reckoned on 30mpg and at least one trip under the bonnet to adjust the carb a week.

Just thinking about it, I don't think I have ever run a carb'd V-Dub....My mk III Golf 1.4 SE was injected, so was my 1.6 mk II driver (I'm pretty sure) and obv all my GTi's and the 3 Diseasels I have had were all injection motors!!

I have mk2f van..... A beasty 1.0 costs me 20quid to do 154 miles to my GF and back,mainly motorways,the needle drops faster than a cat on fire.. Gotta admit tho I owned it since may and only thing that went was gear linkage on way home from picking it up,bad fuel but reliable engine :)

The quanities are too small to be accurate really but assuming £1.35 a litre for 20 quid google calculator says you got an impressive

((20/1.35) litres) per (154 miles) = 47.2566251 miles per Imperial gallon

Needle drop speed is partly due to the tank shape.

"This itself isn't the issue as such but leads me onto one - as the various cylinders suck at different times, you have fuel/air mixture literally being snatched from one part of the manifold to another. The chambers need to be narrow to keep the air speed right up, in order to help stop fuel falling out the air, which it inevitably does anyway during the process of trying to decide what cylinder to go to. This restricts the engine considerably at higher rpm."

Found an interesting page on inlet manifold design with some formulae.

It appears to say that the snatched back and forwards mixture in a plenum can be used to advantage too

(acoustic supercharging or Helmholtz resonance) if the runner plus plenum are right length and volume.

And that tapering intake ram tubes also have an ideal length and diameter to set the torque peak.

Edited by dvderlm

I've got a 1.3 SPi ( mk3 ) soon to have fitter 4-2-1 stainless mani and straight through stainless .. I want to put a gt cam in and run it on bike carbs.. would 400's be fine and get them drilled out to ?? mm or would 600 carbs be ok .. bare with me I'm still learning on bike carbs etc :).. Also is there any bike to get them off as my bro's got a 97-98 ninja 400 and he might be breaking that :..

I've had 14 or 15 mk2 polos now. The only problem i ever had, Was when i fitted a weber following all the hype about them.

The float stuck shut and it wouldnt rev.

The pissburg carb is great when clean and set up.

People have to remember these carbs have seen 20 odd years of untouched abuse. The need a little attention after a while.

Its never taken me more than a quarter turn of a screw while using a c0 meter up the pipe.

Make sure its got a decent base gasket. Simple

Did that to all of mine and they ran perfect. Also damn good on fuel if you drive properly and look after the fuel /ignition system

I was able to touch 50mpg in my old 1043 5 speed bready on a run up to leeds from southampton once

(That trip also says something about reliabilty...)

I Drove that car to leeds and back twice, Once to manchester, Once to leeds then nottingham in one day,

and to london numerous times,

Never once broke down... Appart from that weber incident.. Luckily at the end of my road...

I towed a boat back from bristol with my 1.0 4 speed mk2 loon... That was still averaging around 30mpg iirc somehow.

Even earlier cars with solex carbs are fine, Just make sure the choke fully opens when you push the choke in otherwise youll be going down the road using far more fuel than you need to..

And carb mount gasket as allways.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.