Skip to content

Why a 3 Cylinder Unit?

Featured Replies

A 3 pot should be well balanced as each piston is mounted at 120 deg around the crank, rather than opposite each other in a 4 pot. I haven't driven a 3 cyl petrol, but i own a 3 cyl deisel, and although a oil burner, its refined and has good accel. My rents have a new 6r 1.4 tdi (same engine?) but they say that its not got the grunt of the 9n (it was their car before mine). Not sure why

maybe its because the 6r is slightly heavier than the 9n because of whats on it, i.e the daytime running lamps, auto wipers, front end of a golf

As far as i know the 6r is actually lighter as the 9N was a heavy car. The 6r only has 1.6 and 1.2 diesel engines theres not a 1.4 one. The 6r diesels have 4 valves per cyliner rather than the 2 per cylinder which the 9n had so id imagine the 9N has more torque thus why it most proably feels faster

  • Replies 46
  • Views 4.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

As far as i know the 6r is actually lighter as the 9N was a heavy car. The 6r only has 1.6 and 1.2 diesel engines theres not a 1.4 one. The 6r diesels have 4 valves per cyliner rather than the 2 per cylinder which the 9n had so id imagine the 9N has more torque thus why it most proably feels faster

Correct - the new Polo is at least 100kg lighter than the old one comparing as close to like with like. The entry level models are under 1000kg.

on a par with 6n's and 6n2's

Sorry, the 6r is a 1.2. However, my dad just says it has a 'flat spot' on take off, not that it's slow. Wasn't aware of the difference in valves.

The theory behind 3 cylinders being rough sounds sound as well

A 3 pot should be well balanced as each piston is mounted at 120 deg around the crank, rather than opposite each other in a 4 pot. I haven't driven a 3 cyl petrol, but i own a 3 cyl deisel, and although a oil burner, its refined and has good accel. My rents have a new 6r 1.4 tdi (same engine?) but they say that its not got the grunt of the 9n (it was their car before mine). Not sure why

It's not just first order harmonics, it's second order too.

3 Cyl have automatically 75% of the frictional losses of a 4 Cyl regarding valvetrain, and you can also downsize items like the oil pump, water pump etc- all helps towards a more efficient engine.

Alex has the nail on the head with OEMs designing cars to pass cycles, the levels of NOX recorded in most urban areas, doesn't correlate at all well with emissions cycle data, but a vehicle that is good say on a real world cycle (Artemis) might be poor on a european drive cycle.

You can't say a 3 cyl has more torque than a 4 cyl, that's basically saying an apple is bigger than an orange...

The market is heavily shifting to downsizing and heavily boosted motors- which is good! More technology, more efficient, and more fun!

downsizing confuses most people, for example skoda now offer a 1.2 Octavia. most will laugh and say thats not enough for a car that size but it will do 120MPH and 0-60 in under 11 seconds, not going to set the world alight but its respectable especially for a 1.2!

Hence why a lot of manufacturers talk about their cars in terms of horsepower (well, pferdestarke) not engine size. Volkswagen lists both on its price lists now, I think it'll take a few years for people to accept the idea of a 1.2-litre large car. But 105bhp isn't far off what you were getting in a 1.8-litre engine not so long ago.

And Renault, for example. If you bought a Scenic this time last year with a dCi 130 engine, you'd be getting a car with a 1.9-litre engine. If you buy one now you'll get a car with a 1.6-litre engine, and paying more for it. Sounds like a rip off until you realise that you're getting a vastly more superior small engine that offers the same power, more torque and a large drop in fuel consumption and CO2 emissions.

And the 110bhp 1.6 petrol engine in the Megane will be replaced with a turbocharged 1.2 later this year.

I'll be interested to see how people get on with the idea of a 900cc three-cylinder Mondeo when that eventually hits the market. It's coming! Focus next summer, then B and C Max late in 2012, and I'd imagine you'll see it slotted into the Mondeo the year afterwards.

what I can't wait for is the 800cc two cylinder turbodiesel hybrid that is the VW XL1. 313 mpg! 8-)

Edited by leonh

I've driven or had most of the cars with the engines mention here.

9n3 with a 1.2 petrol, dam that things noisey, it sounds like a oil-burner, wasnt terribly slow.

3 bmws with the 2.0 stright six, now thats a smooth engine, although it takes alot to get going.

1 bmw with the 1.9 IS (m44), great engine but noticablty less smooth than the 6 pots.

V6 Mistu FTO, Not great smothness, and usualy loud due to the manual tappets. makes an epic noise though, and 180bhp from a 2.0 N/A in the mid 90s was very good.

By far the smoothest engine I've had is the volvos 5 cylinder 10v, I swear the thing runs on lube, its now dead though down to the shitty ignition system they put on them. Probably not so smooth now its in cube form.

