Skip to content

Why a 3 Cylinder Unit?

Featured Replies

Hi,

A work colleague of mine has had use of a brand new Mk8, 1.2 3 pot, courtesy of the insurance company whilst the police try and find his Volvo.

He's not impressed with the general engine refinement and noise and having been in a couple myself (a 9n and 6r) I can't say I am either. Fine when your underway but acceleration is a bit coarse. I'd explained that it was due to it being a 3 cylinder and not the usual 4. He asked why they chose to make do with 3, but I couldn’t offer any real explanation.

This is where you come in! Does anyone know why VW went for 3 instead of 4? Is it simply a case of economics?

  • Replies 46
  • Views 4.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

It's entirely economy based. I quite like the grunt of a three-cylinder engine!

  • Author
It's entirely economy based.

In that a 3 is cheaper to make? Surely a development of existing units would have been better?

I assume he means mpg/road tax based

It's entirely economy based.

In that a 3 is cheaper to make? Surely a development of existing units would have been better?

No, fuel economy. Three cylinder engine is lighter in terms of weight, and it's also thriftier on fuel consumption. Both generations of the Polo Bluemotion have three cylinders. But because it's got three cylinders I guess it's not as balanced as a four cylinder engine, therefore you get more noise when you give it beans.

Cost wise I doubt it's much cheaper to make but having a three pot allows you to share the engine with new cars like the up! and the SEAT Mii and Skoda CitiGo which share the up!'s platform.

Ford is putting a 900cc three cylinder turbo into the Focus next year. 124bhp and better fuel consumption than an equivalent diesel, but without the toxic soot cloud. Being considered for the Mondeo and C-Max too, but it'll be a real giggle when it goes into the Fiesta and Ka. Renault is doing one too, which is going in the Megane.

You can get a two cylinder engine in the Fiat 500 (TwinAir), and Volkswagen is working on a four pot TSI with a cylinder cut off. Basically it'll be a two cylinder engine until you give it the beans, then the other two cylinders will cut in. Like a very small Hemi haha!

Edited by Alex

You have to bear in mind that the Polo is designed as a city car, especially with a tiny engine like that. It's not meant to be a high speed cruiser. Old Polos had four speed gearboxes which would've kerned their high speed refinement too (higher revs).

  • Author

mmm, interesting stuff.

I'd have thought that any fuel economy through adoption of a 3 cylinder would have been minimal. Excluding all other influences (like the car in which the engine is placed), surely cubic capacity and tune are the most influential? Put another way, would a 1.2 4 pot be significantly thirstier than a 3?

Obviously, if there is a physical limitation on the units' external size (i'm thinking VW Up! here) then a 3 pot makes sense.

You have to bear in mind that the Polo is designed as a city car, especially with a tiny engine like that. It's not meant to be a high speed cruiser. Old Polos had four speed gearboxes which would've kerned their high speed refinement too (higher revs).

Your telling me! To be honest, the latest ones are actually best at a constant high cruising speed (70). The regular bouts of acceleration in an urban environment only reinforce the coarseness under load due to an inherent imbalance.

Perhaps we have come full circle: the older 4 pots (like mine) are somewhat smoother but make themselves heard at speed through a lack of sufficient sound deadening. Now, we have good sound proofing but they're owt but smooth!

A 3 pot should be well balanced as each piston is mounted at 120 deg around the crank, rather than opposite each other in a 4 pot. I haven't driven a 3 cyl petrol, but i own a 3 cyl deisel, and although a oil burner, its refined and has good accel. My rents have a new 6r 1.4 tdi (same engine?) but they say that its not got the grunt of the 9n (it was their car before mine). Not sure why

mmm, interesting stuff.

I'd have thought that any fuel economy through adoption of a 3 cylinder would have been minimal. Excluding all other influences (like the car in which the engine is placed), surely cubic capacity and tune are the most influential? Put another way, would a 1.2 4 pot be significantly thirstier than a 3?

No but we're obsessed with carbon dioxide emissions in Europe. Launching an engine that saves fractions of a full mile per gallon can bring CO2 emissions down enough to drop it down a tax band, which in turn makes it cheaper to run as a private car (lower VED) as well as being cheaper if you're a company car driver (lower benefit in kind taxation).

I don't believe it makes that much difference. For example, I did a back to back test of a Skoda Fabia Greenline II and a Skoda Yeti Greenline II. The Yeti is a bigger car, it has a 1.6-litre TDI engine with four cylinders and 105bhp. The Fabia is smaller, has 75bhp and three cylinders (essentially it's 75% of the Yeti engine).

I do most of my driving at motorway speeds, and at that point the little Fabia engine is groaning like a good one while the Yeti's extra power is quite happy to haul it along. I averaged 53mpg over a week of use in the Fabia but 56mpg in the Yeti.

Why? Because these engines seem designed to get through the NEDC test cycle using as little fuel as possible and that's all manufacturers seem to care about. It doesn't always relate to real-world usage where a tiny engine will always be working harder to pull the same load. But people don't think like that, they just believe the book figures, and that's enough for manufacturers to think about.

A 3 pot should be well balanced as each piston is mounted at 120 deg around the crank, rather than opposite each other in a 4 pot. I haven't driven a 3 cyl petrol, but i own a 3 cyl deisel, and although a oil burner, its refined and has good accel. My rents have a new 6r 1.4 tdi (same engine?) but they say that its not got the grunt of the 9n (it was their car before mine). Not sure why

Like I say, just a guess. I've not really researched the reason but I'd assume a three cylinder engine would have an imbalance because of the odd number of pistons. Even with a balancer shaft you can't cancel that out completely.