Edited by mattpolo5491

I cant wait, in a few years these tiny but powerful engines will be available to put in my mk2! :)

And as some are turbo'd there will be boost to play with.

Less cylinders = less frictional + less pumping losses.

indeed, but a loss in smoothness.

On top of this I imagine in standard form a 3cyl probably has more torque.

Hence why a lot of manufacturers talk about their cars in terms of horsepower (well, pferdestarke) not engine size. Volkswagen lists both on its price lists now, I think it'll take a few years for people to accept the idea of a 1.2-litre large car. But 105bhp isn't far off what you were getting in a 1.8-litre engine not so long ago.

And Renault, for example. If you bought a Scenic this time last year with a dCi 130 engine, you'd be getting a car with a 1.9-litre engine. If you buy one now you'll get a car with a 1.6-litre engine, and paying more for it. Sounds like a rip off until you realise that you're getting a vastly more superior small engine that offers the same power, more torque and a large drop in fuel consumption and CO2 emissions.

And the 110bhp 1.6 petrol engine in the Megane will be replaced with a turbocharged 1.2 later this year.

I'll be interested to see how people get on with the idea of a 900cc three-cylinder Mondeo when that eventually hits the market. It's coming! Focus next summer, then B and C Max late in 2012, and I'd imagine you'll see it slotted into the Mondeo the year afterwards.

Well our old 207sw had the 1.6 litre diesel engine, and i wasn't impressed. Had a 405 1.9td a few years ago and that was far better. Now i know it seems an odd comparison but the 207 was heavier than the 405! So engine wise, not so unfair. The 207 needed the 2.0.

The 1.6 did pull well for a very limited time - but only on optimum boost. Like between 3.5-4.5krpm. Which was near useless most of the time.

And this is my concern with these tiny turbo engines. The japanese were using them in small cars years ago and didn't bother using them in larger cars. Why? I think because a 900cc Mondeo is gonna look impressive on paper with it's figures, but in practice it'll be crap.

you sure its not because there is tax breaks in japan if you own a car that is of small dimensions and has a 660cc or smaller engine limited to 64hp (Kei Car)? thats why they didn't fit them to larger cars because there would be no benefit. and besides that was using conventional tech, engine technology has come on quite abit considering Kei cars use basic engine tech with a turbo added. these Ecoboost engines are cleverly designed from the outset to produce good torque and power efficiently. they aren't gonna set the world on fire but will replace the 1.6.

Edited by leonh

And are you sure the tiny engines coming to big cars now aren't gonna be for taxation reasons too?

The jap engines weren't so far developed, for one because it was the '90s and for seconds because they met the criteria you rightly say they needed to.

You might find the whole smaller engine might not all be down to environmental reasons be something to do with road safety as well.

Tax banding was introduced for eco reasons but underlying it meant people buying smaller engines to save the cost of the higher tax.

Technically speaking the fastest legal speed is 70 (currently) but most cars on the market are capable of speeds almost double that but a Big car with 900cc engine isnt going have a high top speed or fast acceleration which should mean slower road speeds that should equal less road accidents.

(Yes i know that speed is only a small factor in accidents but that's not how the government think)

Car manufacturers are not so interested in making fun exciting cars since government have been breathing down their necks with all their emissions bullcrap.

I personally don't have an opinion on these small engines going into big cars. I don't think anyone can really say what is going to happen in the next 10 years. I mean go back to the early/mid 90's... if you told someone back then that more people would be running diesels than petrol, and that some diesels would even be getting 0-60mph in less than 8 seconds, they would most likely tell you to stop being and idiot looser and to stop talking nonsense.

So who knows where we will be in another 10 or 20 years. Whos to say we will be using internal combustion engines? things have moved on so fast in the last 20 years that its almost impossible to say what the future holds for cars and driving. We could all be in hydrogen fuel cell powered cars! (Not that likely because, even though its old tech, the govt and oil companies most likely wont allow it. Just think how much it would cost them for us to have clean, reliable, FREE fuel)

We could all be in hydrogen fuel cell powered cars! (Not that likely because, even though its old tech, the govt and oil companies most likely wont allow it. Just think how much it would cost them for us to have clean, reliable, FREE fuel)

Or maybe we aren't in fuel cell cars because currently the energy density of compressed hydrogen is poor, even when compared to lithium iron batteries. Car the size of a Mondeo with a range of 200 miles, two seats and space for an apple. Any takers?

Engine downsizing is great up to a point, as long as the torque curve's nice and flat and is comparable to the larger lump it's replacing - then what's not to like? Though I do think there'll continue to be some right snotters put into production just to fill particular tax brackets. The VW 1.4TFSI lump is an example of downsizing done correctly - it works on paper and in practice. Mondeo 1.6TDI is the opposite - works on paper, but is not great on the road.