Every single three cylinder engine I've tried has been raucous though, including the 1.2 TDI units in the new VAG cars. An extra cylinder seems to quieten it down. Kia Picanto being a prime example, the three cylinder roars hard under flat out acceleration but the more powerful 1.25 litre version is a much smoother sound.

If I had the choice, I'd always prefer a small but vocal three pot to a wheezy, small i4.

EDIT: Snarly Smart car:

Edited by Alex

the reason three pots are so coarse and have higher NVH levels is literally down to the fact that each bang is separated by 120 degrees so its in theory an extra thirty degrees between sparks hence the three cylinder thrum. you will often hear folk banging on about how smooth their old straight six bmw is and they are right as its only 60 degrees between each. the more sparks in the same time makes it feel more continuous and hence smoother. this may not have made sense, I am very tired.

Yep, makes sense. Though I've always lumped a straight six in the same group as an inline four. They've got pairs of pistons to cancel each other out. As I say, not an expert on that side of things.

the straight six is smoother still which is why the folk at auto express in an article i read today made a fuss about the new base model z4 having a 2l i4 instead of a straight six they just tend to be smoother and of course still shows in luxury cars still having V engines and fisker having a hard time about the harshness of the four pot used to charged the batteries in the Karma.

Keen top gear viewers will remember rowan atkinson talking about the V16 rolls made for the phantom, having the pistons 22.5 degrees apart, that is the only reason it was made, because it was silky smooth. it definitely isn't economical, fast, cheap to make, cheap to service etc. they settled for the BMW V12 because it was slightly more cost effective (being lifted from the 760i)

Ha, well obviously a straight six is going to be smoother than a four cylinder, I just meant I assumed it was that way because (like a four cylinder engine) it's balanced while rotating because each piston has a matching partner which balances it out.

A three cylinder engine hasn't got this balance, and neither does a five cylinder engine, which is pretty raucous too (even the diesels - Volvo D5 sounds brilliant on kick-down). So regardless of the rotational balance of the engine, they're always going to be slightly imbalanced, causing more vibration and in turn noise than an even number of pistons.

And I agree about harshness from going down to four cylinder engines. Buyers are downsizing in great numbers at the moment, and manufacturers are fitting them to cars they seem unnatural in (which they have to, or they'll lose sales). Mercedes offers a 2.2 I4 across its rear-drive cars, including the S-Class, and has just fitted it to the ML-Class. Jaguar, too, they've just put one in the XF. BMW is shifting its 520d en masse to the corporate sector. And that's just a sample.

Despite what they say though, and despite how quiet the four cylinder engines are, it's just not as smooth as a six cylinder engine.

I wouldn't know from experience. biggest engined car I have ever driven was a 2.2 Solex carbed Volvo 244, Mustard yellow it were.

Retro-tastic!

chocolate brown interior. but being a 20 year old who has only had polo's limits my experience somewhat the volvo and a LHD mazda miata turbo are the only RWD cars i've driven. all this theory is down to my motorsport degree.

Less cylinders = less frictional + less pumping losses.

Less cylinders = less frictional + less pumping losses.

indeed, but a loss in smoothness.

I've driven a few 3 pot cars, my Mum has a 3 pot Mitsubishi Colt and it gives a very rough noise on acceleration and isn't the smoothest car to be in on idle.

I just don't think they are right and I personally would avoid a 3 pot.

However the funniest experiance I've had in one was in a Chevvy Matiz 3 pot, think it was an 800cc weapon.

I removed the airbox from it and I can't describe the induction sound it made after.

Sounded like something much bigger and faster than what it actually was, almost made driving it enjoyable.

If petrol was cheaper I'd much rather have a 6 pot, had a variety over the years from straight 6's to V6's and I much prefer the smoothness, noise and power delivery over a conventional inline 4. But as times are tight I'm stuck with the 4 pots for now.

The only 3 cylinder I've ever driven was the Ecotec Corsa C I learnt to drive in, so obviously I never got to open it up, but I swear to god I hated that car. Just generally sounded strained as soon as things went past like 1.5/2k rpm. I think literally every other car bar the one below I've driven has been an I4.

My dad's got a late 70's Chevrolet Camaro with the 5.7 pushrod V8 under the bonnet. Now that thing sounds rough. Sounds like it's going to stall at tickover.

Just remember,4 cylinders, 4 strokes. Every time a cylinder fires, another cylinder just has to compress the fuel and fire: hence the smoothness.

The way i think of it, a three cylinder 1200 has more torque because every time one of its cylinders fires, it is doing so in 400cc.

Whereas a four cylinder 1200 is combusting a 300cc cylinder.

This theory only works when revs are low and each cylinder can be looked at independently.

When up to speed i believe the four cylinder revs harder because there is less reciprocating weight.

I quite like the idea of a three cylinder, or even a twin. That would be cool (Fiat TwinAir)

Only a theory haha someone correct me if they want!

speaking of the twinair, did you know that both pistons rise and fall in unison.

Yeah, we've discussed this before!

If they weren't in unison the firing wouldn't be very smooth. And they just have a big balnce shaft on the crank!

Cool idea, Bring out the single cylinders!

A 3 pot should be well balanced as each piston is mounted at 120 deg around the crank, rather than opposite each other in a 4 pot. I haven't driven a 3 cyl petrol, but i own a 3 cyl deisel, and although a oil burner, its refined and has good accel. My rents have a new 6r 1.4 tdi (same engine?) but they say that its not got the grunt of the 9n (it was their car before mine). Not sure why

maybe its because the 6r is slightly heavier than the 9n because of whats on it, i.e the daytime running lamps, auto wipers, front end of a golf

Cool idea, Bring out the single cylinders!

Everyone loves a thumper..

374329_240402149348322_213642845357586_5

This one's gonna be a little special though :-D

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.