And this is my concern with these tiny turbo engines. The japanese were using them in small cars years ago and didn't bother using them in larger cars. Why? I think because a 900cc Mondeo is gonna look impressive on paper with it's figures, but in practice it'll be crap.

No- because emissions regulations didn't stipulate the requirement for them, hence little financial point investing in technologies to push the smaller unit up to the performance level of a larger engine, without the emissions handicap.

Matt- OEMs still make fun cars, but at the end of the day, crash regulations, emissions, and general sales (lets face it hardly any 18-26yr olds are going to buy a fun, new car with a list price of £35k+) funnel them towards making 'generic' vehicles, so the company can stay alive. Boring, yes, necessary, yes!

you sure its not because there is tax breaks in japan if you own a car that is of small dimensions and has a 660cc or smaller engine limited to 64hp (Kei Car)? thats why they didn't fit them to larger cars because there would be no benefit. and besides that was using conventional tech, engine technology has come on quite abit considering Kei cars use basic engine tech with a turbo added. these Ecoboost engines are cleverly designed from the outset to produce good torque and power efficiently. they aren't gonna set the world on fire but will replace the 1.6.

And it's not only petrol engines that they could replace, it's diesels too.

Diesels produce less CO2 but they're not environmentally friendly engines, per se. They produce a shit load of smog and actual pollutants (CO2 isn't a pollutant) and have a negative effect on air quality compared to an equivalent petrol engine.

And they're only really popular in Europe. Asia, America and Australia are all petrol-heavy markets and don't buy diesels because their focus is on air quality not CO2.

Plus of course a diesel engine is expensive, and they'll get moreso. We've got Euro6 emissions standards to come in 2015, and that'll mean adding after-treatment (such as AdBlue) or additional filters to diesel engines, which will in turn potentially bump up the price of buying a diesel powered car compared to a petrol.

Diesel is already quite a lot more expensive, per litre, than petrol, and as petrol cars become more efficient then it takes more and more miles before you'll make up the difference in price between a diesel and petrol engine. Particularly for the corporate sector where you'll pay 3% more tax for diesel engine even compared to a petrol unit with exactly the same CO2 emissions.

What I'm saying is small petrol engines are a decent alternative to diesels because they're kinder to the environment, have a broader market appeal globally and they're starting to make business sense too.

You might find the whole smaller engine might not all be down to environmental reasons be something to do with road safety as well.

Tax banding was introduced for eco reasons but underlying it meant people buying smaller engines to save the cost of the higher tax.

Technically speaking the fastest legal speed is 70 (currently) but most cars on the market are capable of speeds almost double that but a Big car with 900cc engine isnt going have a high top speed or fast acceleration which should mean slower road speeds that should equal less road accidents.

(Yes i know that speed is only a small factor in accidents but that's not how the government think)

That's a very limited view. These days a car has to be able to handle everything from heavily rutted British country roads to the glass-smooth German autobahns. So yes, while the speed limit here is low, they do need to be able to handle sustained sessions in triple figures. And they're as capable, if not moreso, in some cases than a bigger naturally aspirated old engine.

Tax globally is based on efficiency, but with us we've focussed on CO2 which has made diesels much cheaper to run. But petrol-focussed markets like America and Japan are getting pinched by eco-taxes and drivers are being forced into smaller engines, plus fuel costs are rising everywhere.

The 1.0-litre Ford EcoBoost engine is half the size of a 2.0-litre engine in a Mk1 Focus, but puts out the same power. It's not a safety issue.

Mondeo 1.6TDI is the opposite - works on paper, but is not great on the road.

Yep, catch it off boost and suddenly you realise it's a tiny diesel engine in a HUGE car. But if you can keep the rev needle pointing upwards it's not bad all things considered. Not considerably more efficient than a less burdened 2.0-litre diesel though.

Edited by Alex

True, but it does mean you start pulling away like a saxo driver so you don't get T-boned at roundabouts while you're pulling away in lag land.

Glad all of the 1.6 HDI/TDCI's I've driven have been hire cars :lol:

True, but it does mean you start pulling away like a saxo driver so you don't get T-boned at roundabouts while you're pulling away in lag land.

Glad all of the 1.6 HDI/TDCI's I've driven have been hire cars :lol:

I found myself trying to avoid stopping at roundabouts - it's doable, but it did catch me out. You get that odd moment where you assume, as it's a Mondeo, that it's got a 2.0-litre diesel engine and end up in the wrong gear.

petrols are way cleaner like you say its the NOx that diesels pump out that are the issue hence the particulate filters and so on but with the gap in price between diesel and petrol more and more cars are becoming unlikely to save you money with diesel I remember about 5 years back Top gear Mag said that if you were to buy a 535d over a 535i you would never make the money back on the purchase and higher cost of fuel. I feel a lot more diesels are that way now.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